News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:23AM (#16567950)
OP here (shocked to see this on HN):

The context is missing but is important. When I say MOOCs have failed I mean something very specific: asynchronous online learning has proven to be so dramatically less effective than synchronous, guided learning. Better than nothing existing, but we’re learning that only a small subset of people are able to effectively learn from them.

In other words, take a random sample of 100 people with the same level of motivation. 90% will complete a live, guided course. 5% will complete a MOOC of the same quality. Which is unfortunate because the live/synchronous part is what is expensive.

There was a time when we thought all education was is just a bunch of video lectures, and that if we got a bunch of professors to record their lectures college would be free.

We now know that doesn’t work, at least for the vast, vast majority of people, both because we’re unable to discipline ourselves and because most true learning happens in a multi-way environment with accountability measures.

Re:Surprising Things About School by kbutler on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:46AM (#16568082)
How are you measuring the same level of motivation?

From my anecdotal experience, the people taking the "live, guided course" have committed to:

  - synchronous attendance at a particular time, probably at a particular place
  - probably a dollar investment
  - face-to-face contact with instructor
  - near-traditional learning environment
People taking a MOOC have committed to:

  - browsing on an electronic device
There's generally a really high barrier to entry to the synchronous, guided learning, so it seems like comparing students who have paid tuition and enrolled in a class vs prospective students expressing interest on a university recruitment page.
Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:55AM (#16568132)
There have been quite a few studies that have done this in a scientific manner.

Internally we have taken sets of students that apply to our free “mini code bootcamp” and sent half to an archived version published each night and send the other half a live link that becomes an archive each night. So we didn’t control scientifically, jsut an AB test, but the shift has been breathtaking.

We can also take students that are struggling learning from our MOOCs and they finish the live course almost every time. I know the latter is unscientific, but it becomes obvious over time.

Re:Surprising Things About School by kbutler on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:33AM (#16568337)
This Harvard study & Atlantic article by the study authors give the same 5% completion rate you cited, but give a completely opposite interpretation: basically, that the MOOC broadened access, allowing more people to get what they wanted out of the course.

https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/01/the-tr...

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2381263

"In these course[sic], “dropping out” is not a breach of expectations but the natural result of an open, free, and asynchronous registration process, where students get just as much as they wish out of a course and registering for a course does not imply a commitment to completing it."

...

Also the discussion of the "Colbert Bump", where increased publicity to less-motivated (just curious) students doubled completion but tripled registration (thus reducing completion rate).

Also the point about whether to allow or disallow registration after the course begins (late registrants are ineligible for certification, so they are automatically "failed").

"HarvardX could boost its certification rate by closing those courses to new registrants or restrict courses to those most likely to complete them. Instead, it keeps courses open to maximize the number of students who are learning something new."

I absolutely agree that (at least some) users can be helped by live instruction or supplemented online instruction, but I disagree that commonly cited, low completion rates measure students with the "same level of motivation".

Re:Surprising Things About School by randomdata on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:20AM (#16568700)
'Mini code bootcamp' suggests that your target audience is people looking for careers? What are the end employment results like for all the participants?

For instance, are MOOC students more likely to not complete the course because they have already found work in the meantime? Perhaps because they have more freedom to look for work during business hours, for example, rather than sitting in on a live class during the optimal employment search time?

If the goal is to find work, there is no incentive to keep going in the course after you have met your goal.

Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:46AM (#16568907)
The "mini code bootcamp" doesn't prepare people for jobs, it is a "miniature" version of code bootcamps. It actually only prepares you to begin our full computer science academy, which is six months long.

If you want the stats for our full computer science academy I can give you those; they're good. 50% hired within one month, median $90k salary.

Re:Surprising Things About School by randomdata on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:53AM (#16568951)
Thanks for the clarification. I'm still most interested in the results of the 'failures'. What did the people who failed to compete the MOOCs end up doing? How about those who succeeded with the mini live classes, but did not continue into your full program?
Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:01PM (#16569010)
I don’t have a good sense for what the “failures” went on to do, they fall off our radar.
Re:Surprising Things About School by randomdata on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:20PM (#16569171)
That is unfortunate, although I understand the practical reasons for why that is the case. However, how do we resolve the bias of only looking at the success stories? What if all of the 'failures' also went on to $90k average development jobs within the first month of quitting the MOOC? $90k developer jobs are not exactly difficult to come by in the current market to anyone who has expressed an interest in programming. The fact that they were willing to try a code bootcamp MOOC puts them miles ahead of the general population.
Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:27PM (#16569713)
As I stated above, we've A/B tested it with random samples, but it's hard to get any data on "failure to complete" populations because of obvious sampling bias
Re:Surprising Things About School by watwut on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:41AM (#16568862)
Classes for this crowd (older non-traditional students) tend to be in the evening or during weekend. Because they have jobs, education is not something they do while they are unemployed with intention to drop it the moment they find jobs. Through, major reason why they drop out is that handling work, family and school and harder, more demotivating and more tiresome then handling just school.

Beyond broadening access, if you have to be somewhere in person you have to make it priority at that time - and you are not interrupted while you are there. In home study is very easily interrupted and easy to postpone due to other very real duties until it is too late.

The motivation hit from meeting other students is also missing.

