News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by oldcynic on Saturday March 03, 2018 @09:55AM (#16509468)
Who's suggesting it be set in aspic? That would be idiotic.

I'd trust an independent body, with cross-party oversight, rather more to make changes, and choices, most suited to the service and populace than most politicians. There might even be some opportunity to think long term rather than just having the next election in mind.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by dageshi on Saturday March 03, 2018 @10:26AM (#16509610)
I wouldn't.

Any time that independent body fucked up or did a bad job, they'd simply claim they didn't get enough money from the government to do the job. Whether that was the truth or not. The "cross party" oversight would then take positions according to their party priorities, if in power blame the independent body for doing a bad job, if not in power blame the government for not giving them enough money.

Unless of course that independent body had separate tax raising powers for just the NHS?

In which case I can't see how they can't be elected as they have the power of taxation.

You can't get politics out of the NHS, it spends too much money raised by taxation.

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by oldcynic on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:41AM (#16510071)
I think it's axiomatic that every human endeavour is flawed.

It's pretty clear NICE works rather well and is now accepted by both political sides and the profession. Let's start there.

In terms of funding the NHS spends a smaller proportion of GDP than most developed nations. If we can nail defence and overseas development as x% of GDP, why not also for the NHS? Perhaps consider increasing to the average EU spend?

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:28PM (#16511382)
For one example of politicians chosing to ignore NICE look at the Cancer Drugs Fund.

The CDF makes available cutting edge new technology to people dying from cancer. These meds are very expensive. They often fail the NICE appraisals. The CDF pays for the meds.

We know that these meds often don't work at all, and sometimes cause harm, and are fantastically expensive.

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/apr/28/cancer-drugs...

Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by pjc50 on Saturday March 03, 2018 @12:47PM (#16510467)
I suppose the TV license system is very close to an independent body with "tax" raising powers (including the ability to jail people for non-payment). No longer quite so popular.
Re:American using Britain’s NHS (2015) by DanBC on Saturday March 03, 2018 @03:32PM (#16511401)
Strictly speaking you can't go to jail for non-payment of tv licence. You'd get a fine, and go to jail for not paying the fine.

You're right that people get a criminal conviction for non-payment of the licence fee, and that's a bit worrying when it happens to so many people.