News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by mixmax on Thursday September 02, 2010 @12:34PM (#1656728)
If you think that's high you should be happy you don't live in Denmark.

"The large public sector (30% of the entire workforce on a full-time basis) is financed by the world's highest taxes. A value added tax of 25% is levied on the sale of most goods and services (including groceries). The income tax in Denmark ranges from 42.9% to 63% progressively, levied on 4 out of 10 full-time employees. Such high rates mean that 1,010,000 Danes before the end of 2008 (44% of all full-time employees) will be paying a marginal income tax of 63% and a combined marginal tax of 70.9% resulting warnings from organisations such as the OECD"

Oh and if you want to buy a car you'll be hit with a 180% taxation of your new car on top of the 25% valueadded tax.

source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Denmark#Tax_Burden_a...

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by _delirium on Thursday September 02, 2010 @12:48PM (#1656764)
The people who do live in Denmark seem pretty happy about doing so, though (http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/11/061113093726.ht...). One reason might be that they're fairly wealthy to begin with, so it's taking a large percentage out of a large pie (Denmark's per-capita GDP is ~DKK 375,000 = ~$62,000). The social safety net is also rather strong as a result of the government's large amount of income, and it's popular, partly because nearly everyone uses parts of it--- free education, free adult education, free health care, free child-care, pensions, job retraining, etc.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by erikpukinskis on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:46PM (#1656960)
And interestingly their unemployment rate is lower than ours* (at least since 2004). Evidence that providing more government services doesn't lead to people just sitting on their asses and cashing their welfare checks.

* http://globaleconstats.com/wp/2009/08/25/the-unemployment-ra...

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by billswift on Thursday September 02, 2010 @08:52PM (#1658242)
I bet that if you put 30% of Americans on the public payroll, our unemployment rate would go way down too.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by Calamitous on Friday September 03, 2010 @02:49AM (#1658843)
I don't think anybody's seriously arguing that a majority of people would just sit around, but more government funding or regulation services would throw incentives out of whack.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by laut on Friday September 03, 2010 @01:00AM (#1658670)
Everyone is brought up to think it's the best country in the world. But I'm glad I emigrated and the other people I know who moved seem pretty happy about it too.

No that stuff isn't free just because it's paid for by taxes. And because the government has kept growing the government is now running a deficit. It will have to do reforms to avoid growing the debt.

Some think the big government system is great. I don't. But even if you do think it's nice, the problem is that it's not sustainable.

The growth of the economy is projected be the 2nd lowest in OECD only in front of Japan.

Denmark has been a rich country for a while but as the government has grown it has been falling down the list and is now out of the top 10.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by alexyim on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:11PM (#1656849)
What does the US have?
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by FrankBlack on Thursday September 02, 2010 @06:26PM (#1657937)
Bombs. Lots and lots of bombs. And, apparently, we love to use them. Prisons. We're good at those. Oh, and flags. We like to wave those a lot, too. Especially about the fact that we are "free" compared to those "socialist" menaces around the world. So, we pay an average of 40% in taxes, but does that pay for your higher education or your kid's higher education? Not likely. Does it pay for your health care? Probably not all of it (in some cases, none at all). Does it pay for daycare? Good retirement? So, when you factor that and a lot more into the equation, some countries don't have it so bad. The sad thing is, we could be doing SO well here if we just tweaked things a bit. Tweaking, apparently, is out of the question,
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by brc on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:10PM (#1658067)
I've often tried to point this out to US taxpayers I've met. While in my country the tax rates are about the same, or perhaps a bit lower, our defence force is miniscule in comparison and thus social spending takes place instead.

Though, to be fair on countries like mine (and Denmark) we receive positive externalities from excessive US Defense Force spending, because we don't have to maintain a full sized force due to our treaties with the USA. As a negative, we're compelled to join in on such adventures as Iraq and Afghanistan as a result.

