News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by oldcynic on Saturday March 03, 2018 @09:36AM (#16509406)
As a Brit using the NHS I can only add that I trust, and expect, every government to make the NHS worse whilst they talk of how marvellous it is.

I would really like it given to an independent cross-party body, or the civil service, to try distance it from politics and The Treasury. I'd like to see legislation to heavily penalise drug companies seeking 20,000% price increases and the like.

Both sides fiddle with it, trivially and constantly. They will even fiddle when they have won a second term or reorganised ministers - because what they themselves thought 4 years ago must have been stupid and should be immediately changed, or something.

Much of the waste is from badly thought through political fiddling, remnants of previous fiddling, and public-private partnerships stupidly chosen during a time of lowest borrowing in British history.

Neither side is honest about it however.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by cstross on Saturday March 03, 2018 @01:06PM (#16510575)
I'd like to see a long-term outcomes-based comparison between NHS England and the Scottish NHS, frankly.

The Scottish NHS is a fully devolved issue and has been diverging from the English system for most of a decade now, with a greater emphasis on preventative healthcare and screening programs (not to mention free prescriptions for all).

In another couple of years we may even have some hard statistical data on what practices work best!

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by tim333 on Saturday March 03, 2018 @10:10PM (#16513056)
I believe they did a study and outcomes were better in England. I'll try google it.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by AlphaSite on Saturday March 03, 2018 @02:06PM (#16510920)
Scottish NHS also has funding issues, so who knows whats going to happen.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by sgt101 on Saturday March 03, 2018 @09:48AM (#16509445)
Imagine how well an NHS organised as it was in 1948 would function in today's world. Although there is no doubt that it could be better managed setting it in aspic will kill it surer than a nail in the back of the head. The NHS will face massive challenges in the next 30 years from demographic pressure on demand and staff, technology change and citizen behaviour and expectation. Radical "fiddling" is going to be needed to keep it alive. This is 100's bn pounds - it's the core of UK politics and it should be - we are a democracy.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 03, 2018 @10:20AM (#16509585)
Yes, but that doesn't mean we should plan the NHS according to the political whims of a party who only look to the next 4 years, and a person who is usually inexperienced in the field and likely to be replaced in the next reshuffle in 12 months time.

What's the Tory's stated public position for their 30 year goals and what immediate and mid-term changes have they made in order to achieve that?

Fiddling is _not_ needed.

Planned, careful, forward looking, evidence based change (that's not focused on shifting funds towards private profit) is certainly required.)

It's just like education, every new minister (usually entirely new to the field) dicks around changing stuff because they want to justify their pay and because not changing it might seem like someone else had a good idea and that apparently is complete anathema to our current politicians.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by oldcynic on Saturday March 03, 2018 @09:55AM (#16509468)
Who's suggesting it be set in aspic? That would be idiotic.

I'd trust an independent body, with cross-party oversight, rather more to make changes, and choices, most suited to the service and populace than most politicians. There might even be some opportunity to think long term rather than just having the next election in mind.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by dageshi on Saturday March 03, 2018 @10:26AM (#16509610)
I wouldn't.

Any time that independent body fucked up or did a bad job, they'd simply claim they didn't get enough money from the government to do the job. Whether that was the truth or not. The "cross party" oversight would then take positions according to their party priorities, if in power blame the independent body for doing a bad job, if not in power blame the government for not giving them enough money.

Unless of course that independent body had separate tax raising powers for just the NHS?

In which case I can't see how they can't be elected as they have the power of taxation.

You can't get politics out of the NHS, it spends too much money raised by taxation.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by oldcynic on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:41AM (#16510071)
I think it's axiomatic that every human endeavour is flawed.

It's pretty clear NICE works rather well and is now accepted by both political sides and the profession. Let's start there.

In terms of funding the NHS spends a smaller proportion of GDP than most developed nations. If we can nail defence and overseas development as x% of GDP, why not also for the NHS? Perhaps consider increasing to the average EU spend?

