News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:02PM (#16555807)
I clean with a steamer. It doesn't project particles, and it's extremely good at disinfecting. I also use a vacuum cleaner with exceptionally low dust re-emission. And an air purifier.

The only "chemicals" I use are an extremely mild lactic acid based cleaner and a pre/probiotic on toilets and kitchen tops. And I don't use any fragrances anywhere.

My allergy problems have disappeared. I really recommend this approach. Cheap chemicals are a disaster for ones health.

Microfibres are cool, but I've seen inconclusive evidence they might shed asbesto-like particles. So I'm waiting for better testing.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by outlace on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:05PM (#16557038)
Per the hygiene hypothesis, I wonder if your allergies got better because you’re exposing yourself to more (generally harmless) microorganisms and hence challenging your immune system more. Since I’m sure lactic acid doesn’t sterilize as well as some strong bleach or other chemical.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by Joeri on Saturday March 10, 2018 @01:33PM (#16559568)
Anecdata: my wife’s allergies come and go quite predictably switching between regular and hypoallergenic soaps and laundry detergents. Especially with laundry detergent a single load with the wrong detergent can have her sneezing all day. That doesn’t fit the micro organism exposure theory.

Myself I have an allergy to grass pollen, but the catalyst that really brings it out is car exhaust. Personally I believe that the chemicals in our environment are catalysts for natural sensitivities, turning them into allergies.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by scruple on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:27PM (#16560498)
I recently (in the last 3 weeks) developed an allergy to heavily fragranced laundry detergent. It's the first persistent allergic reaction I've really ever had. We usually use a very mild unscented detergent but my mother in law was staying with us for a little while and uses Tide and she washed some of my clothes. I generally have sensitive skin and so it was quite a shock. I was bruising all over my body just from light but compulsory scratching. It seems to have passed but it's given me a new found appreciation for using mild chemicals for cleaning, etc...
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by outlace on Saturday March 10, 2018 @02:33PM (#16559799)
This is still compatible with the hygiene hypothesis. It could be that your wife grew up in a “too clean” environment and hence her immune system became hypersensitive to substances that anybody in a less clean developing country would have no issues with. She has legitimate allergies; the hygiene hypothesis just tries to explain why many people get allergies in the first place.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by learnstats2 on Saturday March 10, 2018 @06:33PM (#16560703)
A hypothesis which permits compatibility with any reality it is of limited practical value.

If it's ultimately not falsifiable, it's not science.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by outlace on Saturday March 10, 2018 @09:28PM (#16561405)
It’s a completely testable and falsifiable hypothesis. The original commenter seemed to be dismissing the hypothesis based on an anecdote that he thought falsified the hypothesis and I was pointing out that it does not. Of course any hypothesis that cannot be falsified is not worth entertaining.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by erikpukinskis on Sunday March 11, 2018 @12:15PM (#16563519)
How would you falsify your hypothesis that the wife's allergies are from a "too clean" environment?
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by outlace on Sunday March 11, 2018 @06:30PM (#16565080)
You can’t, in general, test something that already happened. Moreover, given the immune system is a complex system with some degree of randomness involved, it would probably be impossible to prove that any particular person’s allergies were caused by a too clean environment. But we can certainly study it at a population level and it can be falsified with populations.

This is similar to smoking. Smoking is a good explanation for a large amount of the cases of lung disease at the population level and is falsifiable at that level. But it is impossible to say that smoking caused a particular person’s lung cancer.

So my original comment of “I wonder if...” is just that. A musing, not a hypothesis. I can’t prove anything for a particular person. But maybe more people will be aware of the hygiene hypothesis and might take it into consideration.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by erikpukinskis on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @07:24PM (#16589270)
So how would you falsify “the population with his wife’s allergy often get it from sources other than a too clean environment”?
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by Moru on Saturday March 10, 2018 @01:41PM (#16559597)
Sounds just like me. One thing at a time can be ok but combinations really triggers. Sneezing constantly for hours is not fun. Antihistamin helps a lot by removing the pollen side and then I can stand the bad air pollution from cars.

