News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by AlexCoventry on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @05:58PM (#16488029)
What are the regulatory hurdles to operating a lightning node in the US? It makes you a money transmitter, right?
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by urza on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @07:46PM (#16488730)
Here is something from Andreas Antonopoulos on this topic: https://youtu.be/c4TjfaLgzj4?t=14m35s

I think the most important aspect is that Lightning Nodes are just sending bitcoin transactions, the whole system is trustless, the node relying your transaction to destination can't steal your money any more then bitcoin full node relying your transaction to miners can.

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by AlexCoventry on Thursday March 01, 2018 @09:01PM (#16498322)
Thanks. That was very unsatisfying, though. He's right that there are usually thresholds where money-transmitter laws kick in, but having to track that and refrain once you hit the limit would be onerous and limiting.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by FriedPickles on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @06:38PM (#16488323)
If FinCEN rules that operating a lightning node constitutes acting as a money transmitter, it would be unenforceable. It may still discourage operating an intermediate node in the US and shift the majority of nodes to other countries.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by AlexCoventry on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @07:19PM (#16488599)
Why unenforceable?
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by ExactoKnight on Thursday March 01, 2018 @01:59AM (#16490204)
The same way Bitcoin can't realistically be stopped by any government. (Short of seizing network hashing power..)
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by zaarn on Thursday March 01, 2018 @03:01AM (#16490389)
Or by ruling that it is illegal to buy, sell or own bitcoin.

While bitcoin might continue, most citizens will stop bothering at that point because buying or selling bitcoin shows up in tax audits.

The government can also make it illegal to operate a bitcoin node or transmit bitcoin transactions, including for ISPs, which would get the protocol quickly blocked.

Additionally they could rule Bitcoin to be an illegal form of monetary exchange which would mean that anything you buy via bitcoin would get you in hot water in addition to the tax problems if you can't prove you used a legal monetary method.

Of course, some people might use Tor and somehow manage to get money extracted from the Tax system so they can buy bitcoin without their local tax office knowing... but how many of the Mr. Normal population are able and willing to do that for bitcoin?

I think you severely underestimate the power of the government.

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by utunga on Thursday March 01, 2018 @07:36AM (#16491456)
> While bitcoin might continue, most citizens will stop bothering at that point because buying or selling bitcoin shows up in tax audits.

But they'd only show up for a short period of time (in this scenario) because after a while bitcoin wouldn't really be worth anything. Lol.

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by ExactoKnight on Thursday March 01, 2018 @03:33AM (#16490478)
You will have a drug war on your hands, only way harder to enforce thanks to encryption.

It's a losing game, and I think you forget that there are way too many rich people in positions of power who like crypto for it to be successfully killed. The ruling classes actually like it more than the lower classes do.

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by zaarn on Thursday March 01, 2018 @03:42AM (#16490515)
The drug war hasn't really helped in putting illegal drugs into mainstream use.

Mainstream users will not use bitcoin if it becomes illegal. End of story. Maybe some people continue to use it but it'll probably be far below any drug usage levels.

>It's a losing game, and I think you forget that there are way too many rich people in positions of power who like crypto for it to be successfully killed. The ruling classes actually like it more than the lower classes do.

That's barely relevant because the "rich ruling classes" could still do it. I'm evaluating this as "what if they do" not "would they do"

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by imtringued on Thursday March 01, 2018 @04:37AM (#16490717)
Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are nothing without public exchanges.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by xkarga00 on Thursday March 01, 2018 @02:04PM (#16495051)
Wait until most cryptos support atomic swaps.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by shanusmagnus on Thursday March 01, 2018 @08:40PM (#16498181)
Still useless from the PoV of this argument until you get to the point where you can buy stuff you need directly in crypto without conversion to fiat. We're a long way from that now, and the closest practical workaround (bitcoin to gift cards to stuff) goes away if the government gets hostile.

The government doesn't have to make it impossible for cypherpunks and superhackers to use bitcoin, it just has to scare normal people. That's easily done with a few laws and some gratuitous enforcement, e.g., throw a few thousand people in jail for tax evasion, watch how long it takes for these casual hodlers to liquidate. That's 90% of the battle won, and 90% will probably be enough.

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by ExactoKnight on Friday March 02, 2018 @03:36PM (#16505457)
There may be a kernal of truth to this, but the fact is, to do this with overwhelming force there needs to a strong social impetus to do this.

With drugs you had families ruined by drug addiction desperate for a solution.

With bitcoin you have... what? Unwavering respect for the right of governments to restrict something most people can identify has at least some utility?

The social consensus for a harsh crackdown is not there, and like the internet on issues with copyright, governments will continue to muddle along as this all evolves way quicker than they can deal with it (kind of like Uber).

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by shanusmagnus on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:45PM (#16507570)
> With bitcoin you have... what?

You have a government losing its sovereignty over its own money supply, for all practical purposes. After being invaded, or losing territory due to an invasion, that's about as serious a threat as any on offer.

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by xkarga00 on Friday March 02, 2018 @03:22AM (#16499946)
Yeah, sorry, I replied to the parent while thinking forward. I agree that in order for cryptos to succeed, merchants have to use them first. It is definitely not simple and we are far from it because it involves rendering the current system obsolete and a mental shift in how we think about money and governance. Eventually I expect governments to be affected, too.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by apo on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @07:48PM (#16488739)
I've seen nothing to suggest that a LN operator would be considered a money transmitter. Whats your best reason for thinking so, and why does your definition of money transmission not include miners?
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by AlexCoventry on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @10:24PM (#16489435)
Miners only register a transfer of value and validate it against their perspective of the current ledger. Transfer routed through a lightning channel involves explicit exchange of funds between intermediaries.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by keymone on Thursday March 01, 2018 @05:45AM (#16491003)
this is not entirely correct. in A -> B -> C payment at no point does B hold A's money with a promise to pay it forward to C.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by AlexCoventry on Thursday March 01, 2018 @09:04PM (#16498339)
B's balance with A and C fluctuate during the transfer, though, and that is enough to at least make it look like a money-transmitter relationship.

The onion routing is very unfortunate, because it means regulators are likely to treat the network as a blatant money-laundering tool.

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by abecedarius on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @06:39PM (#16488338)
https://coincenter.org/files/2018-01/federalalternativev1-1.... talks about the general picture (I only skimmed it). It wants reform to "include a safe harbor for novel businesses that do not create the sort of risks to consumers that money transmission licensing is meant to address (but which may be treated as money transmitters under a loose interpretation of some state statutes)."
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by Klathmon on Thursday March 01, 2018 @08:32AM (#16491762)
I'm not a lawyer, but this is my understanding:

A LN node is no more a "money transmitter" than any internet router that a bank transaction flows through is a "money transmitter".

The node or router can't "steal" or modify the amount or destination in any way, and there is no counterparty risk with either of them, so they both aren't "money transmitters".

Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by Pada on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @06:08PM (#16488108)
I think the same could be said of any bitcoin node.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by xur17 on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @06:13PM (#16488164)
But a regular bitcoin node isn't transferring money. It's simply tracking the state of the network. A lightning node is creating transactions and financial agreements with other nodes in the network.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by Pada on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @06:33PM (#16488288)
Bitcoin nodes propagate transactions created by users as well.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by FriedPickles on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @06:40PM (#16488343)
They relay information about transactions, but do not receive and resend value as a lightning node does.
Re:Show HN: Lightning Network Search and Analysis Engine by ozmbie on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @06:12PM (#16488153)
You're transmitting cryptocurrency, not fiat. So I'm unsure how it works.