News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by kragen on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:49AM (#16568927)
Hard to tell, but it sounds like they're 3-D printing the building envelope, minus vapor barriers and whatnot. But nowadays the envelope is not the expensive part of a building, although it is the most visible. Plumbing, electrical, HVAC, floor finishing, decor, and so on accounts for most of the building cost. For some reason they aren't mentioned in the story, probably because nobody has a credible automation approach to them yet.

If you want to reduce the cost of the building envelope, possibly superadobe, shotcrete on airforms, ferrocrete, and flexible domes are better bets than 3-D printing of concrete. (The geodesic dome was conceived specifically as a solution to this problem, but I'm not convinced it actually does a good job at it.)

What's the current solution these things are competing with? Here in Argentina, the standard low-cost construction approach in the villas miserias is masonry with hollow bricks (18×33 cm), which cost 50¢. So a 6m×6m×3m building envelope requires about 1200 bricks, costing US$600 (AR$12000) if you buy them new instead of scavenging, plus some mortar and a corrugated-metal roof, which add a bit to the cost. It takes several days or even, at times, weeks to finish the construction; usually the family who live there build the house themselves, which is less of an opportunity cost than it sounds like with the unemployment rate as high as it is, especially among youth. Some families pour concrete slabs, others use dirt floors.

So, roughly speaking, this approach has to come down in cost by 10× to even compete with our current vernacular architecture, let alone improve on its pricing.

The concrete-3-D-printing approaches I've seen, like Andrey Rudenko's https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQ5Elbvvr1M, all share the drawback that they require a long time, because you have to wait for the lower layers of the construction to cure a bit before you can add more layers. Their big advantage is not that they're cheaper than pouring concrete into forms — although they may be, especially if you're building a large building or a dense construction — but that they have a lot of freedom of geometry.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by kiliantics on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:00PM (#16568998)
Not to mention the cost of the land...

Short of a radical change in how our society works, the only realistic solution to homelessness is going to have to be some kind of decent social housing. Maybe it will somehow be cheaply 3D-printed but the government is going to have to buy the land first. (That, or stop making it exclusive to the rich.) Access to land was the original problem here (since Enclosure Acts) and it has to be part of the solution.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by idrios on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:08PM (#16570093)
In the last few years I've lived in Cleveland OH (5 years in college), Denver CO / Colorado Springs (3 months), and San Jose / SF Bay area (1 year). All 3 of these places had homelessness issues and the root causes were very different in each.

In Cleveland, the homeless seemed to be mostly folks who grew up in low-income neighborhoods (median reported household income $14,000 [1]) from very broken families, who find themselves adults with few skills no motivation to help themselves because they've never known what hope is.

Homelessness in Colorado seemed to stem more from veterans with PTSD who can't hold down a job, or those with other forms of disabilities.

Homelessness in the SF Bay area was the most confusing to me. I met people there who could've been myself in 10 years, but they were homeless or had once been homeless just because they couldn't afford a place to live there. I don't know if this area just lacks housing or if it attracts the homeless but I know for certain that being homeless here is nothing like being homeless in Cleveland.

It's really not a one-size-fits-all problem.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hough%2C_Cleveland I'm using this neighborhood as an example because I used to volunteer at a school here, but there are many neighborhoods like it.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by harlanji on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:43PM (#16570349)
Similar bg: Minneapolis, short time in Denver, probable lifer in BA (currently by the beach in Sunset SF where vagrants abound).

It’s just too nice here to leave, even with offers of couches in swank condos in other cities. Wealthy vs. poor, the BA has endless amenities to cultivate the former. Housing is a nice feature. I am literally teetering on the edge, rent 6-7wk late and without real food for weeks (in comm w landlord + 24lbs of Huel stocked and 2x all my products). I’ll move into my car if I lose my appt. I’ve a YT channel/vlog documenting the plight to poverty in SF, “iSpooge Daily” channel.

My answer to why is that SFers are aggressively passive, and quick to call abberant behavior any label that kinda fits (“worst possible explanation”) which creats a class of people who can comfortably be treated sub-human. I’ve always remained open to chatting with sober houseless folk, and indeed it could be anyone. I know some guy who’s slept in the same doorways with his cats for all yea years I’ve been in SF while I’ve been pushed around. Makes me question who’s homeless.