However, many of the smaller nations with similar tax bases and larger social benefits compared to the USA tend to forget about the effective subsidies paid by the US taxpayer for our national defense.

Additionally, there is definitely a component of the US Defense spending that is arguably social policy - even if it is part of the military-industrial complex. It does provide a lot of people with taxpayer-funded positions, and allows otherwise-jobless areas to enjoy employment opportunities with establishment of bases.

I clearly think there is a case for a reduced defense force in the USA - just one or two less Nimitz class carriers could build a lot of public hospitals, for one example, and removing bases from Europe and Japan would be another saving. But I don't think you can have an honest and full comparison with other countries until you start looking at the massive US defense force spending, and it's effects on other countries who effectively get to forgo that same spending.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by donohoe on Thursday September 02, 2010 @12:48PM (#1656766)
Yes, but to be fair to the Danes their quality of life and the health of their society as a result is amazing.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by rubashov on Thursday September 02, 2010 @02:47PM (#1657185)
As a result of their tax rate and size of government? That's ridiculous.

Denmark is wealthy and comfortable because it's full of Danes. I bet you Danes in the US are even wealthier and more comfortable than Danes in Denmark.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by jsankey on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:13PM (#1658078)
To be honest your point seems completely vacuous (far more ridiculous than the point you are responding to). It appears to reduce to "Danes are magical - I think". What makes Danes special? Is this not related to the sort of government they would create and support?
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by mixmax on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:56PM (#1658357)
"Danes are magical"

I can assure you we are not.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by citrik on Friday September 03, 2010 @02:15AM (#1658797)
Some of them are ;)
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by rubashov on Thursday September 02, 2010 @10:48PM (#1658466)
They are high time preference and relatively high IQ. These are the features that distinguish the various ethnicities that build pleasant societies.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by ArturSoler on Friday September 03, 2010 @06:07AM (#1659073)
I guess you meant to say that they have low time preference.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by VBprogrammer on Thursday September 02, 2010 @03:07PM (#1657250)
Because America is the greatest country in the world people outside America couldn't possibly be happy with the way they do things?
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 02, 2010 @05:52PM (#1657835)
To be fair, in the few cases where I've seen good data, most groups do better in the US than in their native countries.

For instance, Asian Americans have average income of $65,000. Japan, the richest country in Asia, has average income of about $40,000. Japanese Americans also live 2 years longer than Japanese.

Swedish Americans are also considerably richer than Swedes, as I discovered today: http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-o...

Like it or not, ethnicity plays a big role in many social measures. The US is very diverse, and certain groups drag our averages down (groups that are very small in Europe and Asia).

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by jbooth on Thursday September 02, 2010 @06:54PM (#1658020)
Yeah, but that's a self-selected group. People who are capable of moving their families to another country to pursue a career are more likely to be successful. Similarly people who grow up in poor, backwards communities (trailer parks and projects, meth and crack), tend to wind up poor and backwards. Maybe I'm a reactionary liberal but I have an easier time believing that than the inherent genetic superiority of the danes (oh and that's just SO close to certain ideologies I'm always wanting to accuse the Tea Party of harboring).

Wanna see something really cool? Look at a satellite image of Denmark. It's almost entirely farmland, with little spots of ultra-dense village or city every so often. No suburban wasteland. I'd be 20% happier just for that.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:26PM (#1658103)
Swedish Americans are the descendents of lower class agricultural workers who left religious repression in Sweden between 1860 and 1910. In the case of Japanese Americans, they are descended from manual laborers who left Japan between 1882 and 1924.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_emigration_to_the_Unite...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_American#Immigration

In any case, I don't get how you could read either of my factoids and suggest I was pushing genetic determinism. Clearly, some environmental factors are important. For example, living in the US rather than Sweden or Japan seems to cause people to earn 50% more money. Using US health care rather than Japanese health care seems to increase life expectancy by 2 years (no, I don't actually believe this latter point).

