News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by clarkmoody on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:19AM (#16501494)
Twitter is taking itself too seriously, believing that if it could tweak around the edges, it could improve the quality of the debate in the direction of civility and understanding. Perhaps some nudges and UX changes could encourage these things (I remember a long article about Facebook tweaking their "report picture" function to encourage messaging the person to talk about it before reporting).

BUT

I hate to break it to @jack, but Twitter conversation simply reflects the nature of humanity in an adversarial political system. Attempting to "elevate the debate" will never work, since the debate has never been "elevated." There were no good ol' days of citizen-statesmen calmly discussing their political differences and coming to reasoned conclusions on policy.

No. Politics is always adversarial. As a libertarian, both "sides" of the American political divide feel threatening to me, since all proposals out there are for one form of authoritarianism or another. All proposals involve me giving up a little more of my personal or economic liberty. Will @jack do anything to alleviate my fears that my liberty is being attacked every single day? Probably not.

He's devoted to "collective health and civility," which reads like a 1984 thought-police handbook. Of course, the debate always seems civil after the dissenting voices have been crushed.

(Pre-emptive retort to attack on libertarianism: Yes, I know Twitter is private property. Yes, Jack can do whatever he wants with his business, within the laws for a publicly-traded company.)

Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by wgerard on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:10AM (#16501971)
Huh, your comment actually caused me to re-evaluate my thinking a little bit.

Because you're right, in general this is true:

> There were no good ol' days of citizen-statesmen calmly discussing their political differences and coming to reasoned conclusions on policy.

It seems that way sometimes (calm debate and discussion), but US history of course is full of angry, threatening debates with even politicians themselves erupting into actual physical violence sometimes [1].

Still, it feels like there's been a notable shift. Compare one of the 1992 presidential debates [2] to a 2016 presidential debate [3]. The former feels like an actual debate, the latter feels like a segment on a political news show where basically the loudest voice "wins".

Of course, US politics has always been a thin veneer of civility masking some extremely aggressive adversarial acts (e.g. Watergate), but it seems like that mask has now disappeared almost entirely.

I don't know that Twitter is the cause of any of this (as opposed to just a reflection of where we're at), but it does feel like things have certainly shifted nonetheless.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legislative_violence#United_St...

2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jg9qB_BIjWY

3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=855Am6ovK7s

Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by tjr225 on Friday March 02, 2018 @11:07AM (#16502655)
> Still, it feels like there's been a notable shift.

I don't know if I agree completely...I watched your videos and yes- the debates during the 2016 election were absolutely ridiculous, I think that's mostly due to wider and more public acceptance of conspiracy theory, Fox News, and your Rush Limbaughs, and on the flipside thought-policing, extreme sensitivity, etc

It's funny, back to why I somewhat disagree with you, if you watch any news from the last twenty or thirty years everyone seems to have the exact same concerns as they do now. Donald Trump (and even Hillary Clinton when she was running) are just really loud mouthpieces for those concerns.

Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by throwawayyx96 on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:26PM (#16504798)
Setting aside formal debates among politicians, if you want to talk about why discussion of contentious topics by average Joes and Janes has degenerated into its current state of pointless shouting matches, I feel like it has less to do with Fox News, conspiracy theories, fake news, Russian meddling or whatever else is regularly associated with the alt-right. In the run-up to the election and the months following it, a large faction on the left has abandoned any pretense of discussing ideas and policies or of having civilized debate, preferring instead to become very aggressive with insults, wild accusations of racism, white supremacy, misogyny, etc., in order to demonize their opposition. You see it all the time on this forum and others. It's lazy and harmful, and it's being used as a tool to avoid any self-reflection.
Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by tjr225 on Friday March 02, 2018 @03:31PM (#16505414)
I agree with one caveat- I think it's preposterous to say that the left is responsible for this- both sides participated in this nonsense and it's obvious that that is the case.

And, I think you have to take the context in which Donald Trump rose to power into account- to many (myself included) it's also preposterous that someone with a track record of failure, bankruptcy, and lack of experience could come to head our administrative branch...it's hard to have a conversation when the very idea of his election is so absurd, for better or for worse.

Another edit! I think it's misleading for you to present Fox News, Rush Limbaugh, et al. as things associated with the Alt-Right. These are very much poor sources of information and are very much so digested by a huge swath of conservative Americans.

Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by wgerard on Friday March 02, 2018 @11:24AM (#16502841)
> I think that's mostly due to wider and more public acceptance of conspiracy theory, Fox News, and your Rush Limbaughs, etc..

That's a pretty serious shift!

Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by tjr225 on Friday March 02, 2018 @11:50AM (#16503186)
Absolutely agreed
Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by tonyedgecombe on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:07AM (#16501946)
Yes, every time someone tells me politics is getting more adversarial I think back to people like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxEjzSlbHvY
Re:“We’re committing Twitter to increase the health and civi... by ballenarosada on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:41AM (#16502319)
As a socialist... You're right about Twitter and the history of political debate. The era of Henry Clay and Daniel Webster was also the era of Senators beating each other with canes.