News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by darawk on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:03PM (#16524890)
It's disgusting to me that something like this could even be published in the NYT. Pensions are absurd financial instruments. Paying someone a percentage of their salary in perpetuity is financial nonsense, and creates all kinds of perverse incentives for the recipients. The only reason these things ever got popular in the first place is because they were a way of borrowing from the future to pay the present. Creating a massive latent risk that allows you to get cheap labor in the short term and exposes you to catastrophic failure on the backend. Corporations realized this decades ago and stopped using them.

If the problem is that 401k fees are too high, let's make 401k's more mobile. Let's create a liquid market in 401k managers so that fees get pushed towards zero - as they should be.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by tomc1985 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:08PM (#16524953)
Why? Pensions exist to serve retirees, not those retirees' former corporate masters. One of the only truly kind things an organization can do for an individual that serves them over a lifetime, and you would shit on it?

401(k) is a poor solution that requires individual initiative to deploy successfully. Those who don't contribute eventually burden those who do (even if that burden can potentially be paid for in advance, if you have the account type that taxes on deposit), and that's only if they withstood the lifetime of temptations that press people into early withdrawal.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by Kalium on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:12PM (#16524994)
You're absolutely right! Pensions exist to serve retirees, not their former overlords. Looking after the needs of the retired is the kind, decent, humane thing to do.

It's not about whose interests they serve so much as it is how sustainable and practical they actually are. Is it kind to make a commitment to someone around which they will organize their life at the cost of crippling the lives of their successors? What if that organization isn't a company, but a government, and the resulting costs cripple its ability to perform other functions? Is it kind to cripple a city's services or a school's ability to teach in order to meet pension obligations that were poorly planned for decades? Who will pay a company's pension bill if the pensions push it into insolvency?

These aren't trivial questions with easy, pre-baked answers. They also are real, pressing questions that face us today. Your heart is unquestionably in the right place - it's not about the investor class! It's about the retirees who have given their lives! But there might be some room for subtlety.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by tomc1985 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:13PM (#16525001)
You conflate mismanagement with the act itself...

I agree with you that increased lifespans throw a wrench in the works, but that is not enough of a problem to justify throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Pensions represent a HUGE portion of market actors' institutional conservatism and that is a necessary counterweight to the sort of irrational exuberance that is endemic to tech and other forward-thinking sectors

You want to talk about skyrocketing costs? Why not focus that energy on sorting out the mountains of institutional waste found elsewhere in the economy? Like, why the fuck does infrastructure here cost 10x other industrialized countries? Lots more money to be freed up that way

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by Kalium on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:15PM (#16525022)
In the US, public sector pensions have been mismanaged so frequently that no conflation is required.

EDIT:

Further, there's a basic accountability problem. It was - is - easy to gain politically in the short term by making promises about pensions. Promise bigger pensions, smaller contributions, and so on. The gains can be realized almost immediately. The price is paid much later, often decades later, and the people who made those unwise promises cannot be held to account so long after the fact.

For many states and cities, pensions act as a counterweight to the ability to do anything other than pay pension costs.

As before, you are absolutely right that there are mountains of waste to be investigated and addressed. You're completely right that there's a lot of money to be freed up there. Those issues are real, and they are pressing. Yet it is perhaps no more real or more pressing than the burden imposed by decades of financial mismanagement around pensions.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by tomc1985 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:55PM (#16525326)
Out of curiosity I checked my admittedly-boring hometown's financials for 2017, and found their pension spend to be less than 10% of overall budget for the year (though they note a pending crisis and potential doubling of pension expenses over the next few years).

Not knowing what other entities' books look like, and also knowing that one town is hardly representative, pension spend looks large (large enough that I'd guess many different types would like to optimize out of the equation) but not that large. How big of a crisis are we looking at -- 50% of total budgets? 30%? 20%?

You're right- mismanagement needs to be addressed. And I have no idea how to bring these firms to heel -- I just think that a market-based solution ("let them have 401(k)s!") is not the right answer here.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by Kalium on Monday March 05, 2018 @06:06PM (#16525405)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pensions_crisis#U.S._State-lev...

In general, underfunded pensions and large increases in expenses are a looming threat to many state and local governments. In California, many cities are expecting their pension costs to increase by 50% or more. Few have much in the way of spare cash to begin with.

