News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by btilly on Thursday September 02, 2010 @04:00AM (#1655563)
How many people here ever click on "new"? How many stories just disappear without hitting the front page? How many accounts need to be involved to make a particular story get to the front page?

I'm sure that the answers respectively are, "rather few", "the vast majority" and "not many". And there you have the raw ingredients for a voting ring to form. As a matter of principle I would never be involved with such, and I have a natural dislike for anyone that I think is. But the ingredients are there.

More than that, you still have a popularity effect. People who vote on new articles have to prioritize what they read in some fashion. Speaking personally, it is natural to choose to look at articles with interesting titles, or which are submitted by someone you recognize as being a consistent source of good content. Therefore if someone like patio11 submits an article, it has a significant advantage. As does anything involving YC. (Of course promoting YC is the whole point of this site, so I don't mind that at all. And I'm guilty at looking at content from people I trust before content from people I've never heard of.)

Memory says that jacquesm mentioned once that he had turned down an offer of money to post certain articles from companies that were looking for good pr. (I don't swear that I correctly remember who it was.) He may have turned them down, but I'm sure they asked again, and if they asked around enough I'm sure that they found a taker. And if so, then you have the dark side here on HN.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jbert on Thursday September 02, 2010 @08:57AM (#1656000)
Why not simply mix some 'new' randomly into the front page at some ratio? If one or two of the stories in the front page were (different) new stories for each visitor, you'd solve the "front page or bust" problem.

You'd sacrifice a bit of "quality" from the front page, at the gain of a more variety and more exposure for new stories - entirely tunable by the ratio.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by alextgordon on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:16AM (#1656040)
Or display both in two columns. Frontpage on the left. New on the right.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jbert on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:57AM (#1656141)
Well, the idea would be that the casual viewer couldn't distinguish the 'new' from the front page and so would treat them the same.

Otherwise people will ignore new as they do now.

(Point score could be left off of the front page to help this).

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by alextgordon on Thursday September 02, 2010 @11:33AM (#1656461)
I think the problem is not that people are wilfully ignoring it, rather it's just not prominent enough.

When I open HN, I am immediately seduced by an interesting headline (or point score) of a frontpage story. I don't have time to make a conscious decision to visit /newest. There's no way it's getting precedence over "12 ways to speed up your Erlang programs with NoSQL".

If new and the frontpage got equal treatment, then I'd be seduced by interesting headlines of frontpage and new stories equally. Meaning the good new stories would have a better chance of being upvoted.

I wouldn't like to see frontpage and new stories merged into the same list, since a great deal of new stories are spam or otherwise devoid of interest.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jacquesm on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:29AM (#1656070)
That would help to some extent but because of the different traffic ratios it would also significantly increase the pay-off for a spammer.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jbert on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:58AM (#1656144)
That's tunable again tho.

Not all front pages need some new mixed in - you can adjust both the amount of new and the proportion of 'contaminated' front pages.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jacquesm on Thursday September 02, 2010 @01:16PM (#1656862)
> How many people here ever click on "new"?

I don't know. But 'rather few' sounds accurate

> How many stories just disappear without hitting the front page?

About 90%. For 90% of that 90% that's fine. The other 10% are a loss.

> How many accounts need to be involved to make a particular story get to the front page?

Currently I'd peg that at somewhere between 4 and 5.

> Memory says that jacquesm mentioned once that he had turned down an offer of money to post certain articles from companies that were looking for good pr.

It wasn't for money it was in return for articles about my stuff.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by ujal on Thursday September 02, 2010 @09:56AM (#1656138)
I was wondering about the consequences of introducing some kind of a supervisor system on HN. So practically every new/low-karma HN-member will be assigned to a high-karma HN-member. Every submission and/or voting needs then to be approved by a supervisor. This would imply more work for high-karma members but I am sure they would love to contribute to the quality here on HN.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by btilly on Thursday September 02, 2010 @11:45AM (#1656523)
I would pity whatever high-karma HN-member got assigned me when I was new. I suspect the relationship would have irritated both sides very quickly, likely leading to me not having gotten involved in the first place.

Now that I'm a relatively high-karma member, I'm quite sure that I wouldn't want to have such a responsibility. I spend quite a bit of time here, sure, but in bursts. You can't rely on me to respond to anything within a day. And that lag time is inappropriate for how the site works.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by ujal on Thursday September 02, 2010 @03:25PM (#1657315)
There are for sure lots of potential technical methods to overcome the relationship problem. One of these would be assigning random high-karma users everytime someone submits a link.

Same goes for the time lag issue. You could assign only high-karma users who are currently browsing the site. In the end you could always opt-out.

Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by jashmenn on Thursday September 02, 2010 @11:40AM (#1656494)
But then we end up like Digg, right? And then who is watching the watchmen? If you give a super-user more weight then you're just increasing the potential power of a "corrupt" super-user.
Re:Voting Rings: How Insiders Game User Generated News by ujal on Thursday September 02, 2010 @03:33PM (#1657344)
I am not speaking about a longer period, you could 'graduate' in a couple of days. Apart from that one could easily detect if such a corruption takes place. For example a story that gets not approved but gets enough points and is submitted by someone else could be evidence for such a corruption. The one who has not approved the story could get minus points.