Re:Ask HN: Can the US House and Senate be replaced with a we...
by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @05:18PM
(#16532604)
> But what happens when the citizenry decide that our class of informed representatives no longer serve their interest?
Change them; if the electoral system isn't very good at that, probably fixing that is a more reasonable fix then abandoning representative democracy.
Reserving some direct democracy powers but not forcing voters tombe full-time legislators (as many US states do) is a more extreme, but still reasonable step.
Re:Ask HN: Can the US House and Senate be replaced with a we...
by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @05:22PM
(#16532630)
> Change them; if the electoral system isn't very good at that, probably fixing that is a more reasonable fix then abandoning representative democracy.
In particular, an individual state can[1] change to preference voting (for example) without having to change the US Constitution.
[1] I think. IANAL, and still less am I a constitutional lawyer. There would almost certainly be a supreme court case by some election loser, claiming unequal representation or something. What the supreme court would do... I have no idea.
I would like to say that I do not necessarily feel this way, but I know a LOT of people who are slowly but steadily losing any faith they once had in our government. I know that switching to a direct democracy is drastic and would probably be a bad move, but I think we need to start finding ways to improve our current situation and that starts by asking questions.