Green Day was OG from Oakland, their song Android has stuck with me and I’ve come to resonate with this part strongly “hey old man in woman’s shoes / I wonder if he knows I think he’s crazy / when he was young did he have dreams of / wearing woman’s shoes and being crazy” — in truth the crazies are reacting pretty reasonably to their conditions of sub-human treatment and filth. If not for my long term communities and in-tact families and skills, it’d be a lot harder to keep it together mentally. It’s the sense of hope as I’ve never asked for much, thankfully good will and faith etc has life rafts float up as needed.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by bsder on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:05PM (#16570496)
> Homelessness in the SF Bay area was the most confusing to me. I met people there who could've been myself in 10 years, but they were homeless or had once been homeless just because they couldn't afford a place to live there.

Mental illness and drugs (which really should probably be folded into mental illness) is actually a bigger factor.

1) Saint Reagan (/s) dismantled a bunch of the infrastructure to help those with mental illness in the name of, say it with me now, "Efficiency of the private sector". Consequently, the mentally ill wind up on the streets or in jail--neither of which is actually a good solution. We've only had about 5 years since removing most of the nitwits from the state legislature/Congress (the jungle primaries and redistricting commission have been in effect since 2010 and it flushed most of the Republican nitwits--and Mueller may get the remaining ones), and building/fixing takes more time than dismantling.

2) It also didn't help that some places were actually busing in their mentally ill population to San Francisco.

3) San Francisco weather doesn't kill people. Morbidly, being sufficiently mentally ill in, say, Pittsburgh or Cleveland, probably kills you in winter (and possibly summer).

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by dragonwriter on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:33PM (#16570733)
> Saint Reagan (/s) dismantled a bunch of the infrastructure to help those with mental illness in the name of, say it with me now, "Efficiency of the private sector".

De-institutionalizing the mentally ill was broadly supported across the political spectrum; the institutionalized system was both ineffective and often inhumane.

That both community mental health treatment and poverty support was and remains inadequate are problems, and de-institutionalization certainly highlighted those problems, but let's not create a false historical narrative that de-institutionalization was a policy forced on the country by one political faction.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by Turing_Machine on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:25PM (#16570664)
> Saint Reagan (/s) dismantled a bunch of the infrastructure to help those with mental illness in the name of, say it with me now, "Efficiency of the private sector".

"Saint Reagan" hasn't been President for about 30 years, and hasn't been governor of California for about 40. Perhaps it's time to stop blaming him for things?

Why didn't Saints Clinton and Obama (on the national level) or Saints Brown, Davis, or Brown II: Electric Boogaloo (on the state level) fix these problems?

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by Turing_Machine on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:46PM (#16573018)
> building/fixing takes more time than dismantling.

It doesn't take 40 years more time.

The Democrats have controlled both chambers of the California Assembly since 1959 (except for two short periods from 1969-1971 and 1994-1996) and have controlled the governorship several times in that period.

But yeah, the California homeless situation is still totally the fault of Reagan, who hasn't been governor of California for 40 years. Totally.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by TylerE on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:08PM (#16570519)
I think a big draw for homelessness in SF specifically is the abnormally mild and consistent climate. It rarely gets colder than 45F, or warmer than 90F.
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by baybal2 on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:03PM (#16572483)
America is not an undeveloped nation, yet it still has homelessness. This does not bode with peace in my mind.
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by RobertRoberts on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:16AM (#16575215)
I lived on the streets when I was a teen. Many people start off there because it's safer than being at home. Not an easy problem to solve, and has nothing to do with how developed the nation is.
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by kiliantics on Monday March 12, 2018 @04:42PM (#16571407)
There might be many ways in which people fall below the threshold of being able to afford housing. But the fact is that they can't afford it. The government tends to support landowners in keeping land value high and letting them build luxury housing on it to make more money on rent/speculation, rather than making it possible for everyone to afford housing.
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by RobertRoberts on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @07:12AM (#16575196)
Do a search for land/housing, you can buy a ton of it in rural places for pennies compared to areas like San Francisco. But I think SF is expensive just from market forces alone.

Example:

Right now on Zillow.com, there appear to be 735 houses for sale at $50k or less in Iowa alone. (this is not auctions or forclusures either)

https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/IA/fsba,fsbo,new_lt/ho...

These aren't cramped dinky places, these are full multi-bedroom homes with land. And this is one single state.

The issue isn't land, space or housing, it's jobs, knowledge and opportunity. (and I am sure other social dynamics...)

Edit: I did not verify pricing, so who knows how many are bait-and-switches... but it's still a high number to start with.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by joe_the_user on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:31PM (#16570723)
In the last few years I've lived in Cleveland OH (5 years in college), Denver CO / Colorado Springs (3 months), and San Jose / SF Bay area (1 year). All 3 of these places had homelessness issues and the root causes were very different in each.

