News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by zakk on Thursday February 22, 2018 @03:00AM (#16436008)
I think that’s a lost cause, sadly.

The manufacturer can and will make the device more and more difficult to tear apart, and less modular.

This can partly be a design choice, but also affects the possibility of repairing...

Still, I am not a lawyer but I don’t see how a judge could enforce internal design choices...

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by Buge on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:13AM (#16436311)
There are 3 possibilities for repairing:

1. The government makes a law saying companies have to let you repair.

2. No laws, companies can make it hard to repair, and you can try to repair.

3. The government makes it illegal to repair (because of DRM). This is the current situation.

It would be nice to go from 3 to 2.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by dingo_bat on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:19AM (#16436336)
0. The government makes a law saying companies have to sell spare parts at reasonable prices.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by simonh on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:57AM (#16436723)
Who gets to decide what constitutes a spare part on, say, a car? Should a cam shaft be a part or is it ok just to sell whole engines? That’s a really nice big can of worms you’re opening.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by lmm on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:22AM (#16436823)
Just mandate minimum warranty periods like the EU does. If the company wants to only replace whole cars then they can, but they'll bear the cost of doing so.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by simonh on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:25AM (#16436836)
I don’t see what that’s got to do with after market sale of parts. Of course manufacturers have access to individual components and can stock them during warranty periods as they already have to, but making every single possible component of every product ever sold available indefinitely after the warranty period seems like it would drive costs up through the roof.

I usually find myself arguing against people with what O think is a bit of a blinkered faith in market forces solving all and regulation being the work of the devil. But in this case, unless there really is a demonstrable monopoly position that’s being abused, it should be up to customers to decide if after market parts availability is something they care about in their purchasing decision.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by lmm on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:44AM (#16436906)
I think the market fails here because consumers don't really have the information to let future part support factor into their purchase decision. Compare lemon laws which are widely accepted as a positive example of regulatory intervention in the market.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by throwaway2048 on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:35PM (#16439398)
"every single possible component of every product ever sold available indefinitely after the warranty period" is a vast overexageration, the limit is generally 10 years for stuff like cars, and it encourages parts to be interchangable to cut down on inventory costs ( and incidentally waste too..)
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by logfromblammo on Thursday February 22, 2018 @11:11AM (#16438569)
Such a definition is moot if you could sue for a court order then go to a dealership with a sheriff's deputy in tow and take just the part you wanted out of a brand-new car, and the dealer could in turn recover all of its costs for that now-unsellable vehicle from the manufacturer.

There would be a great incentive to warehouse and sell "spare parts". And they would have to be every individual discrete part, and every subassembly that can be handled as a unit. If you just sold engines, you might end up with an unusable nearly-engine because someone came along and picked just the parts they needed off of it. If you just sold engine parts, you might end up with an unusable nearly-car because someone picked a whole, assembled engine out of it.

So every type of screw, nut, bolt, and washer. Every type of transmission assembly and engine assembly. Every passenger seat. Every floor mat. Every light bulb and every plastic housing. Every wiring harness. Every radio and CD player.

This is itself a great incentive to use COTS parts, reduce number of unique parts, and adhere to standards. Maybe you use a #6 bolt somewhere instead of trimming weight and cost a tiny bit by using a #5 there. Maybe you standardize the dimensions and mount points of your engine compartments, so that 20 years from now, replacement engines can be diverted from the supply chain for newer cars rather than pulled from a warehouse stockpile that has been taking space and gathering dust that whole time. Or maybe you set up your spare parts facility to do on-demand manufacturing or assembly.

It is a big can of worms. But I'd argue that not opening it now would be allowing it to grow even bigger and wormier as time goes on.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by anilakar on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:33AM (#16436862)
It's not that difficult.

If you have an internal ERP product code for the spare part in question, it is swappable.

If the repair shop asks for a single IC chip instead of a complete PCB or ECU, they obviously have the skills and need to replace it, making it a valid spare part request.

If you need software or specialized tools to configure or install a part, you obviously cannot withhold said tools from the repair shop.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by amdavidson on Thursday February 22, 2018 @07:47AM (#16437171)
Having a part number in my system does not mean that it is a reasonable case for a spare part.

These are actual examples from my business: I have part numbers for raw powders that I have not yet sintered into ceramics. I have part numbers for parts that go into a welded and inseparable sub-assemblies. I have part numbers for components that are bonded together with glass seals that cannot be repaired if separated.

