Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by moomin on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:52PM
(#16433309)
I’m going to be a contrarian here, but I’ve really come around to Consider Phlebas. I wasn’t impressed the first time I read it, but I’ve read it over ten times.
Unlike Games and Weapons, the theme isn’t as explicit, but Identity permeates everything in the story. I genuinely think it’s an unsung masterpiece. Excession, as much as people love it, is pretty much pure entertainment. Phlebas, Games and Weapons all leave you with stuff to think about afterwards.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by philipkglass on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @05:35PM
(#16433601)
Consider Phlebas and Look to Windward make a great matched pair. The first introduces the Culture and a bunch of crackling ideas around the beautiful fantasy of a post-scarcity, post-mortality, post-stupidity civilization. It's 31 years old but still feels fresher than most new SF, because the author embraces the weird, wild possibilities of his fictional technology instead of nerfing/overlooking them for the sake of audience familiarity.
Look to Windward is a great follow-up, emphasizing that you can have the smartest, best-intentioned, most powerful military ever and still fuck up when you try to use it to fix another civilization. The rage of the survivors of the Culture's intervention is quite justifiable, though the means of attempted retaliation isn't. From my brief description you might think that it was an allegory dashed off in response to the occupation of Afghanistan or Iraq, but the book was published in 2000. Banks was ahead of the curve.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by kirrent on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:40PM
(#16432787)
It might not be the strongest, but I think it might be one of the easiest to film. Lots of action and interaction between characters compared to something like Player of Games which has a lot of internal monologue.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by GCU-Empiricist on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:40PM
(#16432788)
That's the weird thing: If I rember right Consider Phlebas is by far the worst book to adapt to introduce the Culture, because of how prevalent the Idrian religion (an expy for various militant religious groups) is to the plot and action. As you said lets hope we get all of them, especially Excession IMHO.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by walkingolof on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:46PM
(#16432837)
The merit of Consider Phlebas is the potential of a fantastic scifi/action/adventure series, its easy to make TV off, Excession is the other side of the spectrum, a bunch of Minds talking :)
In the end, Im a fan, Im glad that this happens, just a damn shame that Mr. Banks never got to see it.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by Analemma_ on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:28PM
(#16433141)
It could be interesting though: Phelbas was neat because it introduced the Culture from the POV of an outsider who hated them, and even sometimes admitted that his hate could sometimes be irrational. A utopia (or "utopia") from the perspective of a non-participant who deliberately sides with militant religious groups he doesn't even like would be a fresh change of perspective compared to a lot of television.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by maxander on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @06:29PM
(#16433907)
Yeah yeah, I’m excited too. But it figures this is being done by Amazon- for years they’ve been out to condition us to like having all our needs met by an inhuman yet weirdly friendly technological regime.
Good odds the Minds all sound remarkably like Alexa. :)
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by zaphod12 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:18PM
(#16433055)
This is going to be very challenging to film...it's imagined as such a far future world. I'm sure it can be done well, but I feel like it will be a challenge and may ruin my imagined vision.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by atombender on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:54PM
(#16433330)
Syfy's The Expanse shows that a sci-fi adaptation can work if the original vision is fully respected and understood. The Culture novels will certainly not work as a traditional TV space opera after the Star Trek tradition.
One problem is that The Culture has tech that is so futuristic that it rarely shows up in science fiction. Banks' spaceships don't have hulls; they are often described as multiple-kilometer-long, oblong, semi-translucent bubbles whose outer perimeter is maintained by "matter fields", the exteriors and interiors of which the ships can rearrange as they desire; there's no bridge, no screens, and human accommodation is also created on demand. Drones are not humanoid robots, but are more like sleek, floating geometric shapes that can manipulate the world around them with "maniple fields". Then there are the Minds, who only occasionally manifest themselves as avatars in the real world. And so on.
