Re:Surprising Things About School
by mcherm on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:14AM
(#16568231)
It is incredibly surprising.
You aren't surprised because you have experienced this. But any economist would look at this and say something like this:
> You claim that there are people where an investment of $400 would
> quickly (within a couple of years) give them a salary increase in
> the range of $20,000 to $50,000 per year. That is obviously untrue.
> If it WERE true, then at lease ONE person in the country would have
> spent $4,000 to seed a 10-person program which granted the $400 in
> exchange for a promise to contribute $8,000 back in a couple of
> years. A x20 replication factor would easily swamp administrative
> costs and participants who refuse to pay afterward and the program
> would still be growing exponentially.
I think the source of the fallacy is that while there ARE people for whom $400 is a difficult-to-surmount barrier beyond which no other major impediments stand between them and middle-class success, they are an impossible-to-find minority in a sea of people who are willing to ASK for $400 and those for whom $400 is a major impediment, but further impediments would prevent them from succeeding.
Alternately, we can look at the literally thousands of charities (including schools themselves) that offer merit-based and need-based scholarships, and conclude that the economist is partly right and the system DOES exist, but isn't meeting all of the need.
You aren't surprised because you have experienced this. But any economist would look at this and say something like this:
> You claim that there are people where an investment of $400 would > quickly (within a couple of years) give them a salary increase in > the range of $20,000 to $50,000 per year. That is obviously untrue. > If it WERE true, then at lease ONE person in the country would have > spent $4,000 to seed a 10-person program which granted the $400 in > exchange for a promise to contribute $8,000 back in a couple of > years. A x20 replication factor would easily swamp administrative > costs and participants who refuse to pay afterward and the program > would still be growing exponentially.
I think the source of the fallacy is that while there ARE people for whom $400 is a difficult-to-surmount barrier beyond which no other major impediments stand between them and middle-class success, they are an impossible-to-find minority in a sea of people who are willing to ASK for $400 and those for whom $400 is a major impediment, but further impediments would prevent them from succeeding.
Alternately, we can look at the literally thousands of charities (including schools themselves) that offer merit-based and need-based scholarships, and conclude that the economist is partly right and the system DOES exist, but isn't meeting all of the need.