News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by exabrial on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:19AM (#16471455)
On their defense, people mean well, but 'the road to hell did paved with good intentions' as they say.

1st Amendment is being attacked by liberals, with pronoun laws, hate speech regulations, equal opportunity laws, forced cake baking, many other things.

The 2nd is also being attacked from a variety of ways by liberals, which as said before, is well intentioned, but ultimately destructive.

Thank goodness the 3rd isn't an issue!

The 4th amendment is being attacked by both conservatives and liberals in a variety of ways. From NSA data collections on Americans under Obama, to DEA/BATF sponsored civil asset forfeiture under Bush, and unlawful searches by ICE under the current administration, this Amendment is very important but is being chipped away by both authoritarian ideologies.

Ah, our 5th amendment has been weakened by both liberals and conservatives. From No Fly lists and travel bans you can't get out of, to waiting periods on firearms, we've truly let this very important amendment become weakened.

I like all of the amendments. I don't want to see any single one of them weakened any more and some of our rights restored.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by skookumchuck on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:49AM (#16471557)
> I like all of the amendments.

I'm not an NRA member, but the idea of repealing the 2nd Amendment, or worse, interpreting it out of existence has bothered me in ways I couldn't quite put my finger on. I finally realized what it was. If we decide one of the rights is "archaic", "obsolete", "insane", or any of the epithets routinely leveled at it, we set a terrible precedent. How long will it be before the rest fall when they are inevitably inconvenient?

We need to stand for all the BoR. Not whatever is convenient.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by kelnos on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:32AM (#16471691)
I would absolutely be in favor of a repeal of the 2nd Amendment, and I would be very afraid to see the right to bear arms be legislated out of existence (without a repeal) because of the precedent that would set regarding not just the rest of the Bill of Rights, or the rest of the Amendments, but the entire Constitution itself.

I'm not talking about the 2nd being inconvenient. I'm talking about it being a mistake. Just like prohibition was. Just because we might collectively decide that giving people the right to arm themselves in ridiculous ways was a mistake, it doesn't follow that we're obviously going to decide that freedom of speech was a mistake, too. I'm absolutely not buying a slippery-slope argument here; that's just a fancy way of saying "I don't want positive change because I'm afraid of negative change as well".

The Bill of Rights is not some magical thing. Amendments are simply late additions to the Constitution. They are a part of the constitution. Suggesting that we shouldn't repeal an Amendment is suggesting that the Constitution's own amendment process should be tossed aside as invalid.

> We need to stand for all the BoR. Not whatever is convenient.

No, we don't. We need to stand for what makes sense for our society. "Convenience" has nothing to do with it.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by zaroth on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:39AM (#16473190)
Exactly how do you imagine an attempt to confiscate a few hundred million guns would play out in this country?

Advocating for repeal of the 2nd seems to me to be advocating for civil war and literal decimation of the country.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by direfungasaur on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:49AM (#16473284)
Are you implying that gun-owners would suddenly wage war on the nation if they were told to hand over (some portion of) their guns in the next year or face civil penalties? Doesn't it seem far more likely that most law-abiding folks would hand over their weapons to avoid interruption to their lives, possibly retaining one or two illegally?

Most of the people I know would complain and protest any confiscation, but I doubt they would shoot a law officer to protect that privilege. They would simply lose too much in return for that exchange.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by zaroth on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:03AM (#16473380)
Gun confiscation from law-abiding citizens at a Federal level? Yes, I believe that has a pretty significant chance of going sideways quite rapidly.

Target a vulnerable sub-population and you just might be able to pull it off (mentally impaired, under 21, etc.)

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by direfungasaur on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:49AM (#16473744)
I just don't understand the generality of the assertion. Law-abiding folks are suddenly going to become violent because the government changed one law? I can certainly believe that some segment of the population might revolt, but broad-scale revolt seems rather unlikely. Most of us are well-fed and entertained enough that the loss of firearms would be an irritant, not an issue worth risking life and limb over. Something like prohibition seems far more likely. Some folks would retain whatever weapons were deemed illegal, while the vast majority of folks would hand-over the bulk of their weapons and possibly retain whatever they thought they could conceal.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by zaroth on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:28AM (#16474166)
I think there’s a sizable part of the population which believes very strongly that what would come after gun confiscation is worth fighting a war to prevent.