It's not just the mismanagement of professional pension management funds, though you are of course right that that is a major concern. Broadly, the crisis is the result of applying unreasonable discount rates (8% or more) and making unrealistic promises about contributions and payouts. This is very, very easy to do when you're negotiating a union contract, as a state generally has little choice but to pay up when the time comes. It's also easy to do when you can bump up the assumed discount rate a bit and use the cash this frees up for goodies for your voters.

These weren't just poor management decisions made by self-interested private companies. Indeed, private pensions often assumed much less rosy discount rates and fared much better. These poor financial management decisions were quite often made by union leadership and local officials, some of them elected.

Sad to say, shifting from a defined-benefit system to a defined-contribution system seems to be the only way to guarantee that this particular form of politically expedient mismanagement will not recur. This doesn't have to be 401(k)s, 403(b)s, or other market-oriented system. But whatever the eventual system is, it clearly cannot look anything like the pensions of yesteryear. That system has failed, and the kindness and compassion and pure intentions at its heart has gone to waste.

Let there be no doubt - this is tragedy.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by afarrell on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:16PM (#16525040)
If a tool or user interface often prompts misuse, either alter human (group) psychology, or change the tool.
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by mfoy_ on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:15PM (#16525018)
The way I see it, there are three pension scenarios:

1. You are promised a pension and the company delivers.

2. You are promised a pension and the company does some creative accounting to screw you.

3. You are not promised a pension and plan for your own retirement accordingly.

4. You are not promised a pension and fail to plan for your retirement.

I don't believe #1 is reliable enough. Unless (and maybe even if) you are working for a government, your pension isn't rock solid. If you (more likely) run into #2 you end up betrayed, and have to scramble to make things work in your retirement.

I am 100% in camp #3. Plan for your own retirement-- No expectations; no disappointment.

Option #4? Well... there are consequences to your actions.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by phil21 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:20PM (#16525071)
I generally 100% agree with you. The problem with your stance (and mine) on #4 is that there aren't consequences to their actions.

Those consequences will inevitably be put on group #3 since they will be vilified as a group and it will be very easy to politically take their money to give to group #4.

I've not really figured out away around that problem. The numbers are simply too great too ignore - unless you truly feel something like 60% of retirees who have saved literally nothing other than their (meager) social security benefits will simply quietly die in the street.

Unfortunately this fact is one of the larger reasons why I feel this social division in the country is just starting, not coming to a head as most I talk to seem to think.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by typomatic on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:34PM (#16525183)
> Why? Pensions exist to serve retirees, not those retirees' former corporate masters. One of the only truly kind things an organization can do for an individual that serves them over a lifetime, and you would shit on it?

Morality left the building a long time ago in American capitalism--few consider there to be any real moral duty that a company owes its workers. If it's not in the contract, you're a sucker.

It's not a good way to run a polity as far as I can tell, but that's the program.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by ng12 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:13PM (#16524996)
> 401(k) is a poor solution that requires individual initiative to deploy successfully

That's why 401k's are good. I have control, and if my retirement is underfunded it's my own fault. Compare this to pensions (both public and private) which are chronically underfunded:

https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-state-pension-fundin... https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-corporate-pensions/

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by tomc1985 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:23PM (#16525104)
Except most don't. Many don't even have the opportunity, or realize that they have it. In a world where everyone takes advantages of all the opportunities presented to them I would agree with you, but for most (at least around me) 401(k) seems like afterthought or fantasy

If I don't have steady work the last thing on my mind is retirement...

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by ng12 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:30PM (#16525158)
And in that situation how does a pension help you? If you don't have a stable, well-paying job you don't have a stable, well-funded pension.

We need as better system for retirement but pensions are not the answer.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by tomc1985 on Monday March 05, 2018 @06:05PM (#16525394)
I can count the number of 401k holders in my social group with one or two hands. Many more than that set are employed, mostly semi-regularly, and their jobs offer them nothing retirement-wise

Pensions may not be the answer, but neither are retirement accounts.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by ng12 on Monday March 05, 2018 @06:14PM (#16525459)
If your job doesn't offer a simple 401k plan there's no hope for them offering a pension, let alone a stable well-funded one.