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:28PM (#16511382)
For one example of politicians chosing to ignore NICE look at the Cancer Drugs Fund.

The CDF makes available cutting edge new technology to people dying from cancer. These meds are very expensive. They often fail the NICE appraisals. The CDF pays for the meds.

We know that these meds often don't work at all, and sometimes cause harm, and are fantastically expensive.

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/apr/28/cancer-drugs...

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by pjc50 on Saturday March 03, 2018 @12:47PM (#16510467)
I suppose the TV license system is very close to an independent body with "tax" raising powers (including the ability to jail people for non-payment). No longer quite so popular.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:32PM (#16511401)
Strictly speaking you can't go to jail for non-payment of tv licence. You'd get a fine, and go to jail for not paying the fine.

You're right that people get a criminal conviction for non-payment of the licence fee, and that's a bit worrying when it happens to so many people.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by gaius on Saturday March 03, 2018 @10:09AM (#16509533)
Aneurin Bevan believed that the cost of the NHS would reduce over time as the population got healthier.

The current NHS budget is £125Bn/year. Many people think it is underfunded, but noone is willing to name a figure for fully funded. Is it £150Bn, 200, 500? No progress will be made, by either party, until someone stands up and does this.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by jdietrich on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:42AM (#16510074)
>The current NHS budget is £125Bn/year. Many people think it is underfunded, but noone is willing to name a figure for fully funded. Is it £150Bn, 200, 500?

It's a moving target, because need continues to grow as the population ages. We're in largely uncharted territory, so it's difficult to make long-term cost forecasts. You could always find ways of spending money to improve a healthcare system, so it just doesn't make sense to pick a number ex nihilo. We do have other, better means of determining what a reasonable level of healthcare spending might be on a year-to-year basis.

The National Institute for Clinical Excellence have determined a cost-effectiveness threshold of £30,000 per additional Quality-Adjusted Life Year. This threshold is a little bit arbitrary, but it's a reasonable rule-of-thumb as to what treatments provide a net benefit to society. Based on this figure, we can start to calculate a reasonable overall NHS budget from the bottom-up - the NHS needs enough money to provide all the healthcare interventions that NICE has determined to be cost-effective.

In addition to cost-effectiveness, we also have benchmarks in terms of quality of care. It might not be clinically significant if someone has to wait three weeks for a GP appointment about their psoriasis or six months for knee surgery, but it matters to the patient. We know that wait times have been going up and patient satisfaction is going down, which is a reasonable indication that the system is underfunded. It wouldn't be reasonable to aim for instant care and 100% patient satisfaction, but we should at the least hope for stability rather than regression.

The question of affordability is perfectly fair, but the UK doesn't spend an exceptional amount on healthcare by the standards of equally-developed nations. As a proportion of GDP, our spending is roughly average for OECD nations. In absolute terms, we spend about 25% less per patient than Germany or Ireland. We can clearly afford to spend a fair bit more before we start feeling the pinch.

I think that it's perfectly reasonable to spend a few tenths of a percent of our GDP to try and take the pressure off the system and get the quality metrics back to where they were in 2015. If costs start spiralling out of control, then we need to have some difficult conversations about what kind of care we're going to ration, but I think that conversation is premature if we haven't first tried a modest increase in spending.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by makomk on Saturday March 03, 2018 @02:03PM (#16510907)
Incidentally, one of the provisions in the ACA over in the US specifically prohibits the use of QALY as a cost-effectiveness threshold. It's just one of many reasons it's so absurd for Americans to point to the NHS as a demonstration of how much more cost-effective healthcare would be if it were nationalised; something like the NHS with its cost-saving measures just wouldn't be politically viable there.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 03, 2018 @10:33AM (#16509657)
You can't put a figure on it.

The system interfaces with every area of life, and with capitalism. Western Capitalism says the amount spent on healthcare should grow until all available money becomes profit for the Capitalists.