And you can’t fight that war if you aren’t armed for it. So it’s a do or die / back up against the wall proposition at that point.

Men rise up in violence all the time to protect what is sacred to them. “Change one law” is I think not an accurate depiction of the premise I was responding to - which was repeal of the 2nd amendment and large scale gun confiscation.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by direfungasaur on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:48AM (#16475200)
With respect to the 'change one law' phrasing - I don't think a repeal of the 2nd immediately leads to confiscation. It only removes the federal restrictions, but several state constitutions have the right explicitly enshrined. Pennsylvania is a good example, but I believe there are others. Confiscation would probably require not only an appeal of the 2nd, but also repeal of any state laws as well. I tend to believe that would result a slow, piecemeal process where individual states go through confiscation one by one.

That said, your point can certainly stand at a state level. I still think how the process is managed impacts the broader social response. An approach that attempted to leave bolt-action/small capacity shotguns and files in place may be received differently than a wholesale ban. An approach that only eliminated 'assault weapons' but left handguns would have a different impact than an approach that required both to be turned-in. There's lots of ways to drive a confiscation, with lesser or greater outcomes on how people resist, I would think.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by arwhatever on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:05AM (#16471605)
Scott Greenfield covered your exact point pretty well over at his "Simple Justice" law blog https://blog.simplejustice.us/2015/10/06/ten-favs-from-the-b...
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by kelnos on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:38AM (#16471720)
Kinda a straw man, though. If you're of the crowd that thinks the government should legislate the 2nd away, then sure, you should take Greenfield's words to heart and have a good think.

But nowhere does he suggest that a constitutional amendment to repeal the 2nd would be a bad thing; he doesn't even touch on the amendment process at all.

(Also I don't get where he's saying that conservatives love the 1st and second, liberals love the 4th, 5th, and 6th, and they both hate what the other loves. I have a dim view of the 2nd but I'm pretty happy with the other 9. It's kinda ridiculous to suggest that liberal are against the 1st.)

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by nraynaud on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:18AM (#16471649)
This amendment feels so random, tho. Why firearms and not other weapons? Why not general means of defense?

There are also consistency issues, the prohibition was an amendment, what made that thing negociable?

Other fundamental rules are completely inconsistent like being 21 to drink while the majority is 18.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by bitwize on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:44AM (#16472628)
> Why firearms and not other weapons?

Something something bringing a knife to a gun fight...

The amendment doesn't specify firearms; it just so happens that firearms are the most contentious weapons protected under it, for obvious reasons: firearms are among the most deadly weapons in common use, but hoplophilic citizens do not want to be denied access to weapons their enemies have access to. Nevertheless, there was a Second Amendment case brought to the Supremes (Caetano v. Massachusetts) about a woman's right to buy a stun gun, which was illegal in Massachusetts. The Supremes found in her favor.

As for why the Second is considered "special" -- it's part of the Bill of Rights. There's nothing stopping anybody from repealing it, but the ten amendments in the Bill of Rights are considered special in American legal tradition because the promise of their passage was essential to the ratification of the Constitution itself. So it would take much more effort to gather support for repeal of a Bill of Rights amendment than the Eighteenth Amendment (which was largely passed because of the temporary political vogue of the temperance movement).

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by IIAOPSW on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:28AM (#16471676)
>This amendment feels so random, tho. Why firearms and not other weapons?

But it does cover other weapons. You can own as my knives as you want. The exact text is "the right to keep and bear arms". Firearms isn't specified.

>prohibition was an amendment, what made that thing negociable?

It wasn't negotiable. There was another amendment to repeal it.

>Other fundamental rules are completely inconsistent like being 21 to drink while the majority is 18.

While true this is inconsistent, it isn't actually in the constitution. In theory states can set drinking and majority age as high and low as they want.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by skookumchuck on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:27AM (#16471675)
Glad to see my opinion is shared, and he writes a lot better than I do, too!
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by stdbrouw on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:25AM (#16472546)
In Europe, democratic countries regularly amend their constitution because parts of it have become archaic, obsolete or insane. We have yet to descend into chaos or tyranny.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by seren on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @07:40AM (#16472865)
As a fellow European, I am also regularly surprised by the absolute reverence to the US Constitution. Sure, it is a fundamental law and it cannot be changed lightly, but like any other piece of legislation it seems normal to update it regularly.

