News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by blorsh on Sunday March 11, 2018 @05:46PM (#16564944)
The only real solution to gerrymandering is to use a minimally-complicated algorithm.

The algorithm need not actually determine the districts. It can instead simply rate proposals, allowing a contest to be held. The highest scoring proposal submitted at least 400 days prior to the election is the winner, with earlier submissions winning any ties.

Another improvement would be to let districts spill over state borders. One could exempt Alaska and Hawaii of course.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by Feniks on Sunday March 11, 2018 @06:28PM (#16565074)
Or you could just do away with it all and go for a one man one vote system. Why a vote in Kansas needs to be tallied differently from a vote in New York in the 2020 elections is beyond me.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by Anon1096 on Sunday March 11, 2018 @08:00PM (#16565395)
Districts don't matter for the presidential election. They only affect apportionment in the House of Representatives, which is region based and is 1 man 1 vote (within state boundaries. Even across states the differences in voting power isn't as aggregious as the Senate or overall electoral college).
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by dragonwriter on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:29AM (#16566527)
> Districts don't matter for the presidential election.

Except in Maine and Nebraska (selection of Presidential electors is largely a matter of state law, and most but not all states are winner take all.)

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by dragonwriter on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:27AM (#16566522)
Like many features of the original constitution, protecting slavery (the slave states were modtly low population states, with even smaller voting populations, and were particularly concerned that equal representation would eventually turn against them—abolitionism was already a thing at the time of the Constitution, and they were very concerned about it taking hold) was a major concern. The representation structure (and it's special protection against revision by amendment) plus the 3/5 compromise plus the explicit, limit term, protection of the slave trade, among other provisions of the Constitution, were protection against that eventuality.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by rukittenme on Sunday March 11, 2018 @06:55PM (#16565169)
Because presidential elections are not popular elections. Kansas has proportional representation in the House but is absurdly over-represented in the Senate and slightly over-represented in the Presidency.

This is of course by design. The founder's obviously knew about proportional representation and they deliberately chose to disregard it. Shouldn't that give you pause to figure out why?

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by philwelch on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:10PM (#16565992)
> The founder's obviously knew about proportional representation and they deliberately chose to disregard it. Shouldn't that give you pause to figure out why?

Turns out the reason was slavery. A huge proportion of the Southern population was enslaved, and slaves didn't vote. The free staters didn't want slaves to even count toward state population for the purposes of congressional apportionment, while the slave staters did, so they compromised on counting the slave population at 3/5 of the free population. As a result, prior to the abolition of slavery, the votes of free men in slave states were always represented at a higher proportion than the votes of free men in free states.

Many of the founders were wise and educated men who thought carefully and critically about how to establish a sustainable republic. But to do so, they had to win the votes of a cross-section of the American establishment of the time, many of whom thought that owning human beings, using them as farm labor, and whipping them if they disobeyed were morally acceptable things to do. And upon making a series of political compromises with these people, they had to rationalize those compromises in such a way to make them palatable to the general public.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by s2g on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:36AM (#16566543)
Most of them were perfectly fine with owning people.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by slededit on Monday March 12, 2018 @04:07AM (#16566759)
A lot them even owned their own slaves.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by dbcurtis on Sunday March 11, 2018 @08:33PM (#16565476)
Indeed. With our current system, rural voices are at least marginally relevant. With a purely proportional system, rural voices would not even be heard.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Sunday March 11, 2018 @09:30PM (#16565660)
The major reason is that smaller states wouldn't have joined any proposed Union that made them irrelevant, so the founders had to have things like the Senate to get them to join at all.

This is, of course, no longer relevant.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by twoodfin on Sunday March 11, 2018 @10:28PM (#16565858)
If it’s no longer relevant, it should be possible to convince small states both red & blue to accept an obviously superior system.

But it is still relevant for just about all the reasons it was relevant then.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by philwelch on Sunday March 11, 2018 @10:52PM (#16565935)
I think if you had some way of forcing the issue, and telling states like Kansas and Mississippi that they didn't get to have disproportional control over the federal government anymore, and if they didn't like it, they could just stop being subsidized by California and New York, either they would go along with it, or they would secede from the union and deteriorate into third world countries.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by rukittenme on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:20PM (#16566015)
Why would states persist in a union that made them irrelevant? The politics are still as relevant today as it was then.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:50AM (#16567520)
It’s way harder to leave than it was to refrain from joining.

Another major factor is that Americans mostly see themselves as citizens of the USA first, and citizens of their state a distant second.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by s2g on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:37AM (#16566546)
Because the alternative is worse.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by s2g on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:35AM (#16566540)
They also didn't choose to tie electors to the per state popular vote and chose the electoral college in part to prevent the election of terrible candidates.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by krapp on Sunday March 11, 2018 @07:36PM (#16565320)
>Why a vote in Kansas needs to be tallied differently from a vote in New York in the 2020 elections is beyond me.

    population of Kansas (state):  2.9 million
    population of New York (city): 8.5 million
Without some sort of balancing mechanism, you wind up with a single populous city's votes mattering more than the votes from every city in a less populous state.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Sunday March 11, 2018 @09:29PM (#16565653)
What is wrong with that, exactly? If the city is substantially larger than the state, it seems reasonable to me that its votes would matter more.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by barsonme on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:49AM (#16566273)
This is something our founders debated. It's never good to let the whims of the majority trample on the minority. It's why we have both the house of representatives (based on population) and the senate (flat number per state).

