News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by nickjj on Saturday February 17, 2018 @03:46PM (#16402597)
"...dipping it into salt water and then thrusting a knife into its brain."

So for a few seconds it will think it's being released back into its natural habitat and then seconds later its brains are dripping down some chef's knife.

The article talks about "animal dignity", but how is that giving them any form of dignity? They are still being killed unnaturally.

NOTE: I'm not some animal rights person and I do eat meat without thinking, and no I've never seen the inside of a slaughter house (and yes I think that would probably scar me for life).

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by fmihaila on Saturday February 17, 2018 @03:47PM (#16402601)
> The article talks about "animal dignity", but how is that giving them any form of dignity? They are still being killed unnaturally.

The point is to minimize unnecessary suffering. If you have to kill it, don't prolong it.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by nickjj on Saturday February 17, 2018 @03:55PM (#16402636)
Yes but dignity is usually related to respect and honor.

When was the last time you killed and ate something out of respect?

They should change that phrase to "reduce cruelty towards animals" and then it's fine. Say it as it is basically.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by fmihaila on Saturday February 17, 2018 @03:59PM (#16402657)
> Yes but dignity is usually related to respect and honor. When was the last time you killed and ate something out of respect?

I don't kill what I eat, but most communities and cultures where this is a regular occurrence have long traditions of respecting the animals being sacrificed. One form of respect is to minimize the animal's suffering (both when it's raised and when it's killed), another is to use all parts of it, another is to not have an unfair advantage when hunting it, and so on. It's not one dimensional.

One of my all-time favourite comments on HN deals with this beautifully:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12655610

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by kaybe on Saturday February 17, 2018 @06:10PM (#16403322)
That really is a beautiful comment.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by bshacklett on Saturday February 17, 2018 @07:06PM (#16403590)
Thanks for sharing this.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by blweiner on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:06PM (#16402695)
I've been struggling with this recently as well. I don't need to kill animals in order to survive and so doing so is just for my pleasure. It's surprisingly easy to put this out of your mind when you're sitting down to a nice dinner, but I do doubt that I'd be able to kill animals if I needed to do it with my own hands. Yet I and most others decide all the time that ending the life of another animal can be justified by the pleasure we'll receive from it when we choose to eat meat. So yeah, I'm also having trouble coming to terms with caring enough to reduce some suffering but still being OK with taking a life.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by rocqua on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:31PM (#16402831)
Why do you, and many contemporaries with you, doubt you'd be able to kill animals? Especially when apparently our ancestors had no such qualms. I venture this is a matter of exposure, we rarely see animals butchered. In fact, most animals we see are pets, contant with wildlife is very minimal.

So we recoil at killing animals, because pets are like family, and most of our experience with animals are with pets. Thus, we see animals as much more human than our ancestors.

What then, does this say about the ethical status of animals. Certainly, it seems like our lack of exposure to butchering is why we now care much more about animals. The issue would be much clearer if things had happened the other way around. That is, things would be clearer if we stopped all butchering animals because we thought animals had rights.

That is not to say this means animals have no rights, it might well be that by no longer killing animals as a manner of habit we realized their ethical standing. However, this is less evident than most other cases where we (the caucasian west) have given other groups more ethical standing.

With slavery, we first realized it was wrong, and then stopped having slaves. The counter point might be that in this analogy we are still before the point of abolishment.

I think all I can conclude is that 'not being able to kill animals' is not a sufficient arguments for animals having more ethical standing. In the end though, it might boil down to ethics not being absolute but instead being relative to culture.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by white-flame on Sunday February 18, 2018 @01:32AM (#16404790)
> So we recoil at killing animals, because pets are like family, and most of our experience with animals are with pets. Thus, we see animals as much more human than our ancestors.

This also heavily depends on how human-like we perceive the animals, both in their behaviors and appearance. Most people would be horrified at seeing a dog slaughtered, but have no problem genociding away the fleas, ticks, and worms living with it.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by sethrin on Saturday February 17, 2018 @06:17PM (#16403361)
Rights are fundamentally a social construct, or perhaps we should say a social compact. So far, animals have a much more limited ability to comprehend and reciprocate our social mores. I believe this may be related to the limits we place on animal rights.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by torstenvl on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:42PM (#16402886)
Human meat consumption typically comes from hunting of prey animals or from domesticated livestock. In the former case, a .30-06 through the heart is a much nicer way to go than to be devoured alive by wolves or coyotes or to starve due to overpopulation. In the latter case, the animal is literally genetically predisposed to this life, and the entire lineage would die out if people did not eat them.

