I'm afraid public employee compensation reform probably loses on both counts.
Anyway, the whole point of representative democracy is to not have to consult the electorate for every little thing. Voting on pay is too nitpicky. The best alternative I can think of is that no one bargaining contract can run longer than 5 years, but that just swaps one set of problems for another.
When they look at their tax bills, reduced 401k benefits, layoffs and uncertain retirement dates, damn straight they will. http://blogs.forbes.com/digitalrules/2010/06/01/the-milliona... http://walnutcreek.patch.com/articles/walnut-creeks-100k-plu...
Approval rating seems ok:http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/blogs/beltway-conf...
Where we differ is in our belief over whether California voters would actually pass such an initiative at the polls. On past forms, I think campaign slogans would beat out economics or critical thinking. I do think ballot initiatives are a good thing in general, but as a state we have also passed some very foolish laws, whose long-term impact was not appreciated at the time. 'Three strikes' leading to life in prison is the most obvious example.
Defined contribution 403(b) and 401(k) programs have to have their deposits made soon after each year end. Defined benefit plans are more complicated, but there are big federal fines for companies that fail to deposit the increase in expected value of future payments each year. There are extensive (but imperfect) actuarial rules in the US Code to make the actual minimum contribution match the needs of the pension fund. Big funds need to buy insurance, too, in case things go wrong.
States and municipalities are immune from the federal standards. That's why they're ignoring the consequences and just promising to pay pensions without depositing enough money according to their own actuarial computations. A private company would have had to cut back on promises or pay the full current cost of future benefits.
Heck, even the Federal Government is keeping up with employee pension planning. The trouble is all in states and municipalities.
The states know they are doing this; actuarial science is not a mystery. But governors and legislators figure that public employee unions must be satisfied. And the problem won't explode until they're out of office and then it's someone else's problem.
And we voters who don't hold them responsible are ultimately at fault. Public employee unions couldn't hold politicians captive if we were willing to vote out pols who kowtow to irresponsible demands.