News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by andrepd on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:29AM (#16552359)
As opposed to: gold/silver/diamonds mining (greater energy and human cost), arms manufacturing (orders of magnitude larger industry), etc. Why single out bitcoin (which is actually offering a useful service that critically needs PoW to work)?
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by wffurr on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:29AM (#16552840)
Clearly the parent doesn't believe Bitcoin to be a useful service. I agree with you that precious metal mining and arms manufacturing are also not useful services, except insofar as some precious metals are used to make useful things.

I think it's fair to say "Bitcoin is wasting energy" does not necessarily imply other useless things don't also waste energy given that this whole conversation and article are about Bitcoin.

The fact that huge sums of money, energy, and human time is also wasted on arms manufacturing doesn't make Bitcoin mining somehow a good thing.

Your kind of argument is called "Whataboutism": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by andrewla on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:56AM (#16553034)
The argument being challenged is a comparison -- "... is used for such purposes" that clearly make the point that this purpose is a bad one. That is, the argument is "this use of energy is worse than most others".

It is not specious to confront the argument head-on. If someone says "I am the strongest person in the world" and you say "what about that guy over there", you are not engaging in a useless rhetorical device, you are making a valid counterpoint to the original point.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by wffurr on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:38PM (#16555279)
Except that it's not a comparison, it's a statement about Bitcoin, not those other things, which is the key element that makes it whataboutism instead of a valid counterpoint.

Bitcoin mining is wasting energy.

Other potential uses of such wasted energy include not generating it in the first place.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by pharke on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:54AM (#16553023)
And yet an argument such as this does serve a purpose. It draws attention to the larger follies we commit. It may even give a better perspective from which we might see a common cause for such behaviour.

Rather than shutting a conversation down with cries of "off topic" or "fallacy" (I'm addressing the crowd moreso than you in particular) maybe we should all be looking towards the question of why all of us have a propensity for wastefulness? Surely, some waste is necessary when figuring out new processes or keeping old ones up to date but is there a way we can reduce waste without reducing or putting limits on innovation?

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by s73v3r_ on Friday March 09, 2018 @12:11PM (#16553141)
Except the purpose of a "Whataboutism" type argument is to shut down the conversation.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by breatheoften on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:43AM (#16552930)
I generally find 'Whataboutism' to be an incredibly annoying form of argument. Sometimes though there are useful arguments about priorities of the form: 'x is a problem but y is such a larger problem that spending time and energy on x instead of y is actually an additional problem'. Is there a useful strategy to help distinguish such an argument from 'Whataboutism' when constructing such an argument?

(Note: I don't think the grandparent's argument is of this form as there don't seem to be any obvious shared constrained resources which could be applied to reduce precious metal mining that are instead directed at reducing bitcoin mining ... I'm curious though if you have any suggestions for how to shift one's thinking when _trying_ to make an argument about priorities so as to help prevent oneself from making arguments that amount to whataboutism ...)

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by walrus01 on Friday March 09, 2018 @05:41PM (#16555678)
I can see how the OP visualizes mining as wasteful. But it's easy to forget how much energy is consumed by resistive electrical heating.

Using British Columbia as an example, which until recently had very cheap electricity relative to North America as a whole, for many years a huge number of apartments, condos and houses were built with resistive electrical heating as the default option.

Laws of thermodynamics say that if a hashing ASIC isn't doing physical work, it's producing a huge amount of waste heat. The problem is that waste heat is being vented into the atmosphere rather than being used to heat offices, homes and warehouses. I know there's a few startups that have tried to produce cryptocurrency-mining waste heat appliances that can be installed in decentralized locations. Not sure how successful they have been.

If the waste heat can be used from October to April to heat offices, homes and other things that consume vast amounts of electricity via resistive heating (swimming pools, etc), it would accomplish both the function of hashing and heating.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by croon on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:44AM (#16552481)
I could of course be wrong or ignorant, but I have yet to see a single application that isn't speculation, save a few that uses it as currency transfer but using centralized nodes, meaning they could just use any much cheaper sharded data storage.