It is easy to see how you cannot just use the BOM to determine the list of spare parts and it is easy to see how a manufacturer could simply pot their whole unit in epoxy for "structural" reasons and prevent any individual spare part or sub-assembly from being useful.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by admax88q on Thursday February 22, 2018 @08:38AM (#16437416)
To be fair though, if the law mandated that you make all of those available as spare parts you could. Even if many of them are not useful to most consumers, it's not like you're unable to sell some of the ceramic powder, or one part of a welded component.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by chuckkir on Thursday February 22, 2018 @02:24PM (#16440570)
But maintaining this inventory of partial parts that maybe one person might request for perhaps long after production has stopped is cost (and space) prohibitive. Sure you could do it, but then it probably wouldn't make sense to build the widget in the first place.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by bluGill on Thursday February 22, 2018 @10:27AM (#16438150)
As a manufacture can we do the same? Can I force whoever made the IC that broke to make a new one? It seems like every year we are redesigning out boards because another part went out of production.

We have a lot of embedded systems written in assembly for an 8-bit CPU that is no longer made. The electronics are easy (I'm not an EE) but it will be years before we can replace the software that currently has been running in the field with zero known bugs - I'd love to get those CPUs that work perfectly made again. Instead we bought a warehouse worth, and we hope it is enough to satisfy all our warranty needs.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by logfromblammo on Thursday February 22, 2018 @11:43AM (#16438873)
If your systems are designed for greater modularity, then it would be easier to replace board X version 2, in a vehicle that was manufactured when version 2 was the production-ready part, with a board X hardware version 8, with firmware 8.0-2.2 installed to emulate the part that was shipped with the vehicle.

The important thing is that identical inputs yield identical outputs. The rest of the vehicle doesn't care what's in the black box.

Then you wouldn't have to warehouse old, obsolete parts. You just have to warehouse old, obsolete embedded-software developers. That's probably cheaper if you have enough volume.

Also, if your company is still programming in assembly instead of a higher-level language, such as C, which has been available for 45 years now, I can safely say you are all hoist on your own petard. If you really want reliability, there's always Ada. You can't expect the 80196 to stick around forever.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by bluGill on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:20PM (#16439238)
The point is we need to design hardware version 8, that is not free. Our volumes are not very high: designing revision 7 in the actually lifespan now that we need version 8 means that the cost/per part of version 7 was a few thousand dollars for a board that costs ~$5 to manufacture. If we had known what part would be next version 7 wouldn't have used that part.

The vehicle does not care what is in the black box, but that is only true once input/outputs are actually identical. It is .01 volts different has killed us in random failures. It is 1ms faster, is that better or now - in some cases that 1ms slower was depended on and we didn't know it anymore.

We don't program anything new in assembly. However for a lot of old embedded controllers if it works don't break it. There are no known bugs with the old code. Suddenly the CPU isn't available and we have to create a new one. Marketing can't come up with any new feature that a new CPU would enable so it is strictly and engineering exercise.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by logfromblammo on Thursday February 22, 2018 @02:35PM (#16440664)
> However for a lot of old embedded controllers if it works don't break it.

If you don't maintain it, you are allowing it to break through neglect. That's like saying if the old oil works in an engine, you shouldn't bother changing it. It works great, right up until it doesn't, and then you have a bigger problem.

Software development is an incurable disease. Once you start, you can't ever stop.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by mtgx on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:08AM (#16436766)
Anything that breaks from the final product. So it's up to the companies to decide how modular they make their products. If it's not to modular, then if anything small breaks, then they'll have to replace entire big pieces. If their devices are super-modular, then they will have to replace only that small part. But of course they also have to make all sorts of different small parts, or have contracts with companies that do.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by simonh on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:23AM (#16436828)
Isn’t that already true now for warranty repairs, or are you talking about extending warranties indefinitely?

The other aspect is, who decides what price components must be sold for?

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by privacypoller on Thursday February 22, 2018 @11:13AM (#16438587)
this already happens with lots of car parts. One example: say 20 years ago you repacked bearings, now you "just" buy replacement OEM bearing assemblies because they essentially can't be repacked or even disassembled.

