News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by homonculus1 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:21AM (#16543104)
>A regimented dancelike experience, as in aerobics or Zumba, is fine, but unsupervised dance moves reek of hedonism, and working out is supposed to be a form of work. Most people come with a plan like “legs and shoulders today” or “forty-five minutes of cardio and fifteen minutes of abs,” usually preceded by a warm-up and topped off with several minutes of stretching on a mat.

>[Insert:] Despite the pulsing pop music and comfortable clothes, gyms are not sites of spontaneity and play.

>Working out very much resembles work, or a curious blend of physical labor and office work. Members not only lift weights, for example; they often carry clipboards on which to record the number of reps and sets and the amount of weight lifted for each workout, like a supervisor monitoring a factory worker’s performance.

God forbid people set goals for their bodies and approach them in an efficient, systematic manner instead of running around like children. This article is beyond useless, and there are few things I find more pathetic and loathsome than condescending social critics who squeeze other people's pursuits into their sentimental, rigor-averse narrative. Any lifestyle or socio-economic conclusions drawn from this set of assumptions about how a gym ought to be are just begging the question.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by dang on Thursday March 08, 2018 @12:03PM (#16545694)
This comment breaks the HN guidelines, specifically the one that asks you not to call names in arguments (e.g. "pathetic", "loathsome", "condescending"). I understand the temptation to do this—I have to resist it all the time myself, and sometimes succumb. But it really is just verbal discharge, not information. We're hoping for the opposite here.

Could you please (re-)read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the spirit of this site when commenting here? The idea is: if you have a substantive point to make, make it thoughtfully; if you don't, please don't comment until you do.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by wastedhours on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:41AM (#16543743)
It's something I butted up against several times in my previous role (hence now why I'm a "former" CMO...).

I worked at a group fitness company, really great concept which blends play and HIIT to create an inclusive, fun workout (essentially running around like children in sharp bursts, which is ultra effective). I kept trying to push the notion that we shouldn't be trying to convince people that they hate the gym, or that they should embrace group exercise when it's not right for them.

However, it's worth noting that broadly, the numbers back it up that the majority of people just don't like the gym regime. Churn, vacancy rates, MRR... all point to people trying to force themselves to do it, and then give up because they don't like it (50% will quit before 6 months - sure, it might be they achieve their goals in that time, but attendance rates would probably indicate otherwise).

My main critique of the piece is the lack of awareness that things like Zumba are specifically group exercises, randomly dancing in a normal gym is like body-popping in a morgue - if that's what you want to do, do it in a different place.

As ever with opinion pieces like the article, one person bemoaning other people's workouts isn't helpful. It's almost as if we are an amazingly diverse species with different drivers and motivations, isn't it?

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by lolc on Thursday March 08, 2018 @04:03AM (#16543247)
> running around like children

> their sentimental, rigor-averse narrative

Me, I experience a positive correlation between gym-affinity and tediousness in the people I meet.

> there are few things I find more pathetic and loathsome than condescending social critics

Do you perchance derive a feeling of superiority from your rigorosity?

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by igor47 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:36AM (#16543729)
ah, the knife cuts both ways. do you perchance enjoy a feeling of superiority when you use the term "sportsball"? how much more cerebral and refined you must be than those sweaty grunts!

i find people who spend their days "coding for fun" or whatever tedious, but i don't attempt to ascribe their habits to sinister cultural forces or paint them as self-obsessed egotistical narcissists

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by eadmund on Thursday March 08, 2018 @08:41AM (#16544230)
> do you perchance enjoy a feeling of superiority when you use the term "sportsball"?

Yes, because I'm a grown man who doesn't feel a deep emotional need to watch a bunch of men wearing spandex running around on some grass.

Playing sports is a really awesome thing, and everyone should do it. Enjoying the occasional game is probably okay. Following sports is IMHO a kind of mentally unhealthy extended adolescence.

> i find people who spend their days "coding for fun" or whatever tedious

I am tedious — but fortunately we live in a world where people with my kind of tedious personality are well-rewarded for our skills. A few centuries ago and no doubt I'd have starved to death.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by lolc on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:36AM (#16543956)
As is evidenced by my comments I'm more refined than anybody else around here! Myself included.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by homonculus1 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @02:21PM (#16546853)
>Do you perchance derive a feeling of superiority from your rigorosity?

