There's a difference between being "wrong" (which you're not), and realizing that 99,9% of people in the world aren't you.
IRC will never be used for corporate communication. IRC usage has been declining steadily since 2003[1]. It's over.
Facebook solved a problem that many people had, despite the fact that Myspace, group e-mails, real-time chat and online photo sharing already existed. That's why they today have a market cap of over 500 billion US dollars.
Slack made the concept of IRC usable for "normal people". You're not normal people (that's meant as a compliment), so your capabilities aren't really relevant when looking at why things succeed or fail on a larger scale.
[1]: http://royal.pingdom.com/2012/04/24/irc-is-dead-long-live-ir...
And, to this day, Hotmail is still significantly slower and harder to use compared to Thunderbird. The only advantage is that it still has emails that I received almost 20 years ago.
> IRC will never be used for corporate communication.
As recently as last year, we were using IRC for corporate communication where I work. Fortunately, I'm still able to use the IRC gateway with Slack, but I really don't see any real advantage to using Slack over IRC on a work computer that's always connected. My client's logging easily beats what Slack provides.
> That's why they today have a market cap of over 500 billion US dollars.
I don't think it's because it solved a problem about keeping in touch. It's just an advertising platform and the reason why it has a market cap of that value.
> Slack made the concept of IRC usable for "normal people".
A decade or so ago, I communicated with many normal people over IRC and Usenet. More normal people were able to use chat clients like ICQ, and the various messenger clients (AOL, MSN, Yahoo, Google).
I simply don't see why people keep saying that Slack and hosted chat providers like it are some new innovation that people can finally use when they've been able to do so for the last several decades.
You don't even have to sign up to connect to IRC (though you can register with a nickserv if you want).
> and pay if you want history over 10,000 messages
IRC is only limited by disk space on your local machine.
> IRC, possibly available by hacks/add-ons and not by default or available via quick button, is missing chat history
I'm not sure what you're referring to, but pretty much every client can keep a log of messages sent and received separated by channel/dcc session.
> doesn't support uploads
You can send files to others via DCC.
In any case, the other messenger services I mentioned did not have a long sign up process either. Creating new accounts for AOL instant messenger didn't require much effort at all, for example. Their clients also handled logging much like an IRC client would.
The problem with IRC is that you cannot get chat history of a channel unless you configure a bouncer to do it for you. On that note, what's your opinion on XMPP? We used to use a XMPP server for internal company communication and the server was configured to replay the chat history to a client when it connected.
> Otherwise, just setup a mailing list.
That has a similar problem to IRC which is that new members cannot easily access messages sent before they joined. A better option would be an internally hosted NNTP server.
I like IRC since the protocol is so simple you could almost type in a raw telnet session live.
That simplicity also means it's not to hard to add additional things to it. If you want.
You mean replaying channel chat history on the server side without having to use a bouncer?
> I like IRC since the protocol is so simple you could almost type in a raw telnet session live.
That is true and it makes writing bots relatively easy. From what I've read about XMPP, it appears that most languages have libraries to abstract the XMPP protocol to make writing a bot easier.
Open protocols can certainly do this.
Why separate your communication into two tools instead of one?
If you need real time there is IRC. Otherwise, just setup a mailing list.