One aspect that will be hard to get right is to accurately reflect Banks' philosophical attitude (and his books have a lot of attitude), which is cynical to the point of nihilism, even when set in a world that is broadly utopian. The inherent conflict is everywhere: On the one hand, the Culture has genetically modified themselves to be peaceful; on the other hand, it's a civilization that is constantly involved in war. The cynicism is often wryly funny; there's a lot of Douglas Adams to found in Banks' writing, and the description of the Outside Context Problem [1] is like something right out of Hitchhiker's Guide. It's not something that would be easy to portray on film, where it'd be necessary to explain backstory and explain how an AI-dominated post-scarcity society can exist that has no money and no labour force.
Consider Phlebas is probably the best book to start with simply because it looks at the Culture from the outside. The show might use this to its advantage by having characters explain aspects of the Culture, such as its post-scarcity society, without being too heavy-handed.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by asteli on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:42PM
(#16433236)
When I think of the Culture series, I immediately think of the descriptions of incredibly vast spacecraft, the General Systems Vehicles and whatnot. Even listening via audiobook, my imagination was able to conjure a fragment of the sensation that one gets when perceiving something with incredible scale. Similar to the sensation I got when I first gazed upon the Rocky Mountains.
I'm happy that the series is getting more exposure, but at the risk of seeming curmudgeonly, the series will remain on my "watch only after reading the books" list.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by duozerk on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:15PM
(#16433031)
It's especially infuriating what they did to Altered Carbon when you consider how much of the changes do not add anything to the adaptation (although a very few were improvements, like Poe); quite the reverse. They also completely castrated the books' political message - especially when it came to religion, and to a lower extent anti-capitalism/centralization.
That being said, I imagine it still makes for a watchable show for someone that knows nothing about the books.
In any case, I love both series and I pray dearly they don't fuck up the Culture adaptation.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by BatFastard on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:47PM
(#16433266)
As someone who has not read the book, I quite enjoy the Netflix series! Give me more! So much good SciFi finally coming in series format!!! Only had to wait 40 years.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by AdeptusAquinas on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @05:26PM
(#16433541)
I read the book and really enjoyed it. I also enjoyed the Netflix series a lot. Theyre different stories, with one inspiring the other. At least with the Netflix series I am hoping that the next season will stick to the theme and atmosphere, unlike the IMO dissapointing book sequels
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by telchar on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:51PM
(#16432868)
I'm hoping they don't respect the plot too much, and improve it instead. Consider Phlebas was by far the worst of the three Culture books I have read so far. It had elements of a great story but IMHO was badly in need of an editor to polish the narrative.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by jonathanyc on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @05:44PM
(#16433661)
Man, I would really like Use of Weapons on TV just to see all the different environments. But I feel like it had probably too challenging of a format to bode well for an adaptation.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by Crespyl on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:45PM
(#16433253)
I'd be so excited for an Honor series. Of my favorite space operas, it's definitely one of the more readily TV-adaptable ones (arguably more easily so than Culture), especially after the success of The Expanse.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by Jedd on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @05:03PM
(#16433401)
This is great news indeed.
I've never directed or produced a movie, and I'm impressed at the number of my fellow HN'ers who have great insight into why this isn't the best book to turn into a film.
For my own part I'm just thrilled that it may finally happen. If it's not up to scratch, it won't diminish the novel(s) for me. But if it's great, I'm going to be way pleased.
Fair to say that anyone who's read and enjoyed a book (or series of books), and subsequently seen a TV or film interpretation of the work, will almost always commend others to read, then watch. (There may be exceptions - never heard of one myself.)
Last year there was news of Amazon looking to develop series around Ringworld (maybe re-use some of the sets :) and Snowcrash. I really liked what they did with Man in the High Castle, so I'm feeling optimistic.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by geden on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:59PM
(#16433376)
Slightly alarming but also tremendously exciting. Alarming because Amazon have yet to produce anything truely great. Exciting because Denis Kelly’s series Utopia was truely unique and special UK SF viewing with a real edge. Plan B also have excellent track record.
