News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:39AM (#16399917)
I'm just excited for the time when I can purchase a self-driving big rig and stick a living space in the back of it. Work remotely while traveling all over North America.

Maybe even all over Europe!

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by BoorishBears on Saturday February 17, 2018 @11:29AM (#16401348)
Let’s say you’re wealthy enough to do this. Why can’t you do it today?

I imagine self driving trucks will be priced with the cost savings over decades of driverless service in mind. Couldn’t you get a mega-RV and hire a team of human drivers, retrofit the RV with a collision avoidance system like OnGuard, and live in the RV?

I’m sure it’d be expensive, but I imagine the wealth needed to do either in of the same order of magnitude. right?

Sometimes people talk about how worried they are about human consumption and sustainability and sometimes people talk about sticking their office on a truck, taking to congested roads and generating metric tons of CO2 for a daily change of scenery. We sure are a varied crowd.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by jlebar on Saturday February 17, 2018 @11:42AM (#16401412)
> I imagine self driving trucks will be priced with the cost savings over decades of driverless service in mind.

That's certainly not what I would expect to happen in the long run in a competitive market.

For example -- in the early days of computing, I would believe you if you told me that computers had a high premium, reflecting the work savings computers offered. But these days computers are certainly not priced to reflect their cost savings. They're priced to reflect supply and demand.

Indeed, computers (or, say, cars) have become so ubiquitous that to talk about their marginal cost savings relative to the alternative is kind of meaningless. Imagine a world where self-driving cars are in the same category. I think it's coming, and soon.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by BoorishBears on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:49PM (#16403226)
What indication is there that they’re coming soon, or that commercial applications will be commoditized?

Commercial technology generally reflects cost savings to this day. Technology can run your assembly line at X units per day costs more if X is high, and even more if less people are involved in making X. It’s just technology got cheaper as a whole.

But I don’t think self-driving trucks will ever be that much cheaper since the computing power they use is on the same waning cost curve that brought us cheap computing today, and even if it does get exponentially cheap, the duty cycle of commercial applications will prevent savings from trickling down to commercial vehicles quickly (Just compare depreciation on normal cars vs big rigs).

All that being said, it’s intresting how quickly most people I see talk about this have gone from thinking about safety wins of self-driving cars to how much easier it will make driving. I think we’re headed for something ruinous if self-driving cars do come out and instead of solving the problem of excessive vehicles despite them, we all start thinking of fanciful new ways to constantly have more vehicles on the road.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by jlebar on Sunday February 18, 2018 @04:24AM (#16405175)
What indication is there that [self-driving cars are] coming soon

Not to be glib, but TFA?

or that commercial applications will be commoditized?

There are many companies working on specifically this. I find it hard to imagine an uncompetitive market, but you're right, that could happen.

Commercial technology generally reflects cost savings to this day.

I guess I sort of agree with you, but the question is "cost savings as compared to what?"

Tractors aren't priced according to cost savings compared to oxen. The most someone can charge is the cost savings of their device compared to the next best alternative. So tractors are priced relative to the value they add as compared to other tractors.

We should expect something similar in a competitive market for self-driving trucks.

But I don’t think self-driving trucks will ever be that much cheaper since the computing power they use is on the same waning cost curve that brought us cheap computing today

If self-driving cars are commercially feasible in this way, surely self-driving trucks are, since one truck carries a lot more stuff (economically speaking) than one car.

Also transistor counts are still going up, see GPUs. And this sort of thing is amenable to ASICs. And we can already pack sufficient compute into a van. And the computers aren't even the most expensive part -- "laser is the sauce".

and even if it does get exponentially cheap, the duty cycle of commercial applications will prevent savings from trickling down to commercial vehicles quickly (Just compare depreciation on normal cars vs big rigs).

I don't understand your point here, but note that one important way that self-driving trucks deliver value is by dramatically increasing the duty cycle of the vehicles.

All that being said, it’s intresting how quickly most people I see talk about this have gone from thinking about safety wins of self-driving cars to how much easier it will make driving. I think we’re headed for something ruinous if self-driving cars do come out and instead of solving the problem of excessive vehicles despite them, we all start thinking of fanciful new ways to constantly have more vehicles on the road.

Strong agree on this part.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Sunday February 18, 2018 @03:33PM (#16408342)
Tesla has already developed an electric semi that will probably be self-driving in the near future.

It's priced at under $200k. That's definitely cheaper than paying multiple people to drive me around 24/7.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by xbmcuser on Sunday February 18, 2018 @06:16AM (#16405518)
In the first your mobile home will need to support 1 person in the 2nd it will need to support multiple. Humans are not robots they also need to eat sleep go to the toilet
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by BoorishBears on Sunday February 18, 2018 @12:17PM (#16407020)
Again, I don’t think this changes the impracticality or waste by an order of magnitude.

