I'd say people may as well forget about Apple's "privacy stance". It's nothing but smokescreen at this point (yes, even in the U.S.).
Could you support this claim please?
Re: iCloud backups you're correct. So far. They're about to release iMessages-in-iCloud though, which might obviate the need to include them in iCloud backups.
[1]https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf
Still, you are correct that a determined adversary, potentially one capable of purchasing a quantum computer with enough quibits could factor the device key. It would be nice to see Apple move to a large enough ECC key which would improve security against quantum computing attacks in particular.
Did something change?
I won’t underestimate the rate at which they are developed though, it takes 2x the key size as the number of quibits to run Shor’s algorithm - ~2600 is a lot smaller than 4096, and even then who knows how much time we have until that happens.
Anyone concerned about privacy, the first thing they should be ensuring is they are NOT using iCloud backup.
Is that how iDevices work ? You do data backup with your mp3 player ?
Is there really no Finder equivalent on an iphone ?
Genuinely curious ...
So yeah iTunes is still a core concern when it comes to managing iOS devices of certain types. When iPhone came out the primary selling points included it being an iPod, were you there? I was. There is no way in hell they were going to let go of the signature usability boon that people relied on and made them rich.
So yeah, iPhone was managed by iTunes and for a long time it was the only way to manage media, contacts, etc. on it or do that sort of thing. iPad was included in this, as well.
Over time, alternative options for managing your device data and such have been implemented. Today you can use iOS devices without ever once connecting to iTunes if you want. Sure. On the device there is a file browser though it's semi sandboxed as you can imagine. You can backup to the cloud if you want hence this discussion. It's all independent. If you want.
However, iTunes still provides some very useful abilities. Besides offering a vastly improved UI for managing your media, it offers things like full image restores, deep encrypted backups (requiring no internet access to restore) and recovery features. You can place data directly into individual app sandboxes, or copy videos/music/etc. directly to device.
Despite what another commenter mentioned, I very much doubt these features will be removed. Maybe they will move out of iTunes. A long time ago there used to be a tool called iSync that was dedicated to device sync/interactions on Mac OS X and I could see that kind of approach being revived. It's very nice to have an OS provided, reliable way to recover a bricked phone, or recover backups without blowing an entire weekend of downloading/installing not to mention data usage restrictions many people still endure.
Anyway, TL;DR: you can use iTunes but you don't have to because history.
My guess is they're waiting for more complete coverage in terms of iCloud functionality and maybe security. But Apple has been known to pull the plug on "pro" functionality like this and/or remove functionality before the replacement was quite ready yet.
http://www.libimobiledevice.org
On macOS (I also use it on Linux, haven't tried on Windows):
brew install libimobiledevice
## to disable iCloud backups
idevicebackup2 cloud off
## if you want encrypted backups (native encryption)
idevicebackup2 encryption on -i
## backup to a folder
idevicebackup2 backup backup-folder
## restore from a backup
idevicebackup2 restore backup-folder
This uses the same format as iTunes, which stores them in ~/Library/Application Support/MobileSync/BackupThere are more utilities included:
idevice_id idevicedebugserverproxy idevicenotificationproxy
idevicebackup idevicediagnostics idevicepair
idevicebackup2 ideviceenterrecovery ideviceprovision
idevicecrashreport ideviceimagemounter idevicescreenshot
idevicedate ideviceinfo idevicesyslog
idevicedebug idevicename iproxy
You can also mount your iPhone's filesystem using ifuse (the only one in a separate package): brew cask install osxfuse
brew install ifuse
## mount your iPhone
ifuse mount-point
## unmount, or eject using Finder
umount mount-point
Parts of these protocols have been around since the first iPhones, I find it highly unlikely Apple will remove these anytime soon.It seems that China would just need to do a bit of work but they still can get every piece of data on the device.
Unfortunately does not apply to regular iCloud backups or most other data. But a major step forward.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BLGFriOKz6U&feature=youtu.be...
AFAIK I never had to define an encryption password for an iCloud backup only for local backups with iTunes which means that the device only needs my Apple account credentials to retrieve and decrypt a backup from iCloud as such China and for that matter any entity which gains lawful or unlawful access to your Apple account gets to have the keys to the kingdom.
I can download a backup from iCloud and unpack it in any device or use a 3rd party application to view to content of the backup and the only thing I need is the Apple account password used for iCloud.
- Apple security architect, in the aforelinked video, which you still didn't watch
- iMessage
- Keychain
- Siri data
And more like health, home & payments.
While it's unfortunate that Apple couldn't compel China to run their government requests for data through the U.S. court system, in my view it is pretty amazing that they are "getting away" with keeping the most sensitive data end-to-end encrypted.
I mean China shut down WhatsApp last year and iMessage is of a similar level of security.[2] Then again nobody really uses iMessage in China. They do use keychain.
[1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303
[2] https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf