Re:Report from the Geniatech vs. McHardy GPL violation court...
by larkeith on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:43AM
(#16567770)
Monetary penalties should be used only as a threat, for example in cases where entities are unwilling to come into compliance, rather than a goal; My understanding is that McHardy is doing something much more equitable to patent trolling, attempting to obtain large payouts for past violations, whereas the preferred methodologies would be to pursue legal penalty against contract violations only in cases where prior requests and legal actions have failed to cause a noncompliant entity to fall into line.
Re:Report from the Geniatech vs. McHardy GPL violation court...
by phkahler on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:11PM
(#16572527)
I don't see compliance as the only reasonable goal. I'd someone wrote code and their copyright is infringed, who is to say what they can sure for? For me it may depend on the infringers apparent motive. Companies come in all flavors, from those making honest mistakes all the way down to SCO. And then authors have their own motives. Who are we to judge the penalties sought by someone else?
> I believe individual developers who have contributed to the Linux kernel should have the right to enforce the license, if needed.
and then..
> On the other hand, such activities must always be oriented to compliance, and compliance only. Collecting huge amounts of contractual penalties is questionable.
To wit, isn't this a dichotomy? Either you make compliance mandatory, or optional. Can you have both of the above? How can you enforce without a threat of penalty?