News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Can the US House and Senate be replaced with a we... by qubex on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @03:36PM (#16531899)
Indeed... the whole point of representative democracy (or republic) is that one has a class of informed elected representatives of the citizens. These elected representatives think deeply about the issues at hand and construct coherent policies, something that a sequence of majority decisions are not necessarily able to achieve.
Re:Ask HN: Can the US House and Senate be replaced with a we... by ilovetux on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @05:12PM (#16532553)
But what happens when the citizenry decide that our class of informed representatives no longer serve their interest? That these elected officials only care about election and taking money from lobbyists. That our president is...but I digress.

I would like to say that I do not necessarily feel this way, but I know a LOT of people who are slowly but steadily losing any faith they once had in our government. I know that switching to a direct democracy is drastic and would probably be a bad move, but I think we need to start finding ways to improve our current situation and that starts by asking questions.

Re:Ask HN: Can the US House and Senate be replaced with a we... by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @05:18PM (#16532604)
> But what happens when the citizenry decide that our class of informed representatives no longer serve their interest?

Change them; if the electoral system isn't very good at that, probably fixing that is a more reasonable fix then abandoning representative democracy.

Reserving some direct democracy powers but not forcing voters tombe full-time legislators (as many US states do) is a more extreme, but still reasonable step.

Re:Ask HN: Can the US House and Senate be replaced with a we... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @05:22PM (#16532630)
> Change them; if the electoral system isn't very good at that, probably fixing that is a more reasonable fix then abandoning representative democracy.

In particular, an individual state can[1] change to preference voting (for example) without having to change the US Constitution.

[1] I think. IANAL, and still less am I a constitutional lawyer. There would almost certainly be a supreme court case by some election loser, claiming unequal representation or something. What the supreme court would do... I have no idea.