News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by antoineMoPa on Thursday March 08, 2018 @12:53AM (#16542617)
Could someone tell me shortly what Vulkan brings over opengl? To me it seems that Vulkan is raising up the barrier to entry to Graphics programming by being even more complex than OpenGL but I hope this feeling will disappear as more code samples come out.
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by gpm on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:22AM (#16542700)
My first at all substantial graphics program (a ray traced 3d pong game with reflections, refraction, etc) was in Vulkan, not OpenGL. I don't have the most experience in this area, but I probably have a fairly unique viewpoint on this.

Vulkan is lowering the barrier for entry to graphics programming. It's doing this by not having hidden state. I don't have to remember what is stored where when I'm programming, I can follow the very fine spec as a pretty much step by step guide and get a working program. Practically every operation is simple, and only really cares about the arguments you pass it not some global state. This is very friendly to someone learning how it works.

It is raising the bar for implementing the "get a triangle onto the screen" part of the program, but that's not the hard part and never will be. It's also only raising that bar for crazy people like me who use Vulkan directly. In the future by the time Vulkan really takes over I expect it will lower the bar for that, since there will be nice libraries on top of it which deal with the "allocate everything" step for you (and maybe now, I don't know of any but I haven't searched... AMD has something I think).

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by geokon on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:56AM (#16543219)
Have you done anything with OpenCL? Because what a lot of people describe kinda sounds like OpenCL where there isn't really much global state or a predefined pipeline. On a high level you're just sending kernels to be executed on the GPU and you're free to organize things any way you like
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by gpm on Thursday March 08, 2018 @10:13AM (#16544777)
I haven't done anything with OpenCL, it's been on my "find an excuse to use this" list for awhile now.

I think you might be getting a false impression of Vulkan though. All the vertex shader, fragment shader, submit a buffer filled with geometry primitives, set depth clamping and filter triangles based on winding order, etc pipeline is still there, it's just much more explicit about how you are using it. There is also support for compute shaders that are more what I imagine OpenCL to be like. If you're doing traditional polygon rendering that's going to be slow. Even in my ray tracing project (that does most of the rendering in a compute shader), I imagine using OpenCL would have made it a bit of a pain to display the results realtime to the screen so people can actually play.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by geokon on Thursday March 08, 2018 @11:53PM (#16549878)
Thanks for clearing it up for me. So the pipeline is there but it's stateless... that sounds cool and I guess I really need to try it out. Using OGL a bit it definitely has this weird archaic feeling with all its state. I found it kind of fun and I didn't really shoot myself in the foot with it, but it definitely felt like "this is not how we write software now a days" haha
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by pjmlp on Thursday March 08, 2018 @04:40AM (#16543364)
> Vulkan is lowering the barrier for entry to graphics programming. It's doing this by not having hidden state.

This is OpenGL specific, there isn't an hidden state on other 3D APIs.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by rys on Thursday March 08, 2018 @05:08AM (#16543461)
That's not true. Direct3Ds up to and including 11 are the same way.
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by pjmlp on Thursday March 08, 2018 @05:28AM (#16543509)
Not really, COM instances for each 3D concept are created and passed around.

There isn't this thing of binding/copying stuff into global state.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by enqk on Thursday March 08, 2018 @10:32AM (#16544919)
What about this (only one example)

ID3D11DeviceContext::IASetVertexBuffers https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/desktop/ff4...

It's no different from manipulating the opengl context..

Also google bindless opengl

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by mellinoe on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:22PM (#16547321)
It's very different in practice.

D3D11 contexts are explicit, real objects that you create, manipulate, and pass around. They can be properly and realistically handled in multi-threaded code. OpenGL contexts are opaque and global, and properly handling them in multiple threads is a nightmare. Multiple OpenGL contexts is also very different in functionality from multiple D3D11 device contexts.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by sandov on Thursday March 08, 2018 @10:05AM (#16544712)
Is there another viable free & open source 3D API that I've not heard about?
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by slavik81 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:40AM (#16542762)
The OpenGL state machine is a giant set of hidden global data structures that you manipulate through opaque API calls. It's not very friendly, IMO. My hope is that with stable low-level APIs available, we can build new high-level APIs on top.

Historically, it's been a slow process to move to a newer graphics API, because you need to wait for all the hardware venders to implement it. Building that high-level API in userland means that basic quality-of-life improvements don't have to wait for hardware vendors to write new drivers.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by pizza234 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:53AM (#16544021)
There was an epic post from an NVidia developer:

https://www.gamedev.net/forums/topic/666419-what-are-your-op...