Guess again, I haven't been to the gym in some time so my ego isn't at stake here. I look down on this article precisely because it couches a malicious attack in pseudo-innocent terms, not because it has anything to do with me.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by lolc on Friday March 09, 2018 @04:42AM (#16550718)
What is the attack? And what is malicious about it?
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by hnuser1234 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:56AM (#16543222)
Author seems rather self-aware, article is filed under /outbursts/.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by verylittlemeat on Thursday March 08, 2018 @04:07AM (#16543256)
If you don't like to exercise just don't do it. You don't need to come up with a cultural conspiracy to feel secure about not liking the gym.

I've run into people like this before who feel personally attacked because they "don't understand" why person likes X. It's always invariably something they think their culture is saying is good so they have to fire preemptive strikes against others (who are just trying to have a good time) for the sake of their own ego. Rather than shitting in other people's cornflakes why not just find something you do enjoy?

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by gaius on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:08AM (#16543646)
I've run into people like this before who feel personally attacked because they "don't understand" why person likes X. It's always invariably something they think their culture is saying is good so they have to fire preemptive strikes against others (who are just trying to have a good time) for the sake of their own ego

I’m reminded of the backlash against the “beach body ready” ad.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by apatters on Thursday March 08, 2018 @05:56AM (#16543605)
The article is ranty but I thought she made an interesting point. I'd like to exercise more but fitness fanatics--OK I'll be polite, enthusiasts take it all really, really seriously. The gym is not fun to me, all the structure is not fun, if I say this a lot of fitness enthusiasts will turn up their nose and basically suggest that I'm an inferior life-form who should just MAN UP and do the work(out).

I work enough as it is, can I do a playout instead?

It's like one personality type has a lock on the whole habit. Maybe a more fun approach could draw in other groups of people.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by verylittlemeat on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:09AM (#16543648)
I hope this doesn't come across as dismissive because I am genuinely curious: where are you interacting with these vocal fitness people? Because when I go to the gym I would say 95% of people are in their own world and wearing headphones. I've been going to the gym for 3 years and I don't think I've talked to another person there beyond "are you using this equipment" more than a handful of times.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by stillsut on Thursday March 08, 2018 @02:53PM (#16547114)
I think these obnoxious people are experienced outside the gym - there's one or two at your office, one of two in your wife's friends, one of two of your old college friends. When the conversation turns to what's new in their life, or how's their day going, they recount their fitness ordeals.

Also outside of the classic gym - yogies, spinners, crossfitters - tend to be more social and evangelical during and after their workouts.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by Sinnesloschen on Thursday March 08, 2018 @09:16AM (#16544421)
I think what your describing is gate keeping.

I've noticed this phenomenon as well I refer to it as working out in the prison yard. Everyone looks super serious and can't smile cause I might get shanked.

One suggestion to add on to what the others have said is find maybe a sport like tennis, racquetball, dodge ball, kickball and join a league. You'll meet people who take things seriously and you'll meet people that are having fun, ignore and lose to the serious people and laugh/learn from the having fun types. Find a buddy that has a similar mentality to exercise and go do goofy things in or out of the gym.

Also try a trampoline park(like Get Air). I work out several times a week lift weights, cardio, etc. Nothing was more sweat inducing than taking my kids to a trampoline park for an hour, I needed days to recover from under used muscles I didn't even know I had.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by crazy1van on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:40AM (#16543973)
>can I do a playout instead?

Of course. That's why people do activities like hiking, tennis, surfing, basketball, biking, etc. For many people they are just fun activities that also help with fitness.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by eesmith on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:15AM (#16543670)
My experience has been that there are many different personalities.

Someone who goes to the gym to set PRs in weight lifting is going to be different than someone going spinning in winter to stay in condition for cycling in summer.

Also, different gyms have different styles. One gym I went to didn't have the largest weights because the owner felt that the people interested in that level of strength training would be better served at a different gym. This was also the gym where one of the members would practice his break dancing moves.

He later sold the gym to a chain, and the personality and member base changed. It went from a place I enjoyed going, with fun dance workouts, to the more "regimented dancelike experience" of licensed choreography, and their own line of exercise clothes and foods. I left that gym.

So, perhaps there's another gym that better fits what you want?

