Re:Everything you know about Global Warming is wrong
by marknutter on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:02PM
(#1639177)
The models certainly do enter into it if you want to predict what the consequences will be of having higher CO2 concentrations. Knowing that we belch a lot of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere may tell us the cause, but not the effect. That has to be done with modeling or educated guesses.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Everything you know about Global Warming is wrong
by anthonyb on Saturday August 28, 2010 @05:55AM
(#1641541)
Most of yummyfajitas' post seemed to be name-calling; I was responding to this point:
> To draw conclusions like "the modern warming trend is anthropogenic in origin", we need to believe that our climate models are really good.
Which is entirely wrong. There are plenty of other sources of data which support that conclusion.
Re:Everything you know about Global Warming is wrong
by yummyfajitas on Saturday August 28, 2010 @10:30AM
(#1641771)
I'll ask you again: without using models, how do we know what the earth's temperature would have been without anthropogenic CO2?
Without knowing that, we can not draw any conclusions as to whether the modern warming trend is caused by human-emitted CO2 or not.
Incidentally, I devoted precisely one line of my post to name-calling, namely reversing a common ad-hominem levied against skeptics of climate modelling.
Re:Everything you know about Global Warming is wrong
by anthonyb on Sunday August 29, 2010 @06:06AM
(#1643555)
Increased CO2 is the only reasonable forcing so far; water vapour, methane, etc. have too short a half life in the atmosphere. The bulk of the CO2 increase is anthropogenic in origin, ergo the warming is caused by humans - no models necessary.