News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dtube – A decentralized video platform using STEEM and IPFS by skrowl on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @01:16PM (#16485234)
Here does "decentralized" also mean "censorship-resistant"? In light of YouTube censoring perfectly legal videos for wrongthink, I think it could be a big win for you to also come out as only censoring when there's a legal basis.
Re:Dtube – A decentralized video platform using STEEM and IPFS by nannal on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @03:15PM (#16486375)
Videos can be hidden in the UI but only via enough downvotes from the community, even then the video and its hash is still on the blockchain and available via ipfs.
Re:Dtube – A decentralized video platform using STEEM and IPFS by fro0116 on Thursday March 01, 2018 @03:32AM (#16490475)
Not to diminish the technical accomplishment here, but that sounds like the very definition of tyranny of the majority.

Not to say that our current systems of manual moderation are perfect, but at least it's a step removed from mob rule, with recourse usually available if a video is wrongly flagged for simply expressing unpopular opinion.

If a video tries to express unpopular viewpoints at DTube, it would seem impossible for it to ever get listed again without waiting for the tides of public opinion to turn, which could take much longer if these kinds of moderation systems become prevalent and the majority could silence the voices of the minority so directly.

Decentralized moderation is a hard problem, and I don't claim to have a good solution myself, but I'd rather take centralized services over decentralized ones with moderation implemented as rule by majority with no recourse. That seems like a dangerously slippery slope towards dystopia.

Re:Dtube – A decentralized video platform using STEEM and IPFS by tCfD on Thursday March 01, 2018 @01:08PM (#16494483)
Especially if the majority are all named "sybil"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sybil_attack

Re:Dtube – A decentralized video platform using STEEM and IPFS by skrowl on Thursday March 01, 2018 @09:01AM (#16492024)
Particularly with how popular it is to use bots to Facebook Like, Retweet Twitter, Upvote Reddit, etc. I'm a little worried about being hidden from search when you get too many downvotes, because I personally could probably create a downvote bot army in a day and I'm not really even that interested in it.
Re:Dtube – A decentralized video platform using STEEM and IPFS by lt on Thursday March 01, 2018 @11:02AM (#16493023)
On steem, your influence (the power of your downvote) is weighted by the amount of stake (the currency) you have, precisely for that reason.

Still tyranny of the majority (or of the influential stakeholders, actually), but it's a different issue.

Re:Dtube – A decentralized video platform using STEEM and IPFS by RossDCurrie on Thursday March 08, 2018 @08:57AM (#16544309)
Yeah, on Steem it doesn't take a whole bunch of people to disagree with your opinion... you just have to piss off one person who holds a ton of Steem ;)