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by bitwize on Thursday March 08, 2018 @08:33AM (#16544191)
Here's how I see it -- and I don't like gymbros either. I once worked alongside a Crossfitter who worked out at noon, and once he'd changed out of his dirty, sweaty things, hung them over the supports of his desk to air them out, forcing me to lay down a protective barrier of spray Lysol to avoid choking on the fumes. So going to the gym is definitely not a core part of my identity, especially since I don't want to be that guy.

But I still do it. I've been out of it for a couple months and am trying to get back. I have to be somewhat systematic about it for two reasons: a) I have to do the proper lifts with the proper form; b) my body parts get tired and need a couple days' recovery before they're ready to go all out again so I have to do at least a two day split. But yeah, other than that it's just a matter of showing up, and finding and settling into a groove. I gamify it a bit: can I set a PR in squats today? Some days I'm just not feeling it, and I go home telling myself, well, at least you put in the work.

I think there have already been a lot of attempts to make workouts "fun", and the problem really is that the approaches that have worked, i.e, produced good fitness results, turn people into enthusiasts. CrossFit is notorious for being "cult-like" but it has inspired plenty of people -- especially women -- to get into fitness in a really hardcore way.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by scottlegrand2 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @09:23AM (#16544463)
As someone who has been working out for the past 30 years, I consider the gym to be a commons. What ruins it for me are people who reenact the tragedy of that commons.

There's the guy who takes three towels and hogs three machines at once and gets all shirty if you ask to use one of them while he's elsewhere. Then there's the Iron Man who leaves at least 300 pounds of weights on a barbell after he's done with his sets. And there are the wolf packs of either women or dudes that alternate on a machine for 45 minutes straight exchanging war stories about WTFEver and not letting anyone work in with them.

I approach the gym like I approach work: as something to be done as quickly and efficiently as possible. One of them benefits my body and the other benefits my wallet. But even then, I genuinely enjoy a good run outside on a beautiful trail in the early evening or morning.

And all that said, I'll take my grim ritual over the sciatica, lack of endurance, and general lack of health I had previously.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by H1Supreme on Thursday March 08, 2018 @10:00AM (#16544672)
Your story is a big part of why I invested (Probably $1,000 over 11 years) in some equipment for home. Just the basics. Squat rack, bench (two now), barbell, and weights. I realize this isn't an option for everyone. But, for those who can, and also can't stand people like three towels guy, it's a good alternative.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by mercurysmessage on Thursday March 08, 2018 @09:35AM (#16544538)
There already are more fun approaches, and have been for awhile. Do combat sports, Judo, Boxing/Kickboxing and BJJ. Any of those will give you a fantastic workout.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by dwaltrip on Thursday March 08, 2018 @10:03AM (#16544692)
You should try rock climbing gyms. It's a really fun way to workout.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by te_chris on Thursday March 08, 2018 @04:22AM (#16543306)
No one forced you to read it.
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by zaarn on Thursday March 08, 2018 @05:08AM (#16543458)
"Don't like, don't read" and similar statements aren't a counter argument. (I usually do see them on fanfiction websites though)

Criticism of an article is totally valid, there are plenty of frontpage HN posts where people disagree with an author in the comments. And that's good, the author put out this article precisely because they wanted someone to read it and think about it (even if they disagree afterwards) (atleast most proper blog authors and journalists do that for think-pieces and commentaries)

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by te_chris on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:20AM (#16543687)
"If you don't like to exercise just don't do it. You don't need to come up with a cultural conspiracy to feel secure about not liking the gym."

I agree with you, I was merely replying to absurdity with absurdity.

Parent's criticism challenged the existence of the piece, not the substance.

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by verylittlemeat on Thursday March 08, 2018 @08:28AM (#16544165)
The substance of the article is so thin it would be hard to criticize it without questioning its existence. I wasn't being facetious, the author seems to really believe that exercising at the gym is a moralizing corporate conspiracy.

Why should anyone take that premise seriously when every school age child knows that humanity has valued athleticism and fitness since at least the time of Ancient Greece?

Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by verylittlemeat on Thursday March 08, 2018 @04:26AM (#16543323)
I read it because the title seemed interesting and I was willing to give the author the benefit of the doubt. What does that have to do with my criticism of it?
Re:Body Work: The curiously self-punishing rites of fitness ... by mercurysmessage on Thursday March 08, 2018 @09:30AM (#16544507)
Also, if you don't want to work out at a traditional style gym and want something more fun, just go do Judo, Boxing/Kickboxing, or BJJ.