GDPR requires that the use cases be itemized, and the user can opt out of each one individually. So if the user opts out of receiving a mailing but not the store locator, you have to manage how much data you collect about that person. I agree that for the most part this will just be another click-through like the cookie law was, but companies will be required to accommodate those minority that do care.
> Is the penalty going to be high enough to justify not breaking this law?
The penalty is up to 4% of annual global revenue. Global revenue.
Of course, paying the fine doesn't mean that you can continue with the action - it'd also likely involve imposing a temporary or permanent ban on data processing and ordering the rectification, restriction or erasure of data gathered unlawfully.
Then that part is worthless, just another click-through "agreement" practically nobody reads.
That part won't change anything.
> So if your business purpose is to mail something to the customer, full physical address is OK to collect. If your business purpose is to help them find a nearby store location, you may be expected to collect something less granular like ZIP code or metro area, depending on how many locations you have.
I always wonder one thing: Is the penalty going to be high enough to justify not breaking this law?
All business decisions are cost-benefit. If the costs of doing something outweigh the benefit, you don't do that. This includes following the law: If you can reliably get more money by breaking the law, you break the law, and pay the penalty if you get caught. Unless you're very unlucky, you're still right-side-up after you pay the penalty, so your behavior was, on the whole, justified.