No. I love Let's Encrypt, but we can't put all our eggs in a single basket like that.
Now, if we could somehow foster multiple non-profit organizations like Let's Encrypt, but run under the aegis of different boards and sponsors, I'd be 100% for this idea.
It's very odd that companies for whom CAs business is quite literally a money printing operation can't be bothered to do the relatively minimal maintenance and care required for a trustworthy CA. A bizarre and unexpected failure of the market.
The consumers are, partially, buying a product they can't see: The security operations of the vendor.
Given the consumer has imperfect information, it is exceptionally profitable for a supplier to just not invest in security. The downside being the risk of compromise.
A market set up this way entirely predicts low-cost suppliers. With no way for consumers to introspect security routines, two vendors will appear to simply differ in price. The outcome is rather obvious.
It's like a building that needs secure doors: it's better to invest in a single, massive, bulletproof, guarded door rather than inviting anyone who meets some standards to add a door to the building, since what matters is the weakest door.
If it can be reliably proven that a CA is compromised, then it can be fixed.
Compromising any CA affects the entire internet.
Although it's unlikely that's of any use, since unsophisticated users aren't going to differentiate, and sophisticated ones can use other means to verify identity.
CAs have proven again and again to be ridiculously insecure, and the problem is that there is no penalty for their mistakes.
So just remove them all, after a warning period: Let's Encrypt is enough.
Or if they want to stay in business and be trusted by browsers, then require them to put up at least $100k in cash in escrow for each certificate they sign, which is forfeit if there's evidence that any compromise of that specific certificate, due to their fault, has or may have happened, with at least half of the money being distributed to whoever provides the evidence first.