News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flash on Android is shockingly bad by marknutter on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @10:40PM (#1651630)
Well all things being equal, wouldn't it be better for the open-source solution to win out in the end?
Re:Flash on Android is shockingly bad by dantheman on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @11:05PM (#1651677)
html 5 is not a replacement for flash, not even close.
Re:Flash on Android is shockingly bad by ugh on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @11:20PM (#1651708)
HTML5 doesn’t need to have all capabilities of Flash. The Flash plugin might very well be relegated to Java plugin status (i.e. hardly ever used) while still being a lot more capable than HTML5.

All HTML5 has to capture are the most common use cases Flash is currently used for. Video? Sure deal. Audio? Looks like it will work. Animations? No problem. Infographics with light interactivity (like the stuff you find on nytimes.com)? Will work. Games? Hm, not so great. Audio and video capture? Let’s not talk about that. Oh, and restaurant websites? Shouldn’t have used Flash in the first place.

What’s important is what’s widely used, not what something is theoretically capable of. You are right that HTML5 is far from being able to match all the features of Flash. It doesn’t have to.

Re:Flash on Android is shockingly bad by rbranson on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @11:49PM (#1651768)
... and the platform won't survive long-term on free games and audio/video capture alone.
Re:Flash on Android is shockingly bad by ergo98 on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @02:37AM (#1652058)
Video has been a relatively recent use for Flash, where it pushed out QuickTime (which Steve stills stews over), MediaPlayer, Real Media Player, and others. It's always been an odd purpose for it, given that it's an ultra thin wrapper around a standard stream, so extracting that stream seems to be an obvious choice. Many "flash videos" are simply a h264 video consumed by an SWF, so decoupling that seems like a big advantage.
Re:Flash on Android is shockingly bad by megablast on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @11:28PM (#1651723)
A cup of noddles is no replacement for a four course dinner.

If HTML5 can do most of the important stuff that flash does, then fine. It already comes with a better supported programming language (javascript), with 1000s of libraries to supports it. It doesn't need to do everything.

And when Adobe releases support for exporting to HTML5 from flash, as they have been rumored to be doing, it will be looking like the end.