It’s so impractical and so offensively wasteful, my analysis is really meant to be a tongue-in-cheek expression of the fact, but apparently we’re still seriously discusssing this...

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Sunday February 18, 2018 @02:48PM (#16407913)
Wait how is this offensively wasteful?

Also how is it impractical?

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by BoorishBears on Sunday February 18, 2018 @05:16PM (#16409116)
I saw in your other comments you mentioned that you had looked into a blimp to do this.

At this point I’m going to assume you’re either trolling or just severely out of touch with reality.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Monday February 19, 2018 @04:52AM (#16411867)
I'm out of touch with reality but you're deriving moral outrage from the use of blimps?

I'm very confused by your responses.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by Numberwang on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:44AM (#16399931)
Wow, never thought about it that way. That would be awesome.

Why limit it to US And Europe. The world might soon be a better place. Imagine Starting out in Berlin Then over a couple of months go to Turkey, then India, Vietnam and beyond and then back without ever driving a single km. Just let it drive while you sleep.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by thanksgiving on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:02AM (#16399983)
Is anyone even talking about let alone demoing self-driving in a seemingly chaotic urban driving in India and elsewhere? My uneducated guess is we are decades away from being able to navigate anything real world like this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pLUm3Q-7iZA

If you zoom out, you'll see that there's a method to the madness but a lone driving car that's not a part of a fleet doesn't have such luxuries.

I don't think the problem is solely image processing and machine learning. I just don't get self driving and how we're supposed to wow the logic. You have to be aggressive to drive in a city or people will constantly cut you off for hours. This means you will hold up traffic making the situation worse for everyone. However, you can't be too aggressive. Imagine the damage we will cause to the "optics" of self driving if we run over (at a slow 10 mph) stubborn people who cut us off. That will just look like murder.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by kjksf on Saturday February 17, 2018 @03:37PM (#16402563)
Based on economics, self-driving cars are not necessarily attractive in India.

Consider that in US the cheapest ZipCar is ~$8/hr.

Adding even the cheapest human driver working at minimum wage is ~$15/hr.

Adding a human driver in US makes the trip 3x more expensive.

Or to put it another way: a self-driving trip can be 3x less expensive.

Or to put it another way: a $30 trip from SF downtown to airport becomes $10 trip which is competitive with BART prices.

I don't know what is the minimum wage in India, but per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_in_India per capita income is $1670 / year which is probably less than $1 per hour.

In other words: self-driving cars only make economic sense in countries where humans are expensive.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by thanksgiving on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @06:52AM (#16428754)
> Or to put it another way: a $30 trip from SF downtown to airport becomes $10 trip which is competitive with BART prices.

I looked up BART because of what you said and it looks pretty bad.

https://github.com/enjalot/bart/blob/master/data/bart-comp-a...

175 people make six figures in base pay. The total cost of employment is ridiculously high. I don't know anything about BART but they clearly need to lay off a lot of people. This is ridiculous.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by cornholio on Saturday February 17, 2018 @06:15AM (#16400197)
Considering the route takes you through Iran and Pakistan, and a few 100s Km from Afghanistan, Indian trafic is the least of your worries. I'm considering driving the same trip but it seems a detour through Caucasus is a much safer choice.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by eeZah7Ux on Saturday February 17, 2018 @07:05AM (#16400338)
Having driven in similar "chaotic" traffic, it's not different that how we move on feet in a crowded area. This explains it better: https://highwayflocking.github.io/

