Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News
by ujal on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:56AM
(#1656138)
I was wondering about the consequences of introducing some kind of a supervisor system on HN. So practically every new/low-karma HN-member will be assigned to a high-karma HN-member. Every submission and/or voting needs then to be approved by a supervisor.
This would imply more work for high-karma members but I am sure they would love to contribute to the quality here on HN.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News
by btilly on Thursday September 02, 2010 @11:45AM
(#1656523)
I would pity whatever high-karma HN-member got assigned me when I was new. I suspect the relationship would have irritated both sides very quickly, likely leading to me not having gotten involved in the first place.
Now that I'm a relatively high-karma member, I'm quite sure that I wouldn't want to have such a responsibility. I spend quite a bit of time here, sure, but in bursts. You can't rely on me to respond to anything within a day. And that lag time is inappropriate for how the site works.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News
by ujal on Thursday September 02, 2010 @03:25PM
(#1657315)
There are for sure lots of potential technical methods to overcome the relationship problem. One of these would be assigning random high-karma users everytime someone submits a link.
Same goes for the time lag issue. You could assign only high-karma users who are currently browsing the site. In the end you could always opt-out.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News
by jashmenn on Thursday September 02, 2010 @11:40AM
(#1656494)
But then we end up like Digg, right? And then who is watching the watchmen? If you give a super-user more weight then you're just increasing the potential power of a "corrupt" super-user.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News
by ujal on Thursday September 02, 2010 @03:33PM
(#1657344)
I am not speaking about a longer period, you could 'graduate' in a couple of days. Apart from that one could easily detect if such a corruption takes place. For example a story that gets not approved but gets enough points and is submitted by someone else could be evidence for such a corruption. The one who has not approved the story could get minus points.