I mean, I get that you think your position is kinder to animals, and there's a certain intuitive value to that position. But ceasing consumption of livestock would, in effect, amount to genocide.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by alkonaut on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:25PM (#16402800)
Who said something about “out of respect”? that makes no sense.

I try to kill anything I’m going to it with dignity and respect. Not out of respect.

And the least I can do to that end is to not kill anything I’m not going to eat, and if I kill anything I make it as quick and painless as possible.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by derefr on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:14PM (#16402739)
> When was the last time you killed and ate something out of respect?

Some indigenous American cultures do make sure to eat the things they've killed, out of respect. You could call that "animal dignity." (You could also consider it a superstitious belief that the animal's spirit will get after them if they disrespect its gifts.)

I also know that in many cultures (at least in previous eras†), if you killed the parents of a family (human or animal), it was seen as correct to kill their babies (i.e. children not yet of an age to fend for themselves) as well, to prevent them from just later succumbing to starvation or predation. That's a form of "animal dignity."

† This mostly came up for human babies in the context of soldiers from an army-on-the-march razing foreign villages. If these villages worshipped a different faith, the whole village would go. But if they worshipped the same faith as the attacking army, the army would likely refuse to burn down the temple of the faith they believed in—and so, rather than kill "innocents", they'd dump them into the hands of the priest of that temple. This was the de-facto invention of the orphanage. Later, orphanages would become formalized as an institution, and spread to the point that soldiers would just assume foreign cultures to have them as well, and so the killing-innocents part of razing villages generally stopped.

(And recently in Western culture, we've invented the equivalent of orphanages for animals as well: wildlife rescue habitats.)

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by user5994461 on Saturday February 17, 2018 @03:59PM (#16402653)
There is nothing more natural than being killed and eaten by one's predator, not necessarily in this order.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by placebo on Sunday February 18, 2018 @12:14AM (#16404577)
I could make a long list of natural behaviours that you really wouldn't want humankind to adopt.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by watwut on Saturday February 17, 2018 @03:52PM (#16402622)
Natural death of an animal in the nature can be quite long and very painful. The point is not to simulate natural kill, the point is to kill the animal without torturing it unnecessary.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by jjeaff on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:15PM (#16402741)
Yes, sometimes when I hear people talk about how we kill animals inhumanely, I feel like they should watch a little bit of national geographic. Makes a sketchy slaughterhouse seem like a picnic.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by dvtv75 on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:53PM (#16402954)
I went on a tour through a slaughterhouse when I was a teen, as part of a school trip. Didn't want to go, but my stepfather decided that it would be "good for" me. I made it clear I didn't want to go and he laughed. He loved the power trip of forcing me to watch animals be killed.

It really messed me up. I won't eat red meat mostly as a result of this, but also because my family were also ridiculously poor cooks. (They were so bad that you wouldn't believe it.)

The smell of the animal fat has stuck with me for nearly thirty years, I can even smell it overpowering the fragrance of perfumed soap. Hand sanitizer, pump soap, and vegetable based soap are fine, but if I have to use ordinary animal soaps, the smell reminds me of what I saw.

I watched a cow be electrocuted, "stunned" they called it. The guide told me that it didn't feel anything because it was in a deep state of shock.

Ever been shocked by a cattle electric fence? When I was 9, I was. You can't move immediately afterward because of the shock of the event, and when the second blast hits you it hits really hard. I felt three of those, it was only when the third struck that I could move, and have no doubt that they were agonizing.

Shocking an animal to stun it, so you can slit its throat and let it die painfully while you dismember it, is no happy little picnic for the beast. This is no easy, painless death. I'm sure it would be agonizing and drawn out over several minutes, and by the time the animal recovers from the shock enough to express its suffering, it's already in pieces and can't.

Roll on lab-grown meat.

Side note: not completely relevant, but I have been attacked by a dog, and I was in shock through that as well. The worst injuries really hurt, but the adrenaline from the attack made me able to get away from the dog. The minor skin injuries I couldn't feel, because the pain centers were being overwhelmed by the worse ones. Between this, and the cattle electric fence, I'm sure they suffer.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by mod on Saturday February 17, 2018 @06:39PM (#16403474)
That seems a lousy way to kill an animal.

I saw a video (which I won't link to you, as I'm certain you don't want to see it) of a phenomenal on-site butcher, he was incredibly precise, fast, etc.

Anyway, the video starts with a live cow, which is killed instantly with a small firearm and a well-placed bullet to the brain.

I butcher animals sometimes (I hunt and have a small homestead) and I would not dream to use any method which involved a death even as slow as bleeding out.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by madengr on Saturday February 17, 2018 @09:07PM (#16404021)
Reminds me of a scene in n House of Cards;

“These ribs are good!”