Re:Surprising Things About School by brudgers on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:36AM (#16568831)
The student handbook for the author's school suggests a graduate should expect to spend three to six months applying for five jobs a day. That's about 500 to a 1000 applications following six months of 45 hours a week at their online school.
Re:Surprising Things About School by ThrustVectoring on Monday March 12, 2018 @06:31PM (#16572299)
Five per day is a pretty low application rate for what it's worth. You can get through twenty in an hour if you're organized and motivated.
Re:Surprising Things About School by brudgers on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @10:52AM (#16576563)
Re:Surprising Things About School by gliese1337 on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:59AM (#16568548)
As long which ones you send to each link is determined entirely randomly, you have indeed done a "scientific" (i.e., statistically valid) control.
Re:Surprising Things About School by kbutler on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:58AM (#16568983)
That's one element.

This first couple of things I'd check would be:

  - Double-blind: What if you tell students it is live, but it is actually pre-recorded? 
  - Are the live+archive and archive-only videos the same? 
  - Are the live+archive students actually watching the video when it is live, or are they using the archive feature?
  - Do archive-only students who consistently watch at the same time do better? 
  - Does time/day of watching affect results? (archive-only students get the link at least [duration of class] later.)
You also need to control other interactions with the participants, track the results faithfully, avoid bias because instructors are more familiar with students from "live" interactions, ensure cohort size and result size are large enough to be meaningful, that group composition isn't biased by confounding factors, etc.

But random assignment is a good start!

Re:Surprising Things About School by brudgers on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:32AM (#16568791)
What studies would you cite for someone interested in learning more about the field?
Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:38AM (#16568842)
I'll dig some of them up later today, but it will be a bit as I need to finish some stuff.
Re:Surprising Things About School by edraferi on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:54AM (#16568124)
I think the time commitment is the biggest issue. Let's assume the costs are the same to me (perhaps due to employer subsidy):

When I take a MOOC, I'm pledging at least 5 hours a week. That covers 2 hours of videos, 2 hours of homework and 1 hour of additional research / review.

If I pledge 5 hours /week to a traditional class, I don't get nearly as much learning. I have to commute to the class, which is at least 30 minutes each way. Now my 5 hours buys me 2 hours of class, 2 hours of commuting and 1 hour of homework. I've lost an hour of homework and an hour of research.

I know which one is better for me.

Re:Surprising Things About School by VLM on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:24PM (#16570654)
Ah OK interesting I think I get what you are saying in that given an authority figure's specification, the student in a class will be far more likely to succeed at reaching that arbitrary externally imposed spec than a MOOC subscriber.

With the side issue that 100% of everyone in my 20 person automata theory class back in ninety-something is a much smaller number than 2% of 24000 people signing up for Ullman's automata theory MOOC.

The fundamental problem is authority along with excessive broadness. If I want to learn Y and the MOOC teaches X Y and Z, I will fail the MOOC. There are also Skinner box conditioning issues where my assignment for something like using bootstrap framework, will be scratching my own itch of project or doing some project at work, such that again I'll fail the MOOC because I'll refuse the assignment; I already have a more ambitious self assigned assignment and am not doing both my assignment and someone elses much less interesting assignment. Whereas if I sit in class I'll have peer pressure and financial pressure to do the class assignment regardless of work or hobby interests.

Sort of a traditional in-person or online class is a goal in and of itself; MOOCs are a means to an end for work or hobby for most.

Re:Surprising Things About School by randomdata on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:15AM (#16568665)
> 90% will complete a live, guided course. 5% will complete a MOOC of the same quality.

What does complete mean here? Complete within a given timeframe? Doesn't that miss the entire gain that MOOCs bring to the table? Which is that education becomes a lifelong endeavour instead of something you try and fit into a few years and, for most, never return to again?

Re:Surprising Things About School by dsr_ on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:01AM (#16568162)
Major counterproof: The Open University.

Sounds like MOOCs need to learn from educational institutions that actually have a track record in distance learning.

Re:Surprising Things About School by tonyedgecombe on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:02PM (#16569542)
The big difference is you have to pay for the OU, there is a commitment up front that filters out a lot of people.

Saying MOOCS are a failure because only 2% complete the course is like saying the OU is a failure because only 2% of their web site visitors sign up.

Re:Surprising Things About School by ThrustVectoring on Monday March 12, 2018 @06:29PM (#16572277)
How well are you controlling for the sheepskin effect? Students are highly motivated to do what it takes to get a degree from a university, and much less motivated to actually learn the topics nominally offered.

I suspect that a MOOC offered with the same incentives and structure as a live class - ie, as part of a degree-granting program with mandatory tests at set dates - would have significantly higher completion rates.

Re:Surprising Things About School by moosey on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:44PM (#16569879)
What is the purpose of a MOOC? Is it to make training available, or to provide academic success?

If it is the former, then it is definitely a success. If it is the latter, then I think that not only percentage rates of success are important, but also the nominal completion rate itself.

A MOOC supplies the opportunity for someone getting a degree in communications, business, or some other not-entirely-technical degree, that might be wonder what a computer science or high level mathematics course is like to go and find out. Does their failure in such a course mean that the class itself is a failure, or can the fact that they had access and were able to put a toe in the water mark success?

I would suggest the latter.

Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:54PM (#16569971)
Right. They're only a failure inasmuch as the initial promise was "these will basically replace college but for free!" which is now clearly not true.