News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surprising Things About School by triplesec on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:13AM (#16567358)
Pullout: "We had one student on the edge of homelessness, was $400 short on bills and almost had to quit because of that. I personally loaned him the money, and his income moved from $10/hr to $70k+/yr. It only took $400, but he didn’t have anywhere to get that from. Insane."
Re:Surprising Things About School by bane on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:23AM (#16567684)
I don't think it's that surprising. Anecdote: Right after I barely graduated from High School after my family clawed its way out of homelessness, I spent a few years working minimum wage jobs with long commutes in an old car. I could barely afford gas and groceries let alone decent housing and college.

After about 3 years of work, I managed to scrape together just enough to enroll in my local community college for two semesters, one class per semester. Total cost? At that time about $400 including books. And that $400 could have vaporized with one flat tire, or one visit to the doctor.

An acquaintance of my parents heard that I was going to college, suddenly took an interest and hired me sight unseen to come work at his startup in an entry-level developer job at 3x my then current pay. I worked there for a couple years and when I was close to finishing college, another acquaintance hired me and doubled my pay. After that I was attached to a growing career and haven't looked back.

But it all started with getting that tiny little bit of money together.

Re:Surprising Things About School by mcherm on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:14AM (#16568231)
It is incredibly surprising.

You aren't surprised because you have experienced this. But any economist would look at this and say something like this:

> You claim that there are people where an investment of $400 would > quickly (within a couple of years) give them a salary increase in > the range of $20,000 to $50,000 per year. That is obviously untrue. > If it WERE true, then at lease ONE person in the country would have > spent $4,000 to seed a 10-person program which granted the $400 in > exchange for a promise to contribute $8,000 back in a couple of > years. A x20 replication factor would easily swamp administrative > costs and participants who refuse to pay afterward and the program > would still be growing exponentially.

I think the source of the fallacy is that while there ARE people for whom $400 is a difficult-to-surmount barrier beyond which no other major impediments stand between them and middle-class success, they are an impossible-to-find minority in a sea of people who are willing to ASK for $400 and those for whom $400 is a major impediment, but further impediments would prevent them from succeeding.

Alternately, we can look at the literally thousands of charities (including schools themselves) that offer merit-based and need-based scholarships, and conclude that the economist is partly right and the system DOES exist, but isn't meeting all of the need.

Re:Surprising Things About School by icebraining on Monday March 12, 2018 @08:02AM (#16567576)
It's self-contradictory - he did have somewhere to get it from :)

I'm only half-joking; I think the problem here is lack of information. That the student was likely to move from $10/h to $70k/y is something that the teachers might know, but random lenders probably don't.

On the other hand, I don't know if I want to see financial companies partnering with schools to provide loans - seems ripe for abuse.

Re:Surprising Things About School by michaelbuckbee on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:30AM (#16567990)
You're describing one of the other points he makes in this: as bad as you think for profit education is, it's worse.

Austen has been railing against places like University of Phoenix, etc for a while as what's been discovered about them is just nuts. The stat that stood out for me was that at one point they had a substantial number of recruiters (thousands) but exactly zero job placement staff.

Re:Surprising Things About School by kthejoker2 on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:34AM (#16568017)
The school should partner with one of those "we invest in you in return for 1% of your life earnings" hedge funds.

That way it'd have easy access to short-term capital needs like this.

Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:47AM (#16568084)
OP here. We are a school that is completely free and takes a percentage of income (though for two years, not for life). Even still the $400 to make it through the last month was a barrier.

We’re working on having a fund available for living expenses, but “I’m going to pay you cash so you can go to school” is a different risk profile than “This School is free until you’re hired.”

Re:Surprising Things About School by kthejoker2 on Monday March 12, 2018 @06:05PM (#16572122)
That's awesome. The only reason the school should take the burden is to distribute the risk pool and also theyre the most capable of providing some value framework on whether this $400 or that $400 is a better investment.

I personally would loan money for this sort of thing if there was a reasonable ROI and someone vetting the students.

Re:Surprising Things About School by austenallred on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:48AM (#16568095)
Lenders aren’t very good at quantifying future changes in income. They’re trying, but it’s a hard problem to solve.
Re:Surprising Things About School by twblalock on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:44PM (#16569882)
Why couldn't that student take out a student loan, like most students?