Friends washing their clothes in perfume however there is no cure for yet.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by kpil on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:14AM (#16557941)
The idea that allergies somehow are caused by our sterile lifestyle is suspicious at best. It's might just be an appeal to nature - "all natural ingredients" fallacy.

I claim that an individual has never before - in the history of mankind - been exposed to so many and different microorganisms as we are now.

Comparing my daughter to my granddad, born 99 years before her, she probably meets as many "new" people per week - if not day, as he did in a whole year when growing up in a reasonably average community not far from a large city.

Me and my wife works in large organisations, and it's representatives are visiting or are visited by hundreds of people from around the world - every week, as do many - most in fact - of the other parents in her school of about 1000 students.

I have lunch in a canteen where approximately 3000 people eat every day, and we all are slopping around in the food warmers and salad bar sharing the utensils and pawing the bread with our halfheartedly washed hands.

On the way to our offices and schools we commute with thousands and thousands of people, all sniffling and coughing it seems.

The interconnectedness of it all is just - mind boggling. We are never more than 2 steps away from someone that were on the other side of the world, yesterday. Hopefully not in an Ebola zone.

A hypothetical "natural" state, where you sleep in a stack of hay with your pigs, and meet one "outsider" twice a a year doesn't seem to tax the immune system even a fraction of what we have to deal with today. Even it's a lot of microorganisms, it's yours (and the pigs) - unless some pigeons shit in your haystack/bed.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by fulafel on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:29AM (#16557961)
The body of scientific evidence supporting the hygiene hypothesis is pretty strong.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by kristiandupont on Saturday March 10, 2018 @08:34AM (#16558412)
I am reading An Epidemic of Absence (http://www.moisesvm.com/) which explores the hypothesis and it presents a plethora of cases and studies that support it. I have not searched for counter points but it seems pretty solid to me. I can recommend the book by the way.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by Coincoin on Saturday March 10, 2018 @03:47PM (#16560080)
One major thing we are no longer exposed to are parasites. Those were common before but they are now pretty much inexistant in western civilization.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by shitgoose on Sunday March 11, 2018 @03:17PM (#16564327)
i doubt you exchange bodily fluids with 1000s of people around you. maybe some, but not 1000s. AC and recycled air, on the other hand, are completely devoid of microorganisms that travel through the air. allergies is a north american thing, virtually unknown to other parts of the world.

EDIT: AC and the recycled air is the actual point of this comment. fluids was the joke, apologies to offended. north america breathes AC recycled air. no one else does. at least not to this extent. at the same time, one of the standard conversation topics amongst immigrants (to NA) is "wtf does everyone here have allergies and what are they anyway?". until they develop their own after living here for a number of years.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Saturday March 10, 2018 @09:17AM (#16558541)
I never cleaned much before. I think the key is that I now get rid of some nasty allergens very efficiently (e.g dust mites or diesel fumes with my air filter) and I don't spread around artificial fragrances.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by smaili on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:11PM (#16555872)
Care to point to Amazon(or other sites) product pages? May be useful for some of us looking to buy.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by bitwize on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:52PM (#16556125)
Windex sells lactic acid cleaner readily available in stores. It's the yellow stuff, it looks like pee but it does the job.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by Paperweight on Saturday March 10, 2018 @04:54PM (#16560370)
Almost all household cleaning sprays use lactic acid. Its smell is less irritating than acetic acid, so presumably you can inhale more of it until you cough...
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by seanmcdirmid on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:34PM (#16556330)
Is that the same as windex vinegar? That’s what we use as our low-level cleaning agent.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by skj on Friday March 09, 2018 @09:35PM (#16556786)
Vinegar is acetic acid.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by bitwize on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:53PM (#16557005)
Nah, the vinegar is the clear stuff. The yellow stuff is labeled "Windex Multisurface" I think (no "with Vinegar") and is clear yellow, not perfectly clear.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by tarp on Friday March 09, 2018 @09:03PM (#16556688)
My friend started a company that sells high pH water for cleaning/disinfecting. https://phurwater.com/science/
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by GavinMcG on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:32PM (#16556938)
What on earth is high pH water? Water has a pH. If something has a high pH it's not water.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by mirkules on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:49PM (#16556993)
According to the company's documentation it is basically (hah!) a pH 11-12.5 solution of sodium hydroxide, aka lye: http://phurwater.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/MSDS-Cleaner...

