News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by IBM on Friday February 23, 2018 @05:42PM (#16450256)
Apple's statements to the press about this have repeatedly said [1]:

>Apple has strong data privacy and security protections in place and no backdoors will be created into any of our systems.

iMessage is end-to-end encrypted and has never been blocked in China, while services like WhatsApp are [2]. During the FBI brouhaha, the national security establishment water holders started writing op-eds on blogs like Lawfare suggesting that Apple was being hypocritical in opposing the FBI, alleging that they had already given the jewels away to China [3]. The DoJ basically parroted this in their filings to the court, accusing Apple of this outright (whether or not the op-eds were co-ordinated with the DoJ is unclear). Fortunately, this led to Apple responding to these accusations in their own filings to the court [4], including this declaration from Craig Federighi under threat of perjury [5]:

>5. Apple uses the same security protocols everywhere in the world.

>6. Apple has never made user data, whether stored on the iPhone or in iCloud, more technologically accessible to any country's government. We believe any such access is too dangerous to allow. Apple has also not provided any government with its proprietary iOS source code. While governmental agencies in various countries, including the United States, perform regulatory reviews of new iPhone releases, all that Apple provides in those circumstances is an unmodified iPhone device.

>7. It is my understanding that Apple has never worked with any government agency from any country to create a "backdoor" in any of our products and services.

>I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct.

Assuming Craig Federighi didn't perjure himself, why has China seemingly made an exception for Apple when it comes to iMessage (or iOS or iCloud)? The answer is that Apple is the only tech company that actually has leverage with the CPC in (indirectly) employing millions of workers in China. People have criticized Apple for taking down the NYT's app or VPN apps in the App Store in China and for not resisting it, but Apple is rightly picking their battles to protect the crown jewels.

[1] https://9to5mac.com/2018/01/10/apple-will-begin-storing-chin...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/25/business/china-whatsapp-b...

[3] https://www.lawfareblog.com/deposing-tim-cook

[4] https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/2762131/C-D-Cal-1...

[5] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2762118-Federighi-De...

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by abalone on Saturday February 24, 2018 @12:48AM (#16451942)
> Assuming Craig Federighi didn't perjure himself, why has China seemingly made an exception for Apple when it comes to iMessage (or iOS or iCloud)? The answer is that Apple is the only tech company that actually has leverage with the CPC in (indirectly) employing millions of workers in China.

Eh, there’s a simpler explanation: Basically bobody uses iMessage in China.

Employing people in China is only leverage is they can readily move production elsewhere (nope, not at that scale).

Not that it counts for nothing but the real issue here is iMessage is just a non issue for China.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by ksec on Saturday February 24, 2018 @02:27AM (#16452205)
But what happens if People start using it? It is like Whatsapp, it was allowed to use as long as it didn't reach a critical mass.

So in some way Apple is praying imessages not succeed in China.

I am glad the current privacy issues is not yet a problem in China. But someday Apple will have to deal with it, and unlike US where there is a system of Law to protect companies and Citizen, there isn't one in China. ( At least not by normal Western understanding of "Law" )

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by Twisell on Saturday February 24, 2018 @08:18AM (#16453138)
It all depend of China real motivation:

-publicly they state that servers need to be in China because they don’t want to hand Chinese citizen data to foreign country. This is nowhere incompatible with iMessage

- privately people suspect that China want to increase mass surveillance to a point even worse than what the USA was already doing with prism. If this is true yes iMessage is incompatible in the long run

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by abalone on Saturday February 24, 2018 @03:31AM (#16452351)
That is a very good question. I doubt they are praying for failure though.
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by socceroos on Friday February 23, 2018 @06:24PM (#16450510)
> It is my understanding that Apple has never worked with any government agency from any country...

Not exactly inspiring.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by IBM on Friday February 23, 2018 @06:35PM (#16450567)
Here's something more unequivocal from Apple's main response [1].

>Finally, the government attempts to disclaim the obvious international implications of its demand, asserting that any pressure to hand over the same software to foreign agents “flows from [Apple’s] decision to do business in foreign countries . . . .” Opp. 26. Contrary to the government’s misleading statistics (Opp. 26), which had to do with lawful process and did not compel the creation of software that undermines the security of its users, Apple has never built a back door of any kind into iOS, or otherwise made data stored on the iPhone or in iCloud more technically accessible to any country’s government. See Dkt. 16-28 [Apple Inc., Privacy, Gov’t Info. Requests]; Federighi Decl. ¶¶ 6–7. The government is wrong in asserting that Apple made “special accommodations” for China (Opp. 26), as Apple uses the same security protocols everywhere in the world and follows the same standards for responding to law enforcement requests. See Federighi Decl. ¶ 5.

