This is blanket false. Our legal system already factors in culpability and reasonableness. Intent is a crucial part of our legal system. The problem is, Section 230 helps big companies avoid responsibility even when they ARE culpable. A small company doing their best to moderate their site is not going to be held legally responsible for bad user content, companies making hundreds of billions by avoiding spending money moderating content, are.

Section 230 has to go if we're going to do anything to fix the Internet.