News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by quietbritishjim on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:18AM (#16536462)
If I'm an electrician on call-out to someone's home and, totally by accident, I discover someone tied up in their basement, should I report it to the police?

If I'm repairing someone's computer at their request and, totally by accident, I discover illegal material on it, should I report it to the police?

It seems pretty straightforward to me that you can, and in fact you really ought to. Maybe you disagree with what counts as "illegal" (like if didn't report finding pot in someone's home in a country where it's illegal) but that's a different discussion from whether this is generally reasonable behaviour.

Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by apocalyptic0n3 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:33AM (#16536596)
These people weren't being paid to find things "by accident" (or at least they weren't when this was first reported a year or two ago). They were being paid to look for what they suspected were crimes. This is more akin to an electrician being called in to rewire the kitchen, seeing a locked basement door, picking the lock, and rifling through the boxes in the basement to find illicit materials.

This was the FBI trying to skirt around the 4th amendment by having someone unrelated to the FBI do the seizure and search bit of investigating, so it could be done without a warrant. The problem is that the FBI both ordered and paid these people to do it, and I personally don't see a difference between that and having an FBI agent take your machine from you and perform the search themselves. There's also the ethical problems for Best Buy, plus the incentive (payment) to create a crime (copy illicit materials or visit sites that would make it look like the person was going to do something illegal) and report it.

Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by snuxoll on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @10:40AM (#16537096)
> This is more akin to an electrician being called in to rewire the kitchen, seeing a locked basement door, picking the lock, and rifling through the boxes in the basement to find illicit materials.

Which still produces admissible evidence. Government agents are bound by the constitution when it comes to searches, private individuals are not. There can be other clauses in a state's constitution that enshrine an expectation of privacy that may be usable to dismiss such evidence, but as far as federal law and the US constitution is concerned a private individual can break a window into your house, find illicit materials, report them to the police and some time later you are sitting in court defending yourself.

> This was the FBI trying to skirt around the 4th amendment by having someone unrelated to the FBI do the seizure and search bit of investigating, so it could be done without a warrant.

Yup, and now that there's evidence such reports are being rewarded they screwed that up. If a government employee requests or incentivizes you to perform a search on their behalf you become an agent of the government for the purposes of that search, 4th amendment applies and if such activity is discovered the evidence is inadmissible. Incredibly stupid move of the FBI.

Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by manjushri on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:23AM (#16536504)
The "totally by accident" excuse is not valid when people are paid bounties to conduct vigilante surveillance. How much money would it take for someone in need to plant evidence?
Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by jbigelow76 on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:30AM (#16536569)
Anybody dumb enough to go source a bunch of kiddie porn to plant on computers to collect bounties probably doesn't have the smarts to actually pull it off correctly.
Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by piracykills on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:26AM (#16536534)
For sure you should - but if you're incentivized to find such a thing, what's to say you won't leave some drugs hidden in their basement yourself? If the pay off was high enough, especially with young, generally low wage employees it might be quite tempting.
Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by quietbritishjim on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:30AM (#16536568)
That's a fair point.
Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by Lewton on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:20AM (#16536471)
> totally by accident

not an accident if you're paid to do it

Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by mfoy_ on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:24AM (#16536509)
The article does not clarify the nature of the payment.

It's not clear whether or not he knew he would get paid when he reported it.

It's not necessarily that the FBI has an arrangement with technicians to snoop around.

Re:Geek Squad staff 'paid by FBI' to flag illegal imagery by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @09:34AM (#16536601)
It really depends. I can imagine this incentive was started because either employees came across images and didn't think much of it, or dismissed it because they didn't want to deal with the hassle. The article mentions a picture of a naked child; didn't mention any abuse or sexual acts, so it could be the owner's own, I mean just look at how many naked baby pictures are out there. It's a gray area then. With this incentive, it was reported; without it, the employee may have shrugged it off. I think they're incentivising "better be safe than sorry" with some monies.