I agree with you that the future is murky for young people. That doesn't change my view that a 401k is preferable to a pension.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by zxcmx on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @04:15AM (#16527785)
I would recommend googling for "airline bankruptcy pensions" to see how this plays out in a lot of cases.

If pension liabilities get large enough, companies will tend to "go bankrupt" (not really!) or restructure in such a way as to shed the liability.

An interesting midpoint, I think is super in australia or kiwisaver in nz - mandated retiredment savings which can be invested in a choice of compliant funds (or self managed if you really want). Variable % contribution but a legal minimum. From a regulatory POV you can set these up with mandatory "employer" contributions and/or add government sweeteners. Of course, it's all part of your compensation, just like a pension promise but more direct and payable immediately.

I think these schemes also work more cleanly with modern reality: few people work for the same company for 30 years anymore.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by kolbe on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:15PM (#16525021)
I don't think there's too much of a difference between the sentiment of how you two want retirees to be treated. I think the main difference is that he respects people enough to believe they can plan for themselves, but you think they need to be coddled. But you both want them to have a prosperous and comfortable retirement.
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by Aunche on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:33PM (#16525182)
Pensions aren't done out of kindness. Their original purpose is to allow a company to underpay its employees until the employees retire in a few decades. By that time, the original investors have long since cashed out. It's essentially a free loan to them.
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by alecco on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:10PM (#16524981)
It's a ponzi-like system. When the population pyramid inverts it becomes insolvent. This is happening everywhere. Then the taxpayers have to foot the bill.
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by poster123 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:08PM (#16524943)
"Pensions are absurd financial instruments."

I don't agree. Retirees do need money as long as they live, which is what pensions (including Social Security) provide. Pensions needed to be properly funded, as the income annuities offered by insurance companies are.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by acchow on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:10PM (#16524971)
> as the income annuities offered by insurance companies are

To which kind of insurance are you referring?

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by colinsidoti on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:17PM (#16525055)
Deferred income annuities. They're insurance against your risk of longevity.

Here's an example from New York Life: https://www.nylinvestments.com/annuities/products/New-York-L...

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by poster123 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:17PM (#16525048)
Life insurance companies commonly sell various kinds of annuities as well, since they are experienced with pricing life expectancy. Google "immediate annuity" or "income annuity" to get quotes.
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by omegaworks on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:16PM (#16525045)
> It's disgusting to me that something like this could even be published in the NYT.

Just because the take is left-of-center and questions neoliberal doctrine, it shouldn't be publishable?

We were sold that privatization would lead to more efficiently run societal safety nets, that it would provide a net-benefit to the worker and to society. The article argues that not only did transition to 401k enrich money management middlemen, it's done worse: it's disenfranchised us. It's destroyed our ability to collectively act via our retirement funds.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by WaylonKenning on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:17PM (#16525049)
In New Zealand, we have Government Super, which is set to 65% of the net average wage (1).

Of course, this is expensive, which is why we have the Government putting aside money into a sovereign wealth fund to help pay for it (2).

We also know that we should personally contribute if we want a better retirement, so we have personal retirement accounts, where the minimum contribution is 3% of salary, matched with 3% from your employer, plus ~$500 NZD from the Government (3).

(1) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_in_New_Zealand#Superan...

(2) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Zealand_Superannuation_Fun...

(3) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KiwiSaver

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by pm90 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:12PM (#16524987)
That is a valid point. Pensions probably made a lot more sense when life expectancy was lower. Today? Not so much. Probably the reason why so many pensions went bankrupt.

401(k)'s do seem like a much better option. However not all employers provide that. I'm not sure what the solution is.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by Amezarak on Monday March 05, 2018 @06:30PM (#16525556)
Life expectancy at 65 has barely budged in the past 100 years (we gained about four years.) On top of that, for the past two years (2015 and 2016), it's decreased.
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by ceejayoz on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:10PM (#16524975)
Do you have similar concerns with annuities?
Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by mfoy_ on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:09PM (#16524964)
It's an Op-ed opinion piece...

Although, I agree pensions are... sub-optimal.

Re:The Investor Class Hates Pensions by thatswrong0 on Monday March 05, 2018 @05:36PM (#16525211)
NYTimes has been such a liberal rag lately