A self driving car can have much better "perception" of the surrounding area and reaction times under 100ms, making it potentially very good at flocking safely.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by avip on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:34AM (#16400073)
The idea that a self-driving car would even make it to Turkey in the first place is laughable. Let's see how it goes in Italy or the Balkans first. But it's ok to dream...
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by ggggtez on Saturday February 17, 2018 @06:55AM (#16400304)
I don't think it can pump it's own gas lol.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by purple-again on Saturday February 17, 2018 @08:23AM (#16400558)
I have one less coffee than I had at the start of your post but it seems my mechanical keyboard survived so still worth!
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by moosekaka on Saturday February 17, 2018 @07:00AM (#16400322)
haphazard traffic flow due to lack of traffic safety awareness and road discipline by pedestrians and drivers alike are not exclusive to just India. we have a large Indian population in Malaysia and Singapore... go to their Little India enclaves and you see the same free for all situation... perhaps just a little better then shown in the video.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by majani on Saturday February 17, 2018 @11:03AM (#16401227)
there are many examples of countries that have been able to leapfrog certain steps in development. Case in point: most 3rd world countries skipped over desktop computing, straight into mobile. Maybe self driving cars will somehow take over the world exponentially like smartphones have, and developing countries skip over human policing of traffic into a majority self-drive reality.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by sharpercoder on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:05AM (#16399991)
It seems that the most "developed" areas in combination with predictable weather gets roll-out first. This means that non-western countries will get them later; or, depending on the situation, maybe never at all at 100% area coverage. I can totally imagine robotic car software parking right after a the highway intersection and subsequentially handing over driving to a human. Traffic in lesser developed countries may be too complex to ever have self driving cars to ride on.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by harikb on Saturday February 17, 2018 @10:17AM (#16401018)
I have always imagined the reverse. Countries with less enforced regulations (even if they have them) are the perfect environment to test these things.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by username223 on Saturday February 17, 2018 @07:35AM (#16400413)
Pretty much. I underestimated how quickly we would see robot cars that drive in straight lines on smooth, well-marked, first-world roads, but I suspect it will be awhile before they venture far out of that context. The developing world's city traffic, and rural roads everywhere, are a bit more complicated, and there's less money out there, so I doubt the robots will be there anytime soon.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by mtgx on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:36AM (#16400078)
And what does that tell us?

It tells us that Waymo is nowhere close to "Level 5" or even to the levels Google and the latest cherry-picked "tests" (where they don't count "disengagements" as a problem) would like you to believe it is at.

Level 5 is supposed to be virtually perfect self-driving in any environment or on any type of road, for which we haven't even properly tested in simulations yet, let alone in the real-world.

I said it before, because of marketing and an incentive to be misleading about their capabilities, "Level 5" will be the "4G" wireless of 2011 (and by that I mean "3G+", in case it wasn't clear). That's actually held true since "Level 2" self-driving. For every level carmakers have been patting themselves on the back for reaching, they're at least one level behind in the real-world. They quickly discover this, too, after trying out their "Level X" cars in the real-world for a while, but they "forget" to tell us about it, after making the big announcement previously, or it doesn't get as much attention in the media.

So, I guess I'll wait for Level 6 or Level 7, before I get into one of these. Level 7 will probably be Level 6 cars that actually can't get hacked, unlike all the cars progressing through the previous levels. Carmakers won't even care that much about security and will only prioritize getting to adequate self-driving capabilities first and will "deal with security later", because we all know it's so much easier to fix security issues and redesign architectures later.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by pnut on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:49AM (#16400117)
Meh... Insurance considerations practically guarantee you are statistically safer in one of these vs. a human operated vehicle, and that advantage will only multiply as the ratio of autonomous to human operated vehicles increases.

As a resident of a first-world country, it's not really my problem if India needs to wait a few decades or modernize their urban transport infrastructure to see the benefit of this technology. I haven't seen it in person, but the reputation is that Street-level activity in those environments is deadly and chaotic, regardless of whether you are a pedestrian, cyclist, or motorist.

Not exactly a situation worth preserving from anyone's perspective...

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by jacksmith21006 on Saturday February 17, 2018 @01:16PM (#16401860)
With ride sharing you can create a profitable business with level 4. The key is to get the revenue rolling to support the investment to get to level 5 some day down the road.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by achamayou on Saturday February 17, 2018 @07:24AM (#16400380)
Much like mileage, emissions, range etc. What’s advertised is what happened in the lab or on the test track.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by flexie on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:22AM (#16400037)
Would be awesome! I do fear that he political hurdles humanity would have to overcome for that route to be safe are larger than the technical ones, though.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by kaybe on Saturday February 17, 2018 @06:42AM (#16400280)
Maybe it would be a good idea to only allow this technology if it entirely powered by renewable energy.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Saturday February 17, 2018 @06:57AM (#16400313)
I mean, Tesla has already announced / demoed an electric semi-truck that will probably be able to drive itself pretty soon, so I don't think that's much of a worry.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by arbuge on Saturday February 17, 2018 @12:31PM (#16401657)
It will be even better once the Bering Strait is bridged (again).
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by make3 on Saturday February 17, 2018 @01:38PM (#16401982)
good luck going through all those places with different legislations on self driving cars without getting arrested a billion times, even twenty years from now, I'm sure
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by jbot29 on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:02AM (#16399979)
Invest in RV parks now.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by madengr on Saturday February 17, 2018 @09:43AM (#16400852)
Or not. You won’t need to park overnight and sleep. Sleep while on the road.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by foobarian on Saturday February 17, 2018 @10:46AM (#16401152)
I don't think many people know how expensive RVs are to drive. It is much cheaper to park for extended periods of time.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by ghaff on Saturday February 17, 2018 @11:52AM (#16401462)
Yeah, if the RV is driving itself, say, 10 hours a day that's 500 miles. Call it $2/mile to operate--cars today are about 50 cents on average--that's $1,000/day. Maybe that's a bit high, call it $500/day.