You can call this water insomuch that it contains water (kind of like wine)

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by kerkeslager on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:59PM (#16557022)
So basically, you can pay $22 to have them mix an unknown amount of NaOH into 32oz of water, or you can buy 5 lbs of NaOH off Amazon for $19[1] and mix it into water yourself. A lifetime supply of "phurwater" for less than the price of a single bottle, without even shopping around--this was the first search result on DuckDuckGo.

What incredible crap.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Grade-Sodium-Hydroxide-Micro-Beads/dp...

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by Karunamon on Saturday March 10, 2018 @12:07AM (#16557184)
200 PPM if their MSDS[1] is to be believed, but damn. This is the best marketing I've ever seen for the most inane product this side of a dodgy ICO.

[1]: http://phurwater.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/MSDS-Cleaner...

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by raverbashing on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:57PM (#16557159)
"A fool is born every minute..."
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by DanBC on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:31AM (#16557964)
> Product Description: 0.02% Sodium Hydroxide Solution generated Electro-Chemically from Diluted Brine
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by hartator on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:26PM (#16555983)
I am curious as well what steamer and products you are using?
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:55PM (#16556138)
I use a Kärcher SC3 steam cleaner. It's cheap (~€100) and pretty good. Even the SC2 is decent. As an alternative, Polti high-end ones are excellent. They invented domestic steamers, and I've seen some used at hospitals. The have accessories for e.g. steaming your mattress to get rid of dust mites.

I use a Miele C3 Silence vacuum cleaner. It's the cheapest (~€220) Miele vacuum cleaner that has top (A class in EU) filtration. More expensive models just buy you more accessories. Sadly, Mieles are super expensive in the US, and you can't do arbitrage due to different voltage. Nilfisk made in Denmark used to be extraordinary, but now they are pretty mediocre. /u/touchmyfuckingcoffee is a very famous vacuum technician in Reddit, and he recommends Miele and Riccar. He doesn't like bagless. Neither do i. Worse filtration and a mess to dispose if you are allergic.

I use a Coway 1008 DH air filter. It's cheap (€400), efficient, and uses low energy. IQAir has great reputation, but in some tests it has shown mediocre performance [1]. Perhaps these tests are not measuring particles in the smallest range, where IQAir claims to excel. I've seen some guys from IQAir at HN, perhaps they can clarify.

For house cleaning I use stuff from Sonett. Bio-D is also good, cheaper and easier to find. I also use probiotics from Chrisal. In the US, these might not be easy to find. I'm sure there are equivalent brands there. Check their ingredient lists. Bio-D cleaning stuff is so safe their hand soap is basically the same formula as their countertop cleaner. Many items are certified by Allergy UK.

I'm happy to hear any other recommendations from fellow allergics. I also found a two-stage filter for my shower (Sprite + Vitamin C Sonaki) did wonders to avoid spraying chlorine into my airways and reduce inflammation and itchiness.

[1] https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-air-purifier/

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by danieldk on Saturday March 10, 2018 @02:07AM (#16557505)
I use a Kärcher SC3 steam cleaner. It's cheap (~€100) and pretty good. Even the SC2 is decent.

I'd like to add a me-too. We bought a Kärcher SC3 to remove old wallpaper when we moved to another apartment (IIRC the price of hiring a steamer for a couple of days made buying one attractive). We use it now to clean our tiled floors, the bathroom, etc. and it has been excellent. The hot steam removes most stains without much effort, it works without detergents, and it is far less work than mopping the floor.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by bosie on Sunday March 11, 2018 @05:58AM (#16562387)
Can you use it to clean something like the counter top of the kitchen and non-tile floors (i.e. wood or laminated floors)?
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by danieldk on Sunday March 11, 2018 @05:09PM (#16564797)
I don’t know. We have used it twice or so on laminated floor, but I don’t know the longer-term effects. Most of the surface in our apartment is tiled.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by innagadadavida on Saturday March 10, 2018 @10:04AM (#16558720)
Do the steam cleaners work with hard water? Our area has really hard water and I need to use a reverse osmosis filter even for our humidifier otherwise the scaling is really bad and accumulates quickly.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Saturday March 10, 2018 @11:07AM (#16558970)
The SC3 comes with a cartridge that claims to soften water and reduce issues.

