News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by dredmorbius on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:08PM (#16478975)
Mass-publishing markets are very strongly given to power-law distributions. We hear that "anybody can be famous" (or successful, or ...), but everybody cannot be famous. Attention and publicity are the ultimate zero-sum games: no matter how large a given talent pool, there will only ever be ten top-ten spots, 100 top-100 spots. All you're doing by enlarging the pool is amplifying the competition for those spots.

There's another side to the equation, though, which is the scope of the audience. Prior to modern technological methods, and I'm including here everything from relatively modern printing (say, 19th century onward), as well as phonograph, cinema, radio, television, and sound amplification, the reach of any given work was small. A book might have a printing of several thousand copies (Adam Smith, Wealth of Nations, ~5,000 initial print run, and the cost at £5 was roughly a quarter of a working man's annual wage). A theatre might seat (or stand) a few thousand (the New Globe Theatre: 3,000), and the largest cities had populations of about a quarter million (London in 1600, more or less). Transportation was slow and expensive (Smith again: 2 weeks, by stage coach or horse from Edinborough to London -- that's how he travelled to university himself).

https://www.oldbaileyonline.org/static/Population-history-of...

As a consequence, entertainment was strongly local. There might be small touring acts, local musicians, and in rare cases, artists with a noble or royal patron (think Shakespeare himself, after a fashion, or Handel, Bach, or a church appointment (Bach, Telemann, and others). Art as a freestanding business was more-or-less a 19th century creation -- look especially at the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood and the Impressionists, there are several excellent documentaries and biographies of each.

Technology increased the reach (and income) of top performing creators and stars, but decreased the viability of those further down the rankings. Where it used to be possible to eke out a livelihood as a local or touring performer, this became far more difficult. (There's something of a reverse shift in that the overall entertainment budget has increased sufficiently that the field has expanded, but the overall balance holds true.)

By way of quantification, I've been looking at the question of how many actors there are, and how many of those are considered "A-list". For the first:

How Many Actors are in L.A.?

https://hollywoodsapien.com/2012/07/05/how-many-actors-are-i...

Based on SAG and AFTRA membership and some adjustments, anthropologist Scott Frank comes up with the figure 108,640, of whom 21,728 are working actors. Los Angeles itself provides about 80% of all acting work, and USBLS data claim 1.77% of Angelenos work in entertainment, more than any other U.S. city.

How many of those are considered "A-List" actors? The definitions are ... fluid ... but generally about ten, no more than twenty. The Ulmer scale is a 100-point model estimating a star's value to a film. The 2009 top ten list, in order, were: Will Smith, Johnny Depp, Brad Pitt, Tom Hanks, George Clooney, Will Ferrel, Reese Witherspoon, Nicolas Cage, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Russell Crowe.

https://www.webcitation.org/5mnRWTArh?url=http://www.ulmersc...

Consider that given power law relationships, the earnings of a given star are going to be 1/n of the first-ranked, income falls off tremendously quickly. VSauce has a surprisingly good video on the topic:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fCn8zs912OE

Upshot: We're not all going to fame our way to wealth and riches. Or even subsistence survival. It's not a creators world.

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by jdietrich on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:51PM (#16479315)
Patreon has completely upended these economics. You can make a comfortable middle-class income based on a small but extremely loyal fanbase. If you're dependent on ad revenue, you need millions of subscribers, because you're only earning a fraction of a cent for each viewer. If you're supported through Patreon, you only need a couple of thousand people to chip in a couple of bucks a month.

It's an interesting middle ground between patronage and busking that doesn't have any clear precedent.

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by dredmorbius on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:33PM (#16479938)
I follow Mastodon quite closely. Its creator, Gargron, produces social networking software with roughly 1 million registered users. He has 685 patrons, and nets $3,267/mo income.

That's less than $40k/yr. Though it's a richly diversified income stream and he has no boss (or rather: 685 bosses).

https://www.patreon.com/mastodon

It's an interesting story, and one I'm watching closely. As I get older, I break out in ever-faster cases of hives when someone claims to have "completely upended these economics". You might consider this the New Hives Mind.

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by PeterisP on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @07:34PM (#16479595)
You still need a quite sizeable fanbase - small is not the right word for a couple thousand loyal fans who regularly spend money on you; even in the pre-globalized world where the distribution was more fair (less global stars sucking up attention), the vast majority of artists, bands, sports clubs, performers, etc didn't have as many serious fans. No matter what happens, there's only so much attention available, and it's a zero-sum game, most content creators won't be able to make it especially if the number of creators grows and dilutes that attention / eagerness of being a fan.
Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by jdietrich on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:15PM (#16480413)
Patreon take a 5% cut of donations. A band with an exceptionally good record deal might get to keep 15% of CD sales. The numbers are fairly similar in most mass media - under historical distribution models, middlemen kept the lion's share of revenues.

Even assuming that competition for entertainment spending is entirely zero-sum, then the disintermediation of the arts is destroying a lot of jobs for middlemen but is increasing the amount of revenue that goes to artists. Even if the pie is static or shrinking, artists are getting a bigger cut.

I'm not saying that everything is sunshine and roses, I'm not saying that everyone can become a creative professional, but I think that the situation is definitely improving. Barriers to entry are lower and there's a much larger middle-class of artists who aren't internationally famous but are making a good living.

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by igravious on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:16PM (#16480419)
Fascinating response. I think you're dead on the money. Extremely pertinent remarks about the cost of art and literature in days gone by.

What YouTube does, therefore, is allow people to dabble, it makes it easy to upload content and a video format whereas before you'd somehow need to work your way into tv or film assuming that industry was located near you. Now all you need is a decent net connection, a bit of talent, a bit of a work ethic, and you can make a go of it. Will you succeed? Hell, probably no–but maybe you'll be more towards the lucrative end of the power law distribution. But yes, for every PewDiePie there are tens of thousand of also rans.

