Ish. The NHS is remarkably cost-effective, but has relatively poor survival rates for cancer, stroke and myocardial infarction. International comparisons seem to damn the NHS with faint praise - it's cheap and the patients are happy, but it's not very good at keeping people alive.
http://www.qualitywatch.org.uk/sites/files/qualitywatch/fiel...
Smoking, drinking and obesity are all higher in the UK than in many other Western countries, and therefore the types and severity of these issues are likely incomparable.
Compound this with the cultural differences of the NHS (you don't go for a six-month check-up unless you're elderly, you just see a doctor when you're already ill), and the fact spending has been prioritised towards other areas (particularly paediatrics), you start to see a different story.
But there's also the fact the median age of the UK is relatively high. It's so good at keeping alive in younger years they get older and then develop cancer, stroke and heart disease/attacks later in life where they might be less survivable.
We all have to die of something. The NHS can't prevent that. What it can do is stop you having a lot of those issues earlier in life as in other countries and therefore the quality of life is improved.
If you want to see an area where it's proper shit, I would not start there: go with dental work, look at obesity prevention, etc. - that's where it's really lagging behind many other countries.
This is slowly changing, but it's generational. National-level screening initiatives also help: for example the Scottish NHS's national bowel cancer screening program. But when NHS England is facing real-terms cuts in spending, new long-term preventative stuff doesn't get rolled out.
The UK's was 81.1 years.
it's already like this, A&E is run on triage, "4 hours" is a target not an instruction
and if you go to A&E with something like a cold you'll be given a stern talking to and sent home
https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/general-election-2010/...
Yes and then sometimes that person dies as the recent case in the news about the girl with asthma who was told off for being late and sent home to die.
The NHS’s matronly they-know-better is a real problem of an effective state monopoly on healthcare. You can’t complain or take your business elsewhere. If they tell you to go home that’s it and there’s no other option.
https://news.sky.com/story/girl-5-died-after-doctor-turned-h...
Just like the American system, this is only useful for people who can pay for it.
Not even remotely true, if you don't mind paying. You can see a GP privately, there are already lots of apps which let you book appointments. A colleague had an ear problem, couldn't get an appointment with his local GP and so used one of these app-based services and got a same-day appointment with a doctor near the office.
If you go private and something happens during treatment they have to put you in an ambulance and take you to an NHS A&E.
For most ordinary people if the NHS tells you to go home that’s it you have to accept it. And people die because of this!
This is not to say that the NHS could not be better, but its problems would generally be made worse not better by introducing market or pseudo-market mechanisms. Unless universality can be guaranteed.
So perhaps the story was about a patient visiting a GP but the context got lost in translation.
The whole “4 hour” thing is mad - you should be seen in a reasonable time frame for the ailment you have. Severed hand? Go right ahead. Headache and photo sensitivity that’s been going for a couple of days already? We’ll be with you when we can and if things get substantially worse come back to the reception and you may be deemed more critical. Obviously I am over simplifying the matter but the NHS is staffed by competent trained professionals who should be allowed to use their own judgment as the whether someone can wait 30 seconds, or 6 hours.