"Fixing" lots of appliances means wholesale replacement of the entire "board" (i.e. component representing 90% of the total electronics) which likely never makes the device as good as new but costs almost as much as a replacement unit.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by bdonlan on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:27PM (#16439310)
Component level repairs are definitely possible in many cases - particularly when the issue is a bad electrolytic capacitor or a cracked solder joint - but requires specific electronics experience, which many appliance technicians might not have. Replacing the board becomes a trade-off between more expensive labor vs more expensive parts.

For smaller devices like cell phones it becomes much more difficult due to a combination of miniaturization, specialized parts not available on the general market, and secret schematics that can't easily be derived from the complex multilayer PCBs in use.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by mcguire on Thursday February 22, 2018 @02:01PM (#16440337)
Ford F-150 wheel hub / brake disk combinations, for example.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by opportune on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:27AM (#16436375)
Woah there, that's way too pro-consumer. Won't someone please think of the copyright holders??
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by chii on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:26AM (#16436370)
how does one work out what 'reasonable' mean?

The farming tractor repairs are 'reasonably' priced at the moment (according to the company selling it).

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by rangibaby on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:08AM (#16436543)
Find out how much the company pays for that repair when they do an in-warranty replacement
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by stctgion on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:10AM (#16436551)
A price such that if you bought the entire product from their spares catalogue that the total would equal the list price of the full product.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:51AM (#16436930)
It's going to be much cheaper to administer the sale of a single vehicle over the individual sale of each part. I'd expect it to cost maybe twice as much?

Currently I'm looking for a toothed belt for a bread-maker - best price I can find is a quarter of the cost of a new bread-maker (15€ delivered), that seems a bit ridiculous to me.

The belt was in crumbs, locked behind security screws. How many functional devices have been dumped for want of a simple belt replacement I wonder.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by ghaff on Thursday February 22, 2018 @07:59AM (#16437224)
That's never been remotely true even with third-party aftermarket parts. I imagine if that were the law, granular parts simply wouldn't be sold by anyone.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by dingo_bat on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:18AM (#16436575)
I'd be ok with 20% variation too.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by nephrite on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:38AM (#16436648)
5. Government mandates that company must repair any equipment it ever produced free of charge or provide replacement free of charge. No timeouts. Basically extend guarantee to infinity.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by rangibaby on Thursday February 22, 2018 @03:55AM (#16436240)
> The manufacturer can and will make the device more and more difficult to tear apart

The company built the thing. There are tools, parts, and instructions that tell someone how to put it together. There are also tools, parts, and instructions that tell someone how to take it apart.

It may require special tools and parts, but for any mass-market item it won't be difficult with the right tools and the knowledge of how to do it.

The reason for this is that the company will lose more money by making it difficult to repair for themselves than they will ever lose to a DIY repairman.

My solution for DIY repairs:

- Official, real service manual made available. If you allow the company to provide a "monkey" version they certainly will.

- All neccesary parts and tools available at cost, or the cost of their generic equivalent in case of things like proprietary screwdrivers etc.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by Pica_soO on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:33AM (#16436394)
There are also tools, parts, and instructions that tell someone how to take it apart.

>Do not try to repair a faulty device. Replace it with a new one in which you transfer the customers data. The device is filled with epoxy glue- disassembly equals destruction.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by rangibaby on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:53AM (#16436475)
and what device is expensive enough for me to want to fix instead of buying a new one, but cheap enough for the manufacturer to just throw out?
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by michaelt on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:23AM (#16436827)
Imagine BMW can make electronic engine control units for $10 each, and the spare part market will bear them charging $500 for them, so they do charge that much.

When I repair it saves me $500 but when the manufacturer repairs it only saves them $10.

Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by PeterisP on Thursday February 22, 2018 @08:53AM (#16437510)
What do you mean by "cheap enough for the manufacturer to just throw out"? The manufacturer generally has no need to fix the devices after the warranty period, they're not necessarily in the repair business. If the devices are designed not to be fixable and need to be replaced then you throw it out and buy a new one from them, earning them more profit than the repair would have. If their warranty defect rate is low enough, they have no need to be able to repair them themselves.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by roblabla on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:28AM (#16436845)
Look at the surface pro 1. Fully unrepairable.
Re:Disney loses bid to stop Redbox from selling its digital ... by jacobush on Thursday February 22, 2018 @03:33AM (#16436128)
Still, it's one thing to make a device hard to repair - it's another to bring state enforced penalties against people who decide to nevertheless tinker.