In any case, they use little water. Like 1 tank for 90 m^2. You can always buy distilled water, or use water from your osmosis filter.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by terraforming on Sunday March 11, 2018 @04:53AM (#16562246)
Can you share the source for "that has top (A class in EU) filtration" please? I might be buying a new vacuum soon and would like to research it well before doing so.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Monday March 12, 2018 @09:20AM (#16567934)
Most online ads in EU include this information. Check e.g. Amazon UK or DE. Or manufacturers websites.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by vymague on Saturday March 10, 2018 @05:27AM (#16557958)
I wonder, what's your opinion about DIY air filters? Like a box fan plus a furnace filter. Both are not common in Europe, but you could get a different type of fan, and affordable HEPA filters from aliexpress.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Saturday March 10, 2018 @10:01AM (#16558710)
Good air filters are complex, not just an HEPA filter, but a series of stages. And an active carbon filter for chemicals.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by opencl on Saturday March 10, 2018 @12:55PM (#16559412)
What are these complex things they do that are anything but shoving air through a filter with a fan? How do they justify costing hundreds more than taping a HEPA filter+carbon filter to a fan yourself?

The product page for the model recommended in that wirecutter article even has a cutaway view, showing that it's just a HEPA filter + carbon filter + fan.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by peferron on Saturday March 10, 2018 @09:07PM (#16561322)
They look better than DIYs, are typically quieter for the same cfm, and optionally have an automatic mode where the fan speed changes based on the detected air quality.

But yeah if you don't care how they look or how noisy they are just assemble one yourself and blast it on max. That's what I did for two years in China and it worked (had a separate particle counter to measure PM).

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by opencl on Sunday March 11, 2018 @09:59AM (#16563008)
Glad I'm not missing out on too much with the DIY setup, quiet would be nice though. And the auto mode certainly explains a fair chunk of the price, air quality meters seem to run at least $100.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by vymague on Saturday March 10, 2018 @11:56AM (#16559196)
But I thought it has been shown putting simple furnace filter on a fan is good enough. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kH5APw_SLUU

Are you talking about other filters to filter the larger particles, and carbon filters? Because aliexpress sell them too.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by hartator on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:17PM (#16556230)
Thanks man! What do you think about the Hepa filters in Roomba robot vacuums?
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:24PM (#16556268)
As far as I can see, they have dust reemission class B in EU, which means they are OK, but probably leak some particles.

It's understandable. On a small machine with little power, if they put a better filter (more resistance) the vacuum is not going to have much suction.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by stephengoodwin on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:45PM (#16556092)
When you say that you clean with a steamer, do you mean something like a garment steamer?
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by nextos on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:08PM (#16556189)
See my post below. The principle is similar, but implemented on a device for that purpose: a steam cleaner. There's also a cloth attached to scrub dirt. Hospitals use this regularly.
Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by dghughes on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:36PM (#16557116)
I recall reading an article a few years about the aerosolization of minerals in the water vapour and how inhaling them cause lung damage.

It could have been a tabloid-ish thing I don't recall where I read it but I often think about it when I am enjoying a hot shower.

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by noja on Sunday March 11, 2018 @04:37AM (#16562220)
> I clean with a steamer

What about mold?

Re:Cleaning sprays have an impact on lung health comparable ... by Broken_Hippo on Sunday March 11, 2018 @06:37AM (#16562478)
If you are using the steamer regularly, this shouldn't be an issue (after all, they use steamers to get rid of mold and the temperature is enough to kill most molds). If you are going to let it sit for a while between uses, care for it properly, including letting all the hoses and implements dry completely.