News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by rusbus on Sunday February 11, 2018 @02:51PM (#16354384)
This is awesome. Clojure has had similar frameworks for a while, but Clojure has a fairly steep learning curve. Really excited to try this in Scala. Wonder if this will be a new trend away from the totally separate webapp + rest API model...
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by vijaykiran on Sunday February 11, 2018 @03:58PM (#16354755)
From my non-substantial experience in Clojure and Scala, I'd say that Clojure is simpler and faster to learn and get productive quickly than Scala. Scala has lot more syntax and concepts that you need to grok compared to simplicity of Clojure.

I'm curious why you say Clojure has a steep learning curve.

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by threeseed on Sunday February 11, 2018 @04:27PM (#16354914)
Clojure has a steep learning curve because it's purely functional.

Most programmers grow up with learning OOP and so throwing all of that out and asking you brain to do everything in reverse is challenging. I know having worked with a dozen J2EE developers in their transition to Clojure. It took at least 3 months to just be productive.

Scala for many people is just Java with a sprinkling of functional and they never really bother to learn the internals or the more complex areas like generic programming e.g. Shapeless/Cats.

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by jrs95 on Monday February 12, 2018 @01:36AM (#16356962)
IMO it's just the syntax that comes across as really bizarre. Scala is much more complex than Clojure aside from the initial hurdle of getting used to that syntax.

Personally I think it's less about FP vs OOP -- even if the OO parts of Scala are familiar, you're going to encounter FP code in Scala, and in general there is a lot more to learn with Scala as a language just to be able to read other people's code effectively.

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by alextheparrot on Sunday February 11, 2018 @03:04PM (#16354456)
I use Scala daily and have never used Clojure - what creates the steep learning curve? Scala also has a lot of features between “Beginner” and “Advanced” which can really add to the learning curve (Implicits being a good example).
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by dominotw on Sunday February 11, 2018 @03:10PM (#16354495)
Oh man I had the misfortune of starting scala with a framework( akka http) that used magnet pattern. Turned me off from scala forever till I rediscovered it again.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by threeseed on Sunday February 11, 2018 @04:29PM (#16354931)
I am very much in the minority but I can't stand most of Akka.

It's overly engineered with too much clever magic and hence is very reminiscent of frameworks like J2EE Spring which is why people left Java to begin with.

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by briankelly on Sunday February 11, 2018 @03:09PM (#16354486)
I haven't tried Clojure yet, but compared to Common Lisp, Scala let's you ease into the advanced features but lisps demand an immediate shift in thinking. You can basically write Java with Scala without much friction.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by alextheparrot on Sunday February 11, 2018 @05:34PM (#16355217)
It lets you ease into it insofar as you don’t use libraries that heavily rely on more advanced features. Trying to understand how Circe is actually serialiazing your case classes (Or why it is failing) can be quite difficult without understanding Shapeless.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by threeseed on Sunday February 11, 2018 @05:38PM (#16355233)
It took me weeks to get Circe working on my project.

But this compiler plugin makes it infinitely easier: https://github.com/tek/splain

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by alextheparrot on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:02PM (#16355546)
Wow going to plug this into a project and try it out tonight, might be worth adding as a default plugin to projects - looks good on the surface.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by briankelly on Monday February 12, 2018 @02:50PM (#16361451)
Fair enough but I still think avoiding those libraries is very doable. Personally I used play-json without the rest of the play framework and it is robust and easy to grok.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by dustingetz on Sunday February 11, 2018 @05:54PM (#16355317)
Clojure has the easiest learning curve I've ever experienced, it took 3 days to bring my co-founder (a Scala dev) up to speed. I am also a former scala dev, I flatMapped that shit, etc. That Scala coolaid tasted far better going down as a starry eyed 20-something than it did on the way back up ... Scala's own source code is incomprehensible, let alone the emergent monstrosities built by well meaning humans that aren't in the top 1000 scala experts on the planet... Scala, fundamentally, simply doesn't make any sense at all, it was a bad idea, you can't fuse OOP and FP without violent and polarized flamewars and fracturing the community into incompatible sects. The experiment failed.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by dsabanin on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:08PM (#16355567)
I think what has failed is in fact Clojure's experiment of doing FP without a type system, now that they have to bolt it on with runtime type checking.

OOP + FP is actually doing quite well, look at Swift, ReasonML (essentially OCaml, which is also doing fine by itself).

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by grzm on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:12PM (#16355583)
> "now that they have to bolt it on with runtime type checking."

I think that's definitely in the eye of the beholder. The overwhelming opinion I've heard from those in the community is that they greatly prefer having the option, but wouldn't want it required. And that's exactly what spec provides. The language isn't perfect (and honestly, what language is, for every purpose?) but calling it a failure is quite hyperbolic.

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by virtualwhys on Sunday February 11, 2018 @07:32PM (#16355663)
> but calling it a failure is quite hyperbolic.

as is claiming that Scala is a failure. If adoption and widespread use across industries (big data, hardware, server, web, etc.) is any indicator of success, Scala is just that.

The reality is that both languages are excellent; if you work in either for the day job you're fortunate -- there are far worse languages out there.

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by grzm on Sunday February 11, 2018 @08:48PM (#16355975)
> "as is claiming that Scala is a failure."

Agreed, and I admit I didn't see this as a response to 'dustingetz' equally hyperbolic criticism of Scala. Answering hyperbole with more hyperbole is rarely a way forward for constructive discussion.

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by dustingetz on Monday February 12, 2018 @08:36AM (#16358443)
Scala's purpose as stated by Odersky is a research experiment in fusing OOP and FP. That experiment has clearly (to me at least) failed. Everyone who gets to be any good at Scala eventually migrates to Haskell or Clojure, because both hit the high notes of functional programming with a vastly simpler model and better outcomes. Scala is a great gateway drug to FP because it is easy for enterprise Java developers to hit the ground running, but java devs don't write good scala code so we start to see the ecosystem fracture into sects, like C++ and we all know how that turned out.
Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by virtualwhys on Monday February 12, 2018 @09:33AM (#16358765)
> Scala's purpose as stated by Odersky is a research experiment in fusing OOP and FP.

It's odd that across so many industries companies would adopt an experimental language; it's almost as if Scala was a stable, production ready language, a successful one even, and that some people have opinions, well founded or not.

> Everyone who gets to be any good at Scala eventually migrates to Haskell or Clojure

The number of Scala developers migrating to Haskell far exceeds that of those migrating to Clojure, probably by a factor of 100X.

> like C++ and we all know how that turned out.

a resounding success? "There are only two kinds of languages: the ones people complain about and the ones nobody uses." Which of the FP languages at hand do people complain about?[1]

[1] https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=%2Fm%2F091hdj,%2F...

Re:Udash – Scala and Scala.js Reactive Web Framework by justinhj on Sunday February 11, 2018 @10:47PM (#16356380)
Failed how? Seems to be thriving for many use cases. I’m a fan lisps and Clojure especially but it didn’t scale to large teams and problems the way Scala does