If little states have no say in our government, what point is there for them to remain?

It's a pity some folks devalue others simply because they don't wish to live in NYC or LA.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by s2g on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:31AM (#16566532)
> It's never good to let the whims of the majority trample on the minority

You are arguing for the minority to trample on the majority.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by barsonme on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:18PM (#16569155)
That’s not what I’m arguing.

It needs to be competitive. The majority shouldn’t be able to have its way without the help of the minority.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:27AM (#16567421)
Why is the rural minority so special? We don’t give other minorities this sort of treatment.

For example, the percentage of rural Americans is similar to the percentage of black Americans. Yet somehow nobody ever argues that black Americans need power disproportionate to their numbers to avoid being trampled.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by bzbarsky on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:19AM (#16568267)
> Why is the rural minority so special?

It's not about rural vs urban. It's about the assumption that the US is a union of separate _states_ with separate legal structures, cultures, etc, etc. So it's not the "rural minority" that's special; it's states that are special.

Now you may disagree with the premises there, of course. But if one accepts the premises, then one needs a way to prevent "big" states from just imposing their will on "small" ones.

(There are in fact people who argue that black Americans need disproportionate power, and some voting districts are set up to effectively produce that, but that has nothing to do with the setup of the US constitution per se.)

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:49AM (#16568467)
They called out NYC and LA so I don’t think they were thinking along the same lines you are.

Of course you need this if one accepts the premise that states are special. You’re basically just assuming the conclusion at that point.

I’m not aware of any voting district that’s set up to give black Americans a disproportionately large amount of power. There are some that are deliberately set up to ensure proportionate power.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by barsonme on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:26PM (#16569226)
I called out NYC and LA because they’re high population areas.

My point is this: delegating power to solely the majority is a bad idea, full stop. In a properly functioning society, the majority needs to work cooperatively with the minority, which means the minority needs some sort of functional advantage (like we have in the US Senate, with respect to states).

How individual states set up this power balance internally is up to them. Obviously I think it should follow a similar model to the one we have at the federal level with our collection of states.

It annoys me when people rag on smaller areas like RI or WY because they get “extra privileges” or some such nonsense when it comes to elections or the US congress.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:43PM (#16570350)
This seems to assume that there is some fixed “the minority” that needs to be advantaged in order to be fair, and further that “the minority” corresponds to the smaller states.

In reality, there’s a different minority for every issue. Giving states with low population a disproportionate amount of power doesn’t necessarily balance the minority with the majority. Depending on the issue it may allow the majority to more easily trample the minority, or it may allow a minority to impose its will on the rest.

The solution to requiring cooperation with the minority is to require more than a simple majority to do things. See for example: removal following impeachment, constitutional amendment, treaty ratification, or the de facto situation in the Senate for most legislation at the moment.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by barsonme on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:26PM (#16573493)
We're a federal republic made up of 50 states plus DC. Balancing the power between _states_ is standard among federal republics (Germany, Switzerland, Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, ...).

Federal republics _need_ the power balance among _states_, otherwise there's no point in the states participating in the republic, thus no point in even having a federal republic. If that's your point, fine. But you can't have your cake and eat it too.

How states want to balance out things internally is up to them, and that can be used to help the minority on specific issues.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:54PM (#16573600)
A federal structure is a means to an end, not the goal itself. If it doesn’t serve the purpose we want then we should change it.

In any case, even if you take the state as the unit that needs to be balanced, my point stands: you can’t balance “the minority” by picking some arbitrary minority and giving them more power.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by krapp on Sunday March 11, 2018 @09:53PM (#16565731)
I can see an argument either way. More populated areas to legitimately represent commercial and cultural centers, but also, the needs of the entire system have to be considered.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by mikeash on Sunday March 11, 2018 @09:57PM (#16565745)
What is it about rural voters that make them more important to the entire system?
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by rukittenme on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:35PM (#16566054)
Resources.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by s2g on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:20AM (#16566499)
Yes, which is how it should be.

States have senators to prevent tyranny of the majority. NYC should be worth more house seats than all of Kansas.

Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by shouldgowork on Sunday March 11, 2018 @08:21PM (#16565453)
Without some sort of rebalancing mechanism, you wind up with a singe empty state's votes mattering more than every voter in a city.
Re:Unratified Amendments to the U.S. Constitution by rukittenme on Sunday March 11, 2018 @11:33PM (#16566049)
The mechanism you're talking about is the federal government.