Look Ma! I've got global reach. But people's attention span is finite and their interests are limited and the way they find out about stuff obeys certain rules. Because of this we get that odd creature, fame.

I think that digital technology and internet and communications technologies have lowered the barriers into the arts and also to consume art. I do fundamentally believe that. That has to be a good thing, doesn't it? But that doesn't mean that art in the digital medium is going to buck social laws.

Could you tell me is there any one or two books I should be reading to glean more of the same information you have provided?

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by dredmorbius on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @04:56AM (#16481951)
Of your last question: not a short list, though I did put together, tongue firmly in cheek, "Media, Advertising, Sustainability, Externalities, and Impacts: A light reading list" this past December after a similar request:

https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/7k7l4m/media_a...

That should give you a basis for making some initial cuts.

The problem is, or rather, problems are:

1. I'm still catching up on the media / social-elements-of-information field, and have only been reading it in depth for slightly over a year (though I've had quite some years of general awareness). Which means that this list itself is somewhat aspirational (though I've at least taken a good look through most of the references cited).

2. What I've described above is a synthesis from a bunch of sources. I'm not claiming it's unique, mind, only noting that I can't really point you at some specific book and say "here, read this for that".

3. I'm coming to suspect the media field itself is not of one, or even some low-n number of minds, about major elements of these matters.

I think Tim Wu's Attention Merchants should get at much of the focus / diversity / attention element.

I've found Robert McChesney particularly compelling, and his Communication Revolution a strong overview of recent (past 20-40 years) developments in the field, particularly from a political-economic perspective.

Alvin Toffler's Future Shock digs into some of the elements of attention and information overload. It's a bit too popular itself, but should point to more robust literature. Herbert Simon in particular.

Hope that helps.

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by igravious on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @05:43AM (#16482108)
Certainly does.

Here is where I overlap with you. I've watched the documentary version of manufacturing consent but not read the book. (Don't tell anyone.) I watched The Century of the Self and Hypernormalisation plus a couple of others by Curtis. McLuhan is on my radar but I've never done a deep dive though of course I'm aware of him. I've read The Master Switch by Wu but not Attention Merchants, this man obviously is someone to keep an eye on.

So that leaves McChesney and Toffler. They are now on my radar, thank you. Under general media scholars you mention: H.L. Mencken, I.F. Stone, and perhaps Walter Lippmann and John Dewey. I thought Mencken a critic, Dewey a pragmatist–Rorty rates Dewey very highly, Lippmann I seem to recall to coming across…, Stone, don't think so. Interesting list.

And if I may be so bold. Have you considered The Revolt of the Masses by Ortega y Gasset? A prescient work. Somewhat more obscure is The Reality of the Mass Media by Niklas Luhmann, Curtis mentions nearly every cyberneticist and cybernetic theorist bar Luhmann, probably for good reason come to think of it. New media theorists: Walter Benjamin obviously for his The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction (but maybe others?), The Language of New Media by Lev Manovich, and finally anything by Wendy Hui Kyong Chun (Wendy Chun).

I gather that media-philosophie is an actual research programme in German-land whereas here we'd call it media studies or communication studies or new media studies and it's looked down upon to the same extent as cultural studies programmes are or courses on semiotics. I'd like to see media-philosophy (what you use to communicate your message) become an actual branch of philosophy like aesthetics/rhetoric (how you communicate your message).

It's been stimulating, ciao!

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by dredmorbius on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @01:55PM (#16485619)
A few more thoughts:

I.F. Stone, H.L. Mencken, and others (see particularly George Seldes) are far more practitioners than theorists, but they've had a significant mark on theory and make many great observations. Mencken's "Brayard vs. Lionheart" (I believe that's mentioned in my reading list) is especially apt, and is short to boot. It describes a large element of the information-theoretic component (though Mencken of course doesn't call it that) through his Gresham's Law reference and dynamic.

Thanks for Gasset, Luhmann, Benjamin, and Chun, as I don't think I've previously run across them.

Added to the already imposing book-mountain.

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by igravious on Thursday March 01, 2018 @06:06AM (#16491079)
> Added to the already imposing book-mountain.

:-) so little time, so much to read …

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by dredmorbius on Thursday March 01, 2018 @02:25PM (#16495255)
A notion I try to make ever-more front-of-mind: Read only worthy books.

It's similar to the advice of Henry David Thoreau in Two Weeks on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers, much of which in fact discusses books and ideas:

It would be worth the while to select our reading, for books are the society we keep; to read only the serenely true; never statistics, nor fiction, nor news, nor reports, nor periodicals, but only great poems, and when they failed, read them again, or perchance write more. Instead of other sacrifice, we might offer up our perfect (τελεία) thoughts to the gods daily, in hymns or psalms. For we should be at the helm at least once a day. The whole of the day should not be daytime; there should be one hour, if no more, which the day did not bring forth. Scholars are wont to sell their birthright for a mess of learning. But is it necessary to know what the speculator prints, or the thoughtless study, or the idle read, the literature of the Russians and the Chinese, or even French philosophy and much of German criticism. Read the best books first, or you may not have a chance to read them at all.

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/4232/4232-h/4232-h.htm

I wouldn't be an absolutist on this point. But I'd note that very, very nearly all that is written is not worth reading. Including myself.

Re:‘Success’ on YouTube Still Means a Life of Poverty by dredmorbius on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:26PM (#16484739)
Thanks for the suggestions, they're new to me. Again, I am not proficient here, just ambitious.

The Revolt of the Masses by Ortega y Gasset is at the Internet Archive:

https://archive.org/details/TheRevoltOfTheMassesJoseOrtegaYG...

More to follow.