News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by Retric on Thursday August 26, 2010 @04:49PM (#1637123)
Modeling is at best a thought experiment. It can only show you if a theory is reasonably self consistent based on your assumptions not if it's actually true.

PS: There are limits on science, and the ability to conduct an actual meaningful exponent is one of the largest ones.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by jshen on Thursday August 26, 2010 @05:39PM (#1637241)
I think there's more to it than that. For example, a model can tell you if something isn't true which is very significant. It can also make predictions that can then be tested.

These two alone are much more than a mere thought experiment.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by ynniv on Thursday August 26, 2010 @06:01PM (#1637279)
Great news! My model tells me that humans no longer have to breathe!
Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by brg on Thursday August 26, 2010 @08:01PM (#1637585)
I am having a hard time seeing the different.

A thought experiment can tell you that if A then B. A model is a means of producing a prediction B from A by means of long, complicated calculations instead of simple logical inferences. In both cases the conclusions should be evaluated before accepted as physical truth.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by jshen on Thursday August 26, 2010 @08:25PM (#1637639)
what do you believe is the different between a theory and a thought experiment?
Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by brg on Thursday August 26, 2010 @10:47PM (#1637874)
I would say a theory is a hypothesis which has been tested. A thought experiment can be part of hypothesis creation.
Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by jshen on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:06AM (#1637966)
and a model can very easily be a hypothesis which can be tested. I.e. it's far more like a theory than a thought experiment.
Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by brg on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:44AM (#1638017)
Perhaps we're splitting hairs. But this doesn't sit right with me.

Consider what is meant by a thought experiment in popular literature. Take Einstein's elevator. Would you call that "Einstein's elevator theory?" Or is that a prediction based on the theory of equivalence?

Maybe in this vein a clear distinction is that a thought experiment is a proof discovery technique. It is working with heuristics and intuition. At the end there is something; a statement or prediction that seems right. But no matter how much intuition confirms it, in the physical sciences it needs to be tested and in the mathematical sciences it needs a formal proof. Beyond that, it is just another hypothesis. After that it leads to a theory.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by Confusion on Friday August 27, 2010 @03:49AM (#1638253)
With all due respect, but you're both not just splitting hairs: you're splitting hairs about something you don't know enough about. There's a whole body of literature on the subject and you're not going to reinvent all of that in the course of this small discussion. If neither of you have heard of, for instance, Carl Hempel, then this discussion is completely pointless.

If you don't standardize your terminology first, then you're just discussing the boundaries of your personal definitions, instead of embarking on actual intellectual discovery of the terrain.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by brg on Friday August 27, 2010 @05:50PM (#1640404)
This discussion is an 'intellectual discovery' for its participants. Its unfortunate you wish to hinder that through dismissive remarks instead of constructively participating.
Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by Confusion on Saturday August 28, 2010 @06:27AM (#1641562)
When I was 12, I once had a night-long discussion with a friend about the implications of faster-than-light travel. Once I learned some actual physics, I realized none of that discussion made any sense at all.

Something isn't intellectual discovery just because information is exchanged and both people feel they are learning stuff. Intellectual discovery makes sense if you are trying to structure the knowledge and are connecting it to knowledge you already have. Without things to connect it to, such as a shared definition of 'theory', you end up running around in circles.

It's like being dropped into a maze and not trying to solve it, but just running around in it. It may be fun, and you won't hear me complain, but as soon as someone starts wondering whether they are going too much into the details of solving it ("maybe I'm splitting hairs"), I feel obliged to point out they haven't really started to solve it. They've just been randomly discovering the territory, not noticing whether they returned to the same point several times.

I'm not trying to be disparaging; I'm just pointing out that talk of 'splitting hairs' is really premature.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by jshen on Sunday August 29, 2010 @11:42AM (#1643944)
I often find it highly useful to flesh out terrain in my own mind before exploring the literature. You're remarks were extremely condescending and you could have made the same point without the poor tone.

Oddly, you nearly admit the usefulness of it. "They've just been randomly discovering the territory". Discovering territory is valuable, whether it's random or not!

But the oddest thing is that you don't provide any useful information. You don't link to a page with the info you think we should read, or to a book on the matter, or a paper. Nothing, but condescension.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by Confusion on Monday August 30, 2010 @05:05AM (#1645729)
I'm sorry, it was not my intention to be condescending; merely to be critical. Searching for 'philosophy of science' should provide plenty of resources; which ones suit you is impossible for me to guess, because it strongly depends on background/prior knowledge, which is why I refrained from advising anything specific.

As a starting point, http://www.teach12.com/ttcx/CourseDescLong2.aspx?cid=4100 may be a pretty decent introduction. There are torrents floating around if you want a taste.

Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by jshen on Thursday September 02, 2010 @12:57AM (#1655341)
The link looks interesting, but does it talk specifically about models and their relation to theories which is what we were discussing that you found to be a waste of time
Re:Science Only Has Two Legs by jacobolus on Thursday August 26, 2010 @06:01PM (#1637280)