I don't doubt theoretical applications, I'm just saying everything thus far has been hype and cluster"%#&s.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by scotty79 on Friday March 09, 2018 @02:25PM (#16554200)
People need something to put money in. They work, they run a surplus. They need to keep it somewhere. You could keep your local currency or buy some other but hyperinflation is a thing and also plain inflation can eat your money in few decades. You could buy property but it can be bothersome to pick, buy, hold and sell. You may end up with a loss if you are unlucky or need money back quick. You could buy gold but it can be easily stolen.

People need gold but better. Bitcoin is just that assuming bitcoin network survives.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by croon on Friday March 09, 2018 @08:18PM (#16556531)
> You could buy gold but it can be easily stolen.

So can your bitcoin wallet, or you could forget your key or lose your hard copy.

> People need gold but better.

Debatable.

> Bitcoin is just that assuming bitcoin network survives.

No, you can fork bitcoin, or create a thousand slightly different blockchains, and you can replace it in the blink of an eye. However weird gold is, it is a finite resource with real world applications (albeit not unique for most of them).

And I'm sure you can buy a number of funds or stocks backed by gold, if that's your thing. But you also have thousands of other stocks and funds, and real estate, and micro financing, etc where your money can both work for you while also potentially benefiting the world. Bitcoin without any application is a pyramid scheme, by definition. You put money in, to take money out later when more people have entered the system.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by scotty79 on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:22PM (#16557077)
> So can your bitcoin wallet, or you could forget your key or lose your hard copy.

You can also encrypt your wallet, put it in few public places on internet and not forget a key. And be completely safe. Gold is much harder to secure.

>> People need gold but better. > Debatable.

People always need better versions of things they already have.

> No, you can fork bitcoin, or create a thousand slightly different blockchains, and you can replace it in the blink of an eye.

It has already happened, didn't replace bitcoin.

> However weird gold is, it is a finite resource with real world applications (albeit not unique for most of them).

Real world applications of gold don't justify any significant fraction of its price. Most of the value comes from scarcity and durability, properties that bitcoin has. Again assuming bitcoin network doesn't die.

> But you also have thousands of other stocks and funds, and real estate, and micro financing, etc where your money can both work for you while also potentially benefiting the world.

When you buy bitcoin you also pass money around to people that need it more than you at the moment.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by ryanlol on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:23AM (#16552801)
>meaning they could just use any much cheaper sharded data storage.

There are a plenty of regulatory reasons why this is simply not true. Cryptocurrencies may sound stupid from a technical point of view, but clearly they have a bunch of very real advantages over e.g. liberty reserve.

Edit: I guess I'll be waiting for Show HN: MongoDB based money laundering platform. :)

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by thedaemon on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:36AM (#16552424)
I would really like to upgrade my GPU, but currently it's impossible as the bitcoin miners have caused the prices to sky rocket into unobtainable pricing.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by DarronWyke on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:30AM (#16552847)
I had to buy mine direct from the manufacturer for MSRP for a new build.

Still cheaper than Newegg/Amazon/etc.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by samueldavid on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:43AM (#16552931)
how did you do it?
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by DarronWyke on Friday March 09, 2018 @12:03PM (#16553082)
Bought direct from EVGA. Check their websites, many of them offer them direct for sale. They may be out of stock so you'll have to do a notify.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by walrus01 on Friday March 09, 2018 @05:37PM (#16555648)
to be more specific bitcoin mining is not driving up your GPU pricing (bitcoin has been uneconomical on GPUs for years, since the advent of dedicated purpose hashing ASICs), but it's ethereum mining and other cryptocurrencies that can still be mined on GPUs that are influencing the price.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by feintruled on Friday March 09, 2018 @12:31PM (#16553302)
I know! I was browsing for one and all the mid-range cards are out of stock, only low-end and super high-end are available. What a ridiculous situation.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by jonknee on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:32AM (#16552389)
What useful service? Scams as a service?
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by waynecochran on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:38AM (#16552438)
If it wasn't for all the speculation and grotesque scams surrounding it could actually be useful as a decentralized currency. But we can't have nice things.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by ianai on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:56AM (#16552574)
This might be a learning moment. Without government, aka anarchy, society would quickly devolve into bitter, cruel chaos.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by unknown_apostle on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:34AM (#16552873)
Long ago given up on cryptocurrency, at least as long as current technical problems exist. But that without government we'd devolve into "bitter, cruel chaos" is definitely not a lesson. That's "not even wrong" level stuff.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by ianai on Friday March 09, 2018 @12:17PM (#16553186)
Alright, you want me and the majority of society to take cryptocurrency seriously? Find a way to disallow or at least police illicit uses of it. Until you do that, I refuse to even entertain the idea that it’s a valuable asset and certainly not currency.

