News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diaspora doesn’t have what it takes to topple Facebook by stcredzero on Monday August 30, 2010 @11:36AM (#1646476)
For encryption to be worth something, it needs to be unencrypted by the end user. However, I don't see how they'd do that. Browsers don't integrate this functionality and one could write a plugin, but that's a big barrier to adoption.

I'm not sure why a plugin is necessary. Javascript can do encryption. Actually, I'm not even sure why airtight end-to-end encryption is necessary. Most people will use a "standard" install. The "standard" install will honor the good-faith deletion requests. Those not using a standard install are SOL. Those who have gotten hacked -- there will be a continual arms race just as there is now. This is nothing new. It's still a far cry better than Big Company Has All Your Data Just Trust Us.

Re:Diaspora doesn’t have what it takes to topple Facebook by stevejohnson on Monday August 30, 2010 @12:40PM (#1646692)
The reason Javascript won't do the trick is that in order to send the correct Javascript, the server needs to have all the information necessary to decrypt all the content anyway. So there's no point in the encryption at all, because the information will pass through the server unencrypted at some stage and can be captured.

If this were implemented as a browser feature or plugin, machines with the user's key information installed would be the only devices capable of decrypting the content sent by the server.

Re:Diaspora doesn’t have what it takes to topple Facebook by stcredzero on Monday August 30, 2010 @01:00PM (#1646767)
My point is also that there's (almost) no point in the encryption at all. If Diaspora is going to be P2P, then any compromised node can hijack the data. The only point of encryption would be to protect information enroute. Once information gets to a node, you either need trust, white box encryption, or hardware based DRM.
Re:Diaspora doesn’t have what it takes to topple Facebook by eli on Monday August 30, 2010 @12:39PM (#1646688)
So all these different 'book sites are going to send javascript decryption code with their pages? And how exactly would you prevent one from just stealing your password or being modified in transit?