Re:Inside the OED: can the world’s biggest dictionary surviv...
by forapurpose on Sunday February 25, 2018 @06:24PM
(#16461829)
> One Wiktionary contributor did a better job
If we define "better" by speed, then every HN comment is better than every book ever published, and all the blog posts on climate change are better than the scientific research. I find it's the opposite: The things that take longer to publish are usually better.
[…]
A few days ago, I emailed to see if ‘mansplain’ had finally reached the OED. It had, but there was a snag – further research had pushed the word back a crucial six months, from February 2009 to August 2008. Then, no sooner had Paton’s entry gone live in January than someone emailed to point out that even this was inaccurate: they had spotted ‘mansplain’ on a May 2008 blog post, just a month after the writer Rebecca Solnit had published her influential essay Men Explain Things to Me. The updated definition, Proffitt assured me, will be available as soon as possible.”
One Wiktionary contributor did a better job[1] in 2012 by immediately finding the use[2] from May 2008. The OED is more Prestigious and Respectable and Authoritative, but the Wiktionary is more comprehensive, informative, reliable, convenient, useful, also cheaper.
[1]: https://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Citations:manspl...
[2]: https://web.archive.org/web/20130518221612/http://www.journa...