News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by ansible on Thursday February 15, 2018 @09:32AM (#16384226)
Computing in automotive is a challenge.

In the past, you might have automotive-grade microcontrollers for functions like ABS, which consume less than a Watt maximum. You paid a little attention to having enough ground vias on the PCB for thermal conductivity, and that was about it to qualify the design for the high end of the temperature range.

Degraded lifetime wasn't so much of a concern.

These days, you've got ARM processors with a TDP of 15W or more, and keeping the die temperatures below the maximum when the ambient temperature is 85C, well, that starts to get interesting. Especially if you don't want to use a fan, and the processor is stuck somewhere without adequate airflow.

And then you've got high-end systems with a TDP in the 150W range. Then you've got to have a good cooling solution to run your application at office environment temperatures, nevermind the full automotive temperature range. And what's going to be the lifetime for these parts running at elevated temperatures, even if you are staying within the maximum temperature limits? Sigh

Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by sixdimensional on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:47AM (#16385454)
It's even worse in avionics.

The turn to commercial off the shelf (COTS) parts to cut costs has raised the cost of using specialized ones (or caused people to have to develop custom solutions at great cost due to market gaps).

High temperature tested CPUs (above consumer grade) is a good example.

IOT causing more and more embedded technology might help change that tide, due to the need for components that can handle extreme and longer term deployments. But, the last so many years of the push to cut costs through COTS has come at a big cost for sustainability.

Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by Retric on Thursday February 15, 2018 @10:15AM (#16384635)
15W chips use ~2% of a HP each, and 150W = 1/5 horsepower worth of parasitic load. So using several high end chips should result in significantly worse fuel efficiency.

Are they really necessary or just cheaper in R&D terms?

Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by simias on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:02AM (#16385032)
Modern cars have tons of advanced features that require a decent amount of computing. I mean just look at the evolution from radio cassette players to modern integrated GPS/media player/bluetooth/etc systems. Also things like automatic parking assist, rear view camera, computer vision algorithms to detect if the driver is falling asleep. It's feature creep all over the place.
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by oblio on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:29AM (#16385273)
> Also things like automatic parking assist, rear view camera, computer vision algorithms to detect if the driver is falling asleep. It's feature creep all over the place.

You have a weird definition of "feature creep". Some of those things you listed save money, others save lives. I definitely wouldn't include such things in "feature creep".

Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by simias on Thursday February 15, 2018 @12:13PM (#16385677)
Sorry, it might not have been the right word. I didn't mean that these features weren't useful, only that in the past decades the past decades the amount of software in cars really exploded from basically 0 to having a bunch of fully featured computers dealing with various subsystems, from fuel injection to radio playback. Software "creeped" everywhere.
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by nimos on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:57AM (#16385553)
Optimised acceleration/deceleration would probably save more fuel than self driving hardware uses, for city driving at least.

At 60mph you'll be using 10-20hp to maintain speed so about a 1-2% loss per 150W chip(well a bit more for conversion losses).

Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by bluGill on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:04AM (#16385050)
Going by your numbers and my best guess, I think the processing of self driving cars needs 1/4 hp. The first few generations will need more than that. (you can get by on less if you are willing to sacrifice safety)
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by madez on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:07AM (#16385081)
Can you break down your guess?
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by bluGill on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:31AM (#16385293)
It takes a lot of processing to detect "objects" and figure out which are of interest. Give me a data structure of objects; with their meaning (a place that can hold the car without getting stuck) and their possible future behaviors (where it can actually get to given the laws of physics and reasonable assumptions) and a self driving car is easy. Getting that list is hard, and frankly beyond my knowledge.

Mostly I'm taking how much energy humans use, and we do a bad job...

Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by carlmr on Thursday February 15, 2018 @09:43AM (#16384328)
Automotive chips under the hood have to be rated up to 125°C environmental temperature. 150°C in some locations.
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by falcolas on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:22AM (#16385203)
There's the flip side of that too: they can be "stored" in environments which are occasionally in excess of -40°C, and have to function properly then as well (and be subsequently heated back up to above 100°).
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by ansible on Thursday February 15, 2018 @09:56AM (#16384457)
Yep. The junction temperature is rated up to that. What I'm saying is that even so, thermal design is a challenge. And I have concerns about chip lifetime under those sorts of conditions.
Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by roymurdock on Thursday February 15, 2018 @10:28AM (#16384758)
As more critical functionality in cars comes to be controlled by MCU/CPUs and software over ECUs and mechanical components, I wonder if software obsolescence will have a larger impact than potential chip failure from increased use.

It's not hard to imagine a future where Tesla stops developing and pushing updates for cars after 5-10 years, basically forcing an owner to trade up as the hardware in older models becomes incompatible with the latest self-driving algos. It's also not hard to imagine a future where Amazon/Uber/Bigco own and update large fleets of vehicles, maintaining and renting them out much like AWS does compute cycles, taking the burden off the user to maintain their own hardware.

Re:Chip Aging Accelerates by Slansitartop on Thursday February 15, 2018 @11:18AM (#16385169)
> As more critical functionality in cars comes to be controlled by MCU/CPUs and software over ECUs and mechanical components, I wonder if software obsolescence will have a larger impact than potential chip failure from increased use.

I don't really see that. Once the software's out there and works, it'll work even if it isn't updated with the latest feature set. I can't really imagine the government changing self-driving car standards so fast that a non-updated car could not operate safely and would have to be retired.

Any broken "cloud server dependence" would probably cause so much weeping and gnashing of teeth that Tesla would be foolish to try it, and again, I doubt the government would allow it for safety reasons.