News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by Retric on Saturday March 03, 2018 @01:52PM (#16510849)
I have some doubt that the generations are that cleanly separated when doing genealogy. The if nothing else the youngest and oldest children of a couple can be 20+ years apart. The same person could easily show up as someones great grandparent (3) and their great great grandparent (4).
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by cgriswald on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:15PM (#16511325)
> if nothing else the youngest and oldest children of a couple can be 20+ years apart.

This isn't relevant to generations. My youngest sister is 21 years younger than I am. But we are both part of the same familial generation. My children and her children will also be part of the same familial generation. (This is irrespective of the fact that my sister is a millennial and I am not.)

> The same person could easily show up as someones great grandparent (3) and their great great grandparent (4).

In the case of the graphic, I suggest that they put each person at the highest possible place in the hierarchy and then simply extended the relationship line down in cases like this.

Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by Retric on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:54PM (#16511854)
Now fast forward 200 years and that clean separation you describe starts looking like a tangle as you and your sister marry people from different 'generations'.

Basically, if you want to understand how people actually behave you need to exclude the living as their relationships are going to be more complex than such neat abstractions suggest. It's only with dead people that you can really understand their life story after-all someone can get married at 25 and again at 95.

Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by totalZero on Sunday March 04, 2018 @01:25PM (#16515764)
What is your definition of "generation," and why do you refer to it as an abstraction? We are referring to generations as a structural parent-child term, where people on the same tier of the tree share the same generation. This is not the same as saying "Generation X/Y/Z" and so forth, which is a different meaning of the word entirely.
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by Retric on Sunday March 04, 2018 @08:28PM (#16518021)
I am deriving the second definition from the first.

Basically, as you start looking at the family tree that actually represents humanity the idea of generation breaks down, do you mean the shortest route from you to someone in ~100,000 BCE or the longest route to some person in ~100,000 BCE. You could say your mother's mother's mother's ... or your father's father's father's but even then the length of the chain going back that far stops being equivalent.

The only thing that becomes meaningful on such a scale is simply generation as unit's of time.

Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by totalZero on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @12:15AM (#16527024)
> I am deriving the second definition from the first.

That doesn't make any sense.

The first definition is a parent-child tree relationship. The second definition is a way to characterize the social atmosphere of a given span of twenty-some years. They are structurally different definitions that are not reconcilable.

Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by kbutler on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:15PM (#16511622)
Zoom in. You can see marriages (red dots) in the middle of green clusters.

They've just done some graph layout to make it look nice.

Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by ajmurmann on Saturday March 03, 2018 @02:54PM (#16511206)
In high school I sometimes hung out with a friend and his uncle. The uncle was two years younger than us.
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by batbomb on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:36PM (#16511732)
In high school I hung out with a lot of such people, but I went to high school in Utah. My best friend had 11 sisters and 3 brothers.
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by mikestew on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:03PM (#16511262)
I have an aunt that’s two weeks younger than I. Another aunt from that same mother is only six or seven years older than I. The fact that my Mom got started young with me is a contributing factor.
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by smellyindian on Saturday March 03, 2018 @07:28PM (#16512577)
Indian family trees in certain communities are like this. And in general, due to keeping in touch, or remaining in one particular geographic area, one hears stories like this quite commonly in India.
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by maxerickson on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:01PM (#16511252)
Are you talking about the graphic? I would guess they imposed some order on it, but I also sort of expect that the sort of thing you talk about doesn't happen all that frequently in different branches of a family tree.
Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by epistasis on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:01PM (#16511559)
No need to doubt the visualization, rare cases like that blend into the visual noise. And in fact, in the most ancient generations, where this problem would be more prominent, you can see far less delineation of the generations.

They can cluster the individuals (green) into hierarchical circles cleanly, then add a line that jumps over one generation, which would not be visible at the resolution of the plot.

Re:When Did Americans Stop Marrying Cousins? Ask the World’s... by bdcravens on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:28PM (#16512040)
Indeed. My wife and I are 40 and 41 respectively and are pursuing our first child via IVF. Meanwhile, some of her cohorts are now grandparents.