Re:Amazon Studios to Adapt Consider Phlebas, First Novel of ...
by Pica_soO on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:25PM
(#16433120)
Even the culture interior is certainly PG-18. Remember- its all better in the culture, they all last longer - and they have those drug glands- so to be honest, how can somebody adapt that faithfully and release it in the usa?
Edit: I read CP in one go during the single day off I had studying for my final exams in my CS degree in '88.
Miz survives and rides off into the sunset with Sharow on the Vrossul tank hunter sigh
Unlike Games and Weapons, the theme isn’t as explicit, but Identity permeates everything in the story. I genuinely think it’s an unsung masterpiece. Excession, as much as people love it, is pretty much pure entertainment. Phlebas, Games and Weapons all leave you with stuff to think about afterwards.
Look to Windward is a great follow-up, emphasizing that you can have the smartest, best-intentioned, most powerful military ever and still fuck up when you try to use it to fix another civilization. The rage of the survivors of the Culture's intervention is quite justifiable, though the means of attempted retaliation isn't. From my brief description you might think that it was an allegory dashed off in response to the occupation of Afghanistan or Iraq, but the book was published in 2000. Banks was ahead of the curve.
In the end, Im a fan, Im glad that this happens, just a damn shame that Mr. Banks never got to see it.
If they do UOW
Good odds the Minds all sound remarkably like Alexa. :)
One problem is that The Culture has tech that is so futuristic that it rarely shows up in science fiction. Banks' spaceships don't have hulls; they are often described as multiple-kilometer-long, oblong, semi-translucent bubbles whose outer perimeter is maintained by "matter fields", the exteriors and interiors of which the ships can rearrange as they desire; there's no bridge, no screens, and human accommodation is also created on demand. Drones are not humanoid robots, but are more like sleek, floating geometric shapes that can manipulate the world around them with "maniple fields". Then there are the Minds, who only occasionally manifest themselves as avatars in the real world. And so on.
One aspect that will be hard to get right is to accurately reflect Banks' philosophical attitude (and his books have a lot of attitude), which is cynical to the point of nihilism, even when set in a world that is broadly utopian. The inherent conflict is everywhere: On the one hand, the Culture has genetically modified themselves to be peaceful; on the other hand, it's a civilization that is constantly involved in war. The cynicism is often wryly funny; there's a lot of Douglas Adams to found in Banks' writing, and the description of the Outside Context Problem [1] is like something right out of Hitchhiker's Guide. It's not something that would be easy to portray on film, where it'd be necessary to explain backstory and explain how an AI-dominated post-scarcity society can exist that has no money and no labour force.
Consider Phlebas is probably the best book to start with simply because it looks at the Culture from the outside. The show might use this to its advantage by having characters explain aspects of the Culture, such as its post-scarcity society, without being too heavy-handed.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Excession#Outside_Context_Prob...
I'm happy that the series is getting more exposure, but at the risk of seeming curmudgeonly, the series will remain on my "watch only after reading the books" list.
That being said, I imagine it still makes for a watchable show for someone that knows nothing about the books.
In any case, I love both series and I pray dearly they don't fuck up the Culture adaptation.
With that being said, and especially if you liked the show, I heartily recommend the books.
I've never directed or produced a movie, and I'm impressed at the number of my fellow HN'ers who have great insight into why this isn't the best book to turn into a film.
For my own part I'm just thrilled that it may finally happen. If it's not up to scratch, it won't diminish the novel(s) for me. But if it's great, I'm going to be way pleased.
Fair to say that anyone who's read and enjoyed a book (or series of books), and subsequently seen a TV or film interpretation of the work, will almost always commend others to read, then watch. (There may be exceptions - never heard of one myself.)
Last year there was news of Amazon looking to develop series around Ringworld (maybe re-use some of the sets :) and Snowcrash. I really liked what they did with Man in the High Castle, so I'm feeling optimistic.
Apply the correct latin phrase, but I've found The Man in the High Castle to be one of the best shows on TV right now.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spacecraft_in_the_Cult...
I have it here on my desk right now- re-reading while working on a hobby project.