You can live as a digital nomad today easily for that kind of money and aren't limited to being on the road or parked at RV parks. I'm not sure I see the attraction of being isolated and on the road all the time even if something else is doing the actual driving.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by TulliusCicero on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:05AM (#16399989)
Once those exist why would the transport companies need you? Would probably make more sense for them to buy big fleets of self driving trucks to use at scale.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by azernik on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:10AM (#16400002)
I think the idea was to not do delivery runs, but just use the cargo capacity to lug around a mobile office. Finish work every day, and go outside to a different city.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Saturday February 17, 2018 @05:34AM (#16400075)
Exactly. I'm not really sure why my dream has always been a retrofitted big rig rather than an actual purpose-built mobile home, but there it is.

Either way, the self-driving aspect is the most important bit.

I also thought about doing this with a blimp, but the logistics are a lot harder with that route.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by CPLX on Saturday February 17, 2018 @08:42AM (#16400615)
A big rig is just a mobile home that doesn't have any windows.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Sunday February 18, 2018 @03:29PM (#16408316)
Yes and no. I guess I like the idea of the living space being separable from the vehicle. That way I could even try out different spaces by just swapping out the trailer. Could have a new living space built while I'm still using the old one.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by makewavesnotwar on Saturday February 17, 2018 @07:39PM (#16403712)
Why use a big rig? Why not an RV? Or a van conversion on something like a Sprinter? The entire premise you're proposing seems very wasteful and morally irresponsible if you care about stuff like global warming and believe in physics, but why try to optimize waste? Seems shortsighted.
Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by fastball on Sunday February 18, 2018 @03:27PM (#16408295)
Big rig for the same reason that I think repurposed cargo containers can be cool. They're not really that practical, but I just like the idea of repurposing things.

Also, you might be interested in electric cars, that might address your concerns about global warming. Don't worry, we'll have electric big rigs before we have fully autonomous ones. Tesla has already unveiled one, in fact. Not sure what a "belief in physics" [sic] has to do with anything either, but live your best life buddy.

Re:Waymo granted a permit to operate as a Transportation Net... by makewavesnotwar on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @03:32AM (#16418722)
Big rigs and repurposed cargo containers don't make sense as a comparison. All production costs of cargo containers are a sunk and they don't generate any waste on their own. Vehicles do. It's not just impractical - it's wasteful. Apples and oranges.

Electric cars are still massively wasteful. You could make ~250 e-bikes batteries with the same amount of lithium it takes to make one Tesla Model S battery. Then there's efficiency. In general - an e-bike goes around 100 miles per kWh where as a Tesla goes around 3-4 miles per kWh. So you're talking about massive waste in terms of material and energy efficiency. An electric bike is around 6300x more efficient than a Model S. Most of the time people are just using their big ass cars/trucks to haul their big asses - it's unnecessary. Telsa's powerwalls also use lithium. Cobalt supplies are heavily bottlenecked now and for the foreseeable future. Just because Musk wants to market his company as a solution to global warming doesn't make it at all true but I guess his advertising was effective on you.

You suggesting that somehow utilizing an entire electric big rig for yourself seems even more preposterous though. Tesla's electric big rig has a battery somewhere around 1200 kWh putting it at ~14 times more wasteful in terms of production resources than a Model S (assuming we're just talking about transporting <5 people). So you're essentially talking about offsetting 13 of your world saving cars or 3600 electric bikes worth of batteries just to haul yourself around at around 0.5 miles per kWh (putting your around 5-6 times less efficient than if you drove a Model X with a trailer).

To the belief in physics point - there is more to pollution than just the gasses created. There is also heat pollution. Most electricity in America still comes from coal. Even though you're not burning anything while you're running the vehicle doesn't mean the energy you're using isn't coming from something being burnt. While Tesla might also be working on stuff like Solar City - it doesn't change the fact that his solution is grid tied - meaning the infrastructure has to be built by existing power companies to deal with the load which they have no inherent incentive to do. Not to mention every ~21 hours or 1260 miles of driving you'd be using enough energy to power my 3 story house for a year.

Also - common sense check - what's the point of a road trip if you're going to try to be in the trailer the whole time? If you're going to skip all the scenery and stops anyway, you might as well fly. And have you tried doing a road trip in a big rig? They're not legal on a lot of roads and they're a major pain to find parking for unless you really enjoy camping at rest stops.

To your condescension - don't worry, I am, and have fun playing with your "Big Rig". You're probably right about electric cars magically fixing global warming. Enjoy your magic kingdom, pal.