Claims about homelessness having multiple root causes have always seemed flawed to me. I would claim the root cause is the lack of supply of houses at a price people can afford.

It's not this root cause that varies from location to location, it's the particular way it manifests that varies from place to place.

IE, a relative shortage of housing prevails everywhere, both places with depressed economies and places with active economies. This shortage means those with low skills can't and don't think of leaving depressed areas for greener pastures and even those with high skills wind-up homeless in the areas of high economic activity - and note that the experience of homelessness can "break" people through deprivation and anxiety, leading the "temporarily homeless" to winding-up looking more like the "hardcore homeless".

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by bluGill on Monday March 12, 2018 @06:03PM (#16572103)
I know somebody too mentally ill to keep up a house. Even if you gave him a million dollars and a free place to live, in just a few years it would not be inhabitable because he doesn't have the mental ability to think about getting anything broken fixed.
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by michaelbuckbee on Monday March 12, 2018 @04:52PM (#16571503)
You make some good points, the problem with 3D Printing houses, shotcrete and some of these other methods is that they cost less in the US where labor costs are high and more in 3rd world countries where labor costs are lower (at least for the types of homes things like this are trying to disrupt).

A really interesting alternative approach is earth bag building. It uses locally available dirt as a material and would generally work out to be even less than the brick building price you estimated.

Here's a family putting up a 30' diameter building out of earthbags: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m5Xl8f2J3sY&t=130s

It is _very_ labor intensive and as you said, it needs time to dry between courses.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by nkoren on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:32PM (#16570276)
> this approach has to come down in cost by 10× to even compete with our current vernacular architecture, let alone improve on its pricing.

I'd like to be wrong, but that seems like a kill shot to me. Not only does the new system need to be objectively competitive with the vernacular, but it needs to be so much better that it can overcome the myriad cultural and institutional inertias which have hitherto kept the vernacular locked in place.

Which is why this is a Hard Problem. I doubt that 3D printing alone can solve it. Would love to be pleasantly surprised, however.

Also, thrilled to see another superadobe shoutout on HN!

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by baybal2 on Monday March 12, 2018 @06:54PM (#16572442)
It is technically possible to do a very basic bungalow from prefab panels if you really really want to for under $1000 in a low income country.

This will be a much bigger change to people whose only other alternative is a carton box.

But I do not see this being a solution. Affordability of housing in developing nations is rarely comes as a number one issue, it is almost always comes after ruined economies, and disfunctional basic civic/municipal institutes: it is no use building those things in countries where a person will never ever earn even those USD $10k.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by baybal2 on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:12PM (#16572531)
Prefab panel buildings simply beat every alternative for moderately comfortable, entry level housing from single family to low-rise.

If the goal is simply to transform a slum into something less of a slum. There are no better alternatives if any much big economy of scale be realized for the project.

Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by petra on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:03PM (#16569030)
This $600 house in Argentina sounds interesting. How much does the land cost?
Re:Cheap 3D-printed home is a start for the 1B who lack shelter by kragen on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:09PM (#16569078)
That is a very complicated question, because typically in the villas miserias the people who build houses do not have any officially recognized title to the land. They may or may not have paid protection money to a local gang for a title, but these are not officially recognized. They may end up paying for the land several times over the years, or not at all, and they may end up being evicted from the land — sometimes with bulldozers — despite having paid someone for it.

On one occasion a few years back, some crackheads who had started building a villa near Ecovillage Velatropa stabbed one of the Velatropans, shortly after allegedly setting fire to one of their outhouses. The Velatropans called the police, who evicted the crackheads and the mentally ill man who had invited them to move in. The next couple of weeks, the Velatropans stood 24-hour guard to ensure that the crackheads did not return. One night I calmed down an extremely excited Cuban who was running to get the village machete — he thought he had spotted one of the crackheads hiding in a tree. By the time we returned in a group to chase the crackhead off, he could not be found.

Velatropa itself is built on a site that previously housed the "villa gay", where a group of some 300 people, initially transgender prostitutes, had lived before being ejected en masse with a judicial order in 1998. The city paid to house them in a hotel thereafter — but only for a week. I don't think the "villa gay" was bulldozed until shortly afterwards, but none of its buildings remained when I started going to Velatropa around 2008.

So the answer to your question is not as simple as a range of numbers of dollars or pesos per square meter. I think it's better understood as an ongoing social process of negotiation of land tenure, among whose elements may or may not be quitclaim deeds, warranty deeds, and fee-simple title.