[1] https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/2762131/C-D-Cal-1...

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by mtgx on Saturday February 24, 2018 @01:18AM (#16452029)
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by yorwba on Saturday February 24, 2018 @01:59AM (#16452141)
The rest of the quote is "...to create a "backdoor" in any of our products and services."

Which you won't be able to easily find evidence for, even if they did do it.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by kodablah on Friday February 23, 2018 @06:11PM (#16450443)
I don't think a doc about how they operated two years ago is still applicable is it? Especially since this is a recent "decision" by Apple. The article put it best:

> they should say explicitly and unambiguously what they’ve done

Why would they choose to be guarded and opaque? I think the silence speaks volumes...otherwise, I can't understand why it's pervasive. Can't they just be clear and transparent and answer the question we all have here and move on?

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by IBM on Friday February 23, 2018 @06:17PM (#16450477)
Their press statements about this "recent decision" have always reiterated that there are no backdoors.

>Why would they choose to be guarded and opaque?

I mean isn't the answer to this obvious? Sure, Apple could come out and spell this out for everyone, but this is extremely political and Apple is not going to be better served by loudly touting how they are in a privileged position relative to others because they have their own cards to play with the CPC.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by kodablah on Friday February 23, 2018 @06:22PM (#16450501)
"No backdoors" has nothing to do with whether the Chinese Government own and/or use the front door.

> I mean isn't the answer to this obvious?

I thought it was obvious... because they know we won't like the answer. But it seems none of us know. It is really easy, regardless of political harm, to issue statements about data privacy for one country. Not so much for another... making other public statements about citizen data privacy more hollow if they only make them when they think they can. It's a clear case of principles vs money to me.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by ec109685 on Friday February 23, 2018 @11:04PM (#16451594)
Apple can break end to end encryption if it wants to by introducing another device they control as a receipient for iMessage messages.
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by abalone on Saturday February 24, 2018 @12:51AM (#16451951)
True! But this also would be detectable by security researchers monitoring the output of devices. Just comparing bandwidth usage would reveal if there is an extra recipient.
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by ec109685 on Saturday February 24, 2018 @01:28AM (#16452056)
Not if you weren’t a security researcher though, assuming this was a targeted attack.
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by abalone on Saturday February 24, 2018 @02:01AM (#16452146)
Look, if Apple is the adversary and willing to lie under oath then there’s not much anyone could do. They could sign and push crafted firmware to a target device, game over.

The question at hand is, if you trust that iMessage/iCloud works as documented, how does an adversarial third party cloud affect it. So far it looks like iMessage and keychain are still secure end to end encrypted. Apple never had the keys to those to begin with.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by ec109685 on Saturday February 24, 2018 @02:31AM (#16452212)
With iMessage they don’t need to push anything to the device.

I think Apple should provide a way to know who you are talking to has changed rather than saying, “trust us”, we won’t do anything bad.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by abalone on Saturday February 24, 2018 @03:37AM (#16452362)
Actually iOS does notify you when another device has joined your trust circle. So if you pay attention to that you’d know you’re being monitored. Suppressing that would need a crafted OS pushed to the device.

iMessage is very secure. The real question is what would China do if it takes off (no one uses it there).

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by ec109685 on Saturday February 24, 2018 @12:52PM (#16454370)
If you are talking to person A and they get a new phone, how do you know that happened?
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by abalone on Saturday February 24, 2018 @03:06PM (#16455066)
You don't, and it would arguably violate their privacy if you did. But they do.
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by ec109685 on Monday February 26, 2018 @07:55AM (#16464919)
What stops Apple telling your iMessage that person A got a new phone but not telling person A it is telling your iMessage that?
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by abalone on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:10PM (#16476797)
See earlier comment re: Apple as the adversary.
Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by aluhut on Saturday February 24, 2018 @09:12AM (#16453296)
> The answer is that Apple is the only tech company that actually has leverage with the CPC in (indirectly) employing millions of workers in China.

You can assume that or you can assume that they need the access to the huge market which would be a much higher leverage for China over Apple.

Both not more then thought experiments by people not actually having any insight.

Re:Apple in China: who holds the keys? by all_usernames on Friday February 23, 2018 @09:21PM (#16451257)
>7. "It is my understanding that..."