“Yeah, got me a new butcher. Has a sound proof room in the back. Slow bleeds em’”

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by dsfyu404ed on Saturday February 17, 2018 @08:52PM (#16403959)
So forcing you to see the reality of where meat comes from was a power trip?
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by lukaslalinsky on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:38PM (#16402866)
This is a dangerous route to take, because at that point you can start comparing yourself to animals. We spent a few centuries developing our world, so I think it's fair to assume higher standards. Animals kill other animals to solve their hunger and they do their best to end it quickly.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by PeterisP on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:49PM (#16402923)
"Animals kill other animals to solve their hunger and they do their best to end it quickly." is not entirely true.

Many animals will start to eat others without bothering to kill them; non-carnivorous birds will peck each other (not particularly quickly) to death, dolphins do gang rape for fun while having the ability to understand what it means, they also kill things like porpoises for fun (they can't eat porpoises and they're neither a threat nor competition to dolphins); predators in good conditions do "surplus kill" i.e. kill just for practice/fun without attempting to eat the victim, apes have been observed to eat parts of other apes while they're still alive, etc, etc.

The main difference between animals is that while less intelligent animals will sometimes simply kill things "just because" even if they don't need to and the suffering will be an accidental side effect, the more intelligent animals will sometimes intentionally hurt/torture others. Morality is orthogonal to intelligence. Romanticizing nature as something pure, "taking only what they need" and beyond evil is ridiculous idealism that doesn't reflect reality.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by chongli on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:54PM (#16402962)
Animals kill other animals to solve their hunger and they do their best to end it quickly.

Not always. Weasels and their relatives engage in surplus killing. Cats regularly play with their prey, clawing them and batting them around for fun, many times without even eating the dead prey animal.

Dolphins are known to devour a shark's liver and leave the rest of the animal to sink, dying a slow death.

Humans are animals. There's almost nothing we do that other predators don't. The difference is that we use technology as a force multiplier of overwhelming magnitude. There isn't much difference in kind, however.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by zer00eyz on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:07PM (#16403013)
> Dolphins are known to devour a shark's liver and leave the rest of the animal to sink, dying a slow death.

Killer whales will do this to other whales as well (well liver and tongue)

The caracas goes on to feed lots of other things however, and the cycle of life continues.

And then there is this: https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn18454-hippy-apes-caug...

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by jjeaff on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @01:26AM (#16418238)
Hardly. Again, watch some National Geographic. You will see plenty of animals struggling as they are devoured alive. We raise chickens for eggs. A few times, Opossums or racoons have gotten into the pen. They will kill every single chicken and eat maybe one or two at most. Sometimes, they will even chew off a hen's leg or both and leave it alive.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by white-flame on Sunday February 18, 2018 @01:28AM (#16404786)
Right, if we can kill it within 30 seconds, that eliminates a lot of unnecessary torture compared to a natural death. But then if 30 seconds is the new normal, then it becomes outrageous again, and killing it in 10 seconds is now eliminating unnecessary torture, right? But then that becomes the new norm and we shave another second off? Do we end up disputing the transmission of pulses down their nervous systems and interrupting them before they're perceived, just to prepare food that's already acceptable to eat?
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by watwut on Sunday February 18, 2018 @04:10AM (#16405138)
You talk about it as if it would be bad process. It is not. It is process that takes into account our natural need to eat, pleasure we have from eating and practicality of killing.

If civilization crushed and I would be suddenly living in the forest with family, I would kill the animal however I could - to eat. Probably painfully, because I know nothing else and probably am too exhausted to waste energy. I care more about me and kids not dying then about lobster pain.

On the other extreme, we have cheap pulses to kill them quick available, why not.

The same process happen with everything: legal systems, medicine and even child raising.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by maxxxxx on Saturday February 17, 2018 @08:16PM (#16403850)
"I do eat meat without thinking, and no I've never seen the inside of a slaughter house"

You should go. It may start you thinking.

Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by azernik on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:10PM (#16402713)
There are gradations of "dignity" - your formulation would demand vegetarianism, since all animals being killed for food are killed "unnaturally". Whereas I think there's a great deal more respect involved in reducing the animal's suffering (quick killing during a period of reduced stress).
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by api on Saturday February 17, 2018 @07:50PM (#16403758)
Being killed naturally would usually mean being slowly dismembered or crushed alive in some animal's jaws.
Re:In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster by paulcole on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:06PM (#16403010)
>I do eat meat without thinking

Congratulations? I’m not sure the point you’re making here.