But on the other hand, ethnicity does also seem to have some measurable effects. Asian Americans beat whites on most social measures in spite of the head start whites had.

Feel free to call me a racist tea partier if you like.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by jbooth on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:47PM (#1658142)
Oh, I wasn't accusing you at all, just noting it was funny that we were talking about the Danish with their blonde hair and blue eyes, in the context of genetic determinism -- been reading about Hitler and Stalin's respective rises to power recently, so it's on my mind.

As far as the Asian American thing, I'm personally partial to social factors there as well. At the risk of being a stereotyping a-hole, there's a lot of Asian Americans in SAT prep classes. Correlation with ethnicity doesn't necessarily mean that asians are genetically predisposed to be better at the SATs.

Really, I just wanted to highlight those satellite pictures of Denmark.

EDIT: Also, RE: the impoverished and hardworking immigrants, I agree, it's not like they were Saudi princes when they came to America, but those who did come were the ones who had the motivation to pull off the journey -- then, now that they've bitten it off, they're obligated to succeed. Still self-selecting to some degree to me.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by Aetius on Friday September 03, 2010 @09:51AM (#1659525)
When's the last time you flew coast to coast? There's quite a lot of farmland in the U.S.
Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by jbooth on Friday September 03, 2010 @10:26AM (#1659655)
There is indeed a lot of farmland in the US, but there's also more suburban wasteland than the entire land mass of Denmark (made up figure).

Denmark manages to have a higher population density than us while still being like 90% farmland. That's efficiency.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by lutorm on Friday September 03, 2010 @02:47AM (#1658840)
Given the obvious bias displayed in the sweeping conclusions drawn in that post, I'm not inclined to put a lot of faith in the author. There are so many possible biases in that comparison.

For example, it's pretty well accepted that it's better to be high-income in the US than in Sweden, so if you for some reason have a population that is in the upper income levels in the US (due to being white and long-resident, for example) it's not surprising that they would have higher income than in Sweden. As Sweden is a much more redistributive society than the US, the upper income levels in the US are, as a matter of speaking, subsidized by the lower-income levels. And there are a lot more lower income levels in the US than in Sweden.

The conclusion that "The U.S would be even richer and have much less poverty if it was made up entirely of Swedes" is ridiculous. It's equivalent to saying "the US would be even richer if it was made up entirely of the people that make a lot of money", which completely ignores the fact that the US economy depends on low-wage earners to a completely different degree than Sweden does.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by jsankey on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:19PM (#1658091)
Comparing average incomes is meaningless for at least two reasons:

1) The cost of living will not be the same; and 2) Income is no measure of quality of life/satisfaction.

As an example, what if average incomes are higher, but so is income inequality? What effect does this have on the society (and the standard of licing of those within it) as a whole?

I also think jbooth has a point in that these are self-selected groups.

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by yummyfajitas on Thursday September 02, 2010 @07:47PM (#1658141)
The data I gave is adjusted for cost of living. (Fun fact: adjusting for cost of living hurts Sweden, living there is more expensive, not less.) This blog post describes the methodology:

http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/income-distributio...

As you can clearly see from the graph linked to in my previous comment, the bottom 15% or so of Swedish Americans are slightly poorer than Swedes. The top 85% or so are richer. That's the effect of inequality.

As for quality of life/satisfaction - I'll focus on wealth since I don't really know what you mean when you say "quality of life" or "satisfaction" (they are fairly subjective terms).

Re:Your real tax rate: 40% by jsankey on Thursday September 02, 2010 @08:08PM (#1658175)
Thanks for linking to the post with the methodology, it was interesting. It does show the difficulty of trying to get accurate numbers, although the author has clearly made an effort to.

Re: the effect of inequality: sure, that's the effect on income. But that is obviously not all that matters.

Yes, the things I am referring to are subjective. Yes, they are hard to measure. But this doesn't mean we should just ignore them, and focus on what we can easily measure. Sounds like a recipe for optimising the wrong thing.