Edit : after looking at the actual list of amendments, at least one was repelled after being introduced (regarding the Prohibition) so it seems they are not as immutable as I believed.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by adamrezich on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:20PM (#16476884)
The whole amendment process is designed exactly for this reason. The problem is, nobody seems to want to actually propose a 2nd Amendment repeal and begin the legal process and see if it actually works (because it won't). So instead, everyone gets to whine about gun rights on social media instead of actually working towards accomplishing the goals they claim to be in favor of.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by skookumchuck on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @11:49AM (#16475213)
Your rights are under constant attack as well, and you've definitely got fewer ones than in the US.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by seren on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:02PM (#16475382)
You mean like the GDPR ?
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by jakeogh on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:30PM (#16476985)
The EU is going to dissolve under it's own regulatory weight. The GDPR is tactical incrementalism of "compliance" procedures. If it lasts long enough people will realize it's not about making them more free.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by bitwize on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:32AM (#16472571)
This is what I, as a pro-gun-control person, keep saying.

By all means, agitate for gun control. But in order to do so you need to successfully present a case for Second Amendment repeal. Anything less -- such as the collective-rights argument -- means that you've empowered the courts to interpret away the force of the Second Amendment. And once you've unleashed that beast, you won't be able to control it. The courts will interpret away the First, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, and Eighth Amendments, and then we're in really deep shit.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by UncleMeat on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:16PM (#16479844)
Why? Did repealing the 18th set off a rash of destruction of right?
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by toomanybeersies on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:36AM (#16471502)
The first is being attacked by conservatives.

Attacking the Bill of Rights isn't exclusive to one end of the political spectrum.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by notMick on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:14AM (#16471639)
Seriously? The only people keeping the first amendment there are the conservatives!

The left are trying to remove it with their various 'hate speech' laws (already done in many countries, say the 'wrong thing' on Facebook in the UK and you have the police coming to arrest you in hours) which can be applied to anything the left simply don't want you to say - and silencing you is fundamental to far left ideology.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by toomanybeersies on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @06:42AM (#16472616)
You have Donald Trump trying to undermine the news media, attacking people for expressing their opinions by refusing to stand for the anthem, calling for stripping the citizenship from those who burn the US flag, and wanting a ban on Muslims entering the country.

Attacks on individual liberties are not limited to a particular political ideology.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by akkat on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:04AM (#16473001)
By "attacking" you mean calling some news fake news and criticizing other people's political statements. Those things are within the law. Jailing people for their political opinion, like they do in UK, China and Iran, is a violation.

Anyone trying to make laws allowing those things would be attacking the first.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by isleyaardvark on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:00PM (#16476054)
The Trump adminstration was literally exploring changing the First Amendment:

http://theweek.com/speedreads/695695/reince-priebus-admits-t...

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by grzm on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:41AM (#16471523)
I'm a big fan of the amendments as well. I think we're all better served when we focus on specific issues that we can discuss together rather than splitting us up into two camps. As long as we look at everything through a partisan lens, we're going to continue to increase the friction preventing us from finding common ground and understanding.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by skookumchuck on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:50AM (#16471559)
The BoR transcends partisan politics.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by grzm on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:54AM (#16471570)
Agreed. Which is why it's important to not lose them while we fight amongst ourselves for not being of the correct political persuasion.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by protomyth on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:18AM (#16471654)
Thank goodness the 3rd isn't an issue!

There is an old Dr Dobbs article that mentions that the 3rd might be the key to keeping the government from installing mandatory software on our computers. A stretch, but don’t forget the intent of that amendment.

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by tlrobinson on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:44AM (#16471745)
There's also an argument that cryptography should be protected by the 2nd amendment (not to mention the 1st and 5th).

For a long time the US government classified cryptography as "munitions" subject to export regulations (though not all "munitions" are "arms") https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_th...

Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by gnode on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:09PM (#16477345)
I don't believe that interpretation is a stretch at all. Griswold vs. Connecticut established that the 3rd amendment infers a right to privacy from the government in one's home.
Re:How We Learned to Love the Bill of Rights by guelo on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:56AM (#16471577)
I Just wanted to point out that conservatives are constantly attacking the 1st amendment by repeatedly trying to establish a state religion.