Meanwhile there's always some new area of life that impacts health - spend on sport, then on encouraging sport by paying for teachers, then on improving colleges where the teachers train, ... before you know it the NHS is funding a deep mine in Siberia because it mines the metals that make the earphones used in mp3 players by students training to be teachers, to encourage them to teach more sport to children so that when those children grow up they'll need less heart bypass surgery.

Meanwhile the Siberian mine leads to contaminants in the ocean that cause excess cost to all health regimes around the world ...

Health encompasses all parts of life, it needs selfless, holistic, planet-wide approach. You could spend £150 Trillion in health and still find more areas of spending to address.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by justinmk on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:06AM (#16509856)
> Meanwhile there's always some new area of life that impacts health - spend on sport, then on encouraging sport by paying for teachers, then on improving colleges where the teachers train, ... before you know it the NHS is funding a deep mine in Siberia

In other words, central planning doesn't work[1]. NHS was a "special case" that tends towards the general case, as is the tendency of all untouchable mandates.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by pbhjpbhj on Monday March 05, 2018 @07:27AM (#16520545)
I'd go with "you can't centrally plan health within a system of Western Capitalism".

Look at the trains in the UK - government was running one major line at a large profit, but they prop up the system as a whole with tax monies, why? It certainly seems like trains (maybe transport) could be centrally planned if you define the limits of the sector carefully.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:38PM (#16511432)
The NHS (in England) hasn't been centrally planned for some time now.

That's what CCGs are for.

Also, a bunch of stuff (drug and alcohol services, weight loss, smoking cessation, suicide prevention, sexual health, etc etc) isn't even NHS any more, and is part of Public Health which is part of local authorities.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by nugget on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:38AM (#16510045)
I don't see how public health can dramatically improve until we start to have radically different conversations about diet across all levels of society. If you follow the money spent in health care it leads directly to obesity and related lifestyle diseases.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by gaius on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:43AM (#16510081)
The NHS spends £11Bn/year on type-2 diabetes, 80% of which according to Diabetes UK is caused by or could be addressed by lifestyle choices. Not just diabetes of course, I don't mean to pick on one subset, I mean the NHS has to spend an awful lot of money on things that really shouldn't be things in the first place.

People who really love "our NHS" eat right, exercise, and get enough sleep... The rest are just trying to score cheap political points.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by nugget on Saturday March 03, 2018 @01:09PM (#16510598)
>eat right, exercise, and get enough sleep

Of these three, diet has by far the most impact on t2 diabetes. The focus on casual exercise ("10k steps per day") is relatively useless compared to a low-inflammation diet. But there seem to be a lot of perverse incentives and special interests who keep the conversation muddled or focused elsewhere.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:40PM (#16511442)
We're not just talking about diabetes though, we're talking about preventable illness, and good exercise does help prevent heart disease and stroke and some other stuff linked to high blood pressure.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by oligopoly on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:25PM (#16512027)
There's actually quite a few illness that can and often does have origins as 'secondary gain'[0].

It's quite insane that there isn't more done to address root cause. With diabetes-2 I think NHS fails at the point when they don't address people who are at risk. Help people to change their habits by attaching pain and pleasure to their choices and making it personal. This would save NHS lot of money and most importantly help the individual.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/144873.Healing_Back_Pain...

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:15PM (#16511320)
Sure, but pretty much everyone (even current Conservative party) agrees the Lansley reforms (The Health and Social Care Act) were a fucking mess and are currently causing problems.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by rmc on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @10:18AM (#16529323)
When it was set up in the 1940s, it was claimed to be impossibly expensive, and would bankrupt the nation.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:09PM (#16511299)
> I would really like it given to an independent cross-party body, or the civil service, to try distance it from politics and The Treasury.

They did that. The governmental bit (in England) is the Department for Health and Social Care.

NHS England is the qango that runs the NHS in England. They provide money to CCGs to commission most services. NHS England directly commissions some (so called "tier 4" services) - eg inpatient mental health services for children; medium and high secure mental health services; etc.

I genuinely have no idea what happens in Wales, Scotland, or NI. Health is devolved and they run their systems independently.