In brief: current APIs are a leaky abstraction, and a disproportionate amount of time is spent in debugging the curious "competition" between applications/libraries and drivers, at least, for relatively complex applications.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by __s on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:01AM (#16542640)
Searched ELI5 vulkan https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/4651a7/e...

Vulkan offers superior performance potential & avoids concurrency issues in GL. It achieves this by more closely matching its abstraction to GPUs as they are today. It also allows for simpler drivers, which should hopefully make for more consistent results

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by lucozade on Thursday March 08, 2018 @02:29AM (#16542930)
Vulkan is much lower level than OpenGL. It gives the user much more control, particularly around memory and thread management, at the expense of the user having to manage those pieces.

It has a much higher barrier to entry and will likely stay that way. What will presumably happen is that higher level APIs will emerge that abstract that complexity away.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by Lorkki on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:20AM (#16543100)
Vulkan is actually really close in scope to the vendor-specific APIs that OpenGL drivers use to communicate with the GPU. The intention from the beginning was that you would pick an appropriate higher-level abstraction (unless you're, say, making Unreal Engine and already retooled your OpenGL pipeline for the AZDO extensions).

The clear advantage over OpenGL is that those abstractions are debuggable and vendor-independent.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by exDM69 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @05:20AM (#16543489)
OpenGL is a terrible API with 25 years worth of legacy baggage. There are many ways of doing everything and a portable engine needs to support many methods for even the simplest of things because the newest and best methods aren't supported everywhere.

Vulkan is a much better designed API with a lot less legacy crap in it. It's lower level and gives more control to the app/engine developer.

The bad news is that Vulkan is a bit verbose, but this stops being an issue once you move past "hello world" level apps. OpenGL gets really difficult once you start doing complex things.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by megaman22 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @05:37AM (#16543551)
The multiplicity of ways to do everything in OpenGL was always a stumbling block for me in the past; it's been a big driver towards leaning in the direction of DirectX, or Monogame or Unity for cross-platform, in the past.

There still seems to be a lot of fragmentation from the handful of samples I've looked at so far; is there something like a canonical example of "the right way" to do things?

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by pjmlp on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:14AM (#16543855)
Yeah, first thing you have to do is dynamically collect extensions on program startup.

https://vulkan-tutorial.com/Drawing_a_triangle/Setup/Instanc...

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by exDM69 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @08:36AM (#16544209)
That's a bit dishonest way to put it. The situation with extensions has vastly improved w.r.t. OpenGL.

In the link you provided, it only needs to enable the appropriate window system extension. It also prints out some info about other extensions but that is not required.

It's a huge improvement that extensions need to be explicitly requested at init time.

It's massively better than OpenGL, and API extensions can't be completely avoided in a multi-vendor cross-platform API without limiting to lowest common denominator.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by pjmlp on Thursday March 08, 2018 @09:45AM (#16544593)
It doesn't look much different from OpenGL multiple execution paths for each GPU, and possible workarounds when they aren't available.

Specially given the amount of extensions that have been added since Vulkan was released.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by planteen on Friday March 09, 2018 @08:35AM (#16551593)
OpenGL ES 2.0 and higher cleans a lot of that up. Crufty old calls are removed. You simply include a header and link a library without the need for a complex loader (though there still are extensions).
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by zaarn on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:31AM (#16543149)
Vulkan is largely a successor to OpenGL and it's also a lot lower level. IMO it's primarly targeted at engine developers.

The lower level API also allows you to do things that OpenGL simply wouldn't allow, like driving multiple GPUs for one display output using your own abstractions.

DirectX12 is much in the same spirit (but not equivalent, they're still a lot different internally).

Vulkan will also (probably) bring better crossplatform support from Games since it's equally supported on Windows, Linux, Mac (with a library), Android and the Game Consoles. (There is OpenGL on Android but IIRC it's not quite the same)

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by HelloNurse on Thursday March 08, 2018 @04:03AM (#16543245)
In this case "lower level" means less messy, not less abstract, and more verbose, not more complex.

A lot of Of constraining and not very valuable parts of OpenGL were replaced with do-it-yourself, making the API "retreat" from advanced complex solutions to more general and more portable building blocks.

Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by agumonkey on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:45AM (#16543192)
from the few that I got: gpu drivers and api lied to each others, it lead to absurdly complex drivers full of bugs and absurdly complex codebase full of paranoid tricks to circle around the weird gpu behavior. Complete waste. Vulkan is a bit like RISC, makes it more "complex" but explicit, so in a way it's simpler.
Re:Vulkan 1.1 Released by dtech on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:13AM (#16543080)
Is OpenGL vs Vulkan really such a big difference for entry? I would think that most programming first experiences with graphics programming are through an engine or wrapper like Unity or SDL.