This is not a technical challenge I’m making. This is a political demand.

You would also still have to prove it’s more efficient and has a smaller carbon and energy footprint than traditional currency.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by sokoloff on Friday March 09, 2018 @12:41PM (#16553395)
Have we effectively disallowed or policed the illicit use of $100 bills for drugs, weapons, or other trade?

I agree with you that cryptocurrency is not currently particularly intrinsically useful, but I don't believe that "let everyone use it in a decentralized tamper-proof manner" fundamentally requires "and simultaneously restrict it from the following uses, which a subset of the global population deems undesirable".

(In that regard, it's similar to "regular" crypto. I don't mind that people I don't particularly like are also able to use crypto to secure their communications. It's essential to my use case that they not be able to intercept my comms, and I accept in return that I can't intercept their comms either.)

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by ianai on Friday March 09, 2018 @12:47PM (#16553439)
There are genuine attempts made to police those uses. In the case of USD, the US enjoys being the default global currency. That bad actors also use it is more of a side note alongside everyone using it.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by mjlangiii on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:35AM (#16552878)
What about cultures that didn't have centralized government like native Americans?
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by TheSoftwareGuy on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:55AM (#16553031)
They had various forms of government, depending on which particular tribe you are thinking of. Many had a theocracy, and some, like the Iroquois were part of a federation.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by netsharc on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:01AM (#16552622)
Before blockchains, I wondered about how to prove something on the internet. I thought about an authority that could hash any piece of data and you could query it. For example if someone claimed someone tweeted "X", the authority website could show that the hash is really from that Twitter account and is the sentence "X", or disprove it.

I didn't really think about distributed cryptographic "proof" and the chaining so you can't delete B from A - B - C and chain up A - C, indeed the authority would just have to be trusted and be somehow tamper proof.

Blockchain would be interesting to record the sequence of events you want to make sure people can't change retroactively, making it distributed means it's ecologically disastrous though.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by groby_b on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:48AM (#16552975)
Before Blockchains, most people who cared about cryptography were well aware of Merkle Trees. They date back to 1979.

Yes, there's also the proof-of-work part. We had that in 1999 with Hashcash.

The only thing bitcoin brought to the table was moving proof-of-work from a trusted hardware module to a P2P network.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by mywittyname on Friday March 09, 2018 @06:00PM (#16555794)
Easily moving money between countries. Not every country makes this as easy as it is in Europe.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by jonknee on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:53PM (#16556435)
There are a lot of ways to transfer money between countries and Bitcoin is one of the worst (sketchy exchanges, slow, huge spreads, etc). If you want easy try something like TransferWise.
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by onychomys on Friday March 09, 2018 @10:30AM (#16552369)
Well, offering a service, anyway. We could have a long debate about "useful".
Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by s73v3r_ on Friday March 09, 2018 @12:10PM (#16553133)
"which is actually offering a useful service that critically needs PoW to work"

That's hugely debatable.

Re:What Happens When Bitcoin Miners Take Over Your Town by pjc50 on Friday March 09, 2018 @11:32AM (#16552862)
Yes, those things are also bad. And entrenched and hard to stop.