News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by stochastic_monk on Saturday March 10, 2018 @11:09AM (#16558977)
I typically don’t have the patience for most videos. I want information, and much of the time, the information bandwidth or payoff is too low. I think video can be great auxiliary, supporting material, but there should usually be a textual component when trying to inform.
Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by pdkl95 on Saturday March 10, 2018 @11:53AM (#16559185)
> there should

Or, we could accept that different people learn better in different ways. It's wonderful that a variety of learning resources are being made, so more people have the opportunity to learn complex and interesting topics.

> the information bandwidth or payoff is too low

Perhaps consider that you might not be the target audience?

Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by laretluval on Saturday March 10, 2018 @01:06PM (#16559459)
> Or, we could accept that different people learn better in different ways.

No evidence for interpersonal difference in learning styles: https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/mar/12/no-evidenc...

Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by PhasmaFelis on Saturday March 10, 2018 @02:19PM (#16559744)
It's trivially obvious that some people get more from reading than from watching, and vice versa. If you think a study disproves something trivially obvious, odds are that either the study is flawed or you've misunderstood it.

I'm guessing the latter, as mjw1007 points out.

Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by posterboy on Saturday March 10, 2018 @03:36PM (#16560039)
> If you think a study disproves something ...

That wasn't the comment. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. So, I don't really know why the parent posted that. Or why you try to imply counter evidence, but don't name any.

> trivially obvious

It's something you see on a street intersection? I'm kidding, but i don't agree. I don't even agree that the problem is framed correctly. Somebody mentioned "isomorphism" in this thread, which is a very important notion. Different methods of learning are used to learn different things. The things are in principle in different domains. The things might be isomorphic, ie. readily transferred from one domain to another, but they are not equal. A painting of a square is not the same as a verbal description of it. On the one hand, nobody is equally skilled in all domains. On the other hand, there should be some basic skills that are necessary to solve certain problems. So, either everyone who isn't comfortable with a given "learning style" will inherently fail to solve corresponding fundamental problems, or there are multiple ways to solve a problem effectively -- which ideally would mean the student can choose the problems of interest and capability.

In conclusion, both hypothesis are true at the same time, but you are assuming a misguided context. Of course there might exist different ideas of what's elementary or fundamental.

Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by mjw1007 on Saturday March 10, 2018 @01:43PM (#16559608)
That's saying that some recently fashionable, and fairly elaborate, theories about teaching children are basically junk science.

That includes the ideas that there are left/right brain learners, children who are holistic as opposed to serialists, and children who are inherently "verbalisers" or "visualisers".

I don't doubt they're right. But I think it would be a mistake to read that article and conclude that adults who simply say they do much better with videos than books, or vice versa, are mistaken about themselves.

Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by jehlakj on Saturday March 10, 2018 @03:03PM (#16559900)
Uneducated individual here. What is the proper term for arguing against a claim that was never made or incorrectly assumed, but ambiguous enough to become a target? I see this a lot in political debates. Something more technical than a misunderstanding.

Anyway, I think that’s what’s happening here. It’s not a simple matter of different learning styles, but rather the strength of stimuli that are involved when learning something new. Some people may find text sufficient, but a lot of people prefer videos because it’s far more engaging. Breaking down learning styles into visual, audio, etc is meaningless imo.

Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by hexane360 on Saturday March 10, 2018 @03:50PM (#16560098)
I think this falls under a strawman argument. I don't think there's any requirement that strawmans have to be deliberate.
Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by __s on Saturday March 10, 2018 @11:25AM (#16559041)
I get around this by watching videos in fast forward
Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by edanm on Saturday March 10, 2018 @04:12PM (#16560168)
I usually agree with you, but lately, I have seen amazing advances in using video as a medium to teach ideas.

I think the standout for me would be the channel 3Blue1Brown on Youtube, which teaches math concepts with animated videos, in a way that is just amazing. I highly recommend it if you're at all interested in math.

(And no, this doesn't replace the kind of textbook learning you need to actually understand math. It's more about concepts and ideas. But it's still amazingly valuable).

Re:Round Peg in a Square Hole [video] by sillysaurus3 on Saturday March 10, 2018 @07:01PM (#16560822)
To illustrate just how good 3Blue1Brown is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15003510

That was one of the other videos Deemed Worthy. There are so many more.

I wasn't able to visualize higher dimensions until watching that. And now it seems totally obvious how to do it.