The googlefaces hire all sorts of behavioural scientists, paychologists, statisticians to get people more addicted to their ecosystem, spend millions on lobbying to bend the laws and generally do whatever they want.
People caring about this topic waste their time explaining for the millionth time why surveillance is bad to every innocent soul who bent their mind into a pretzel coming up with excuses for surveillance and spyware.
1) Ban surveillance. Not going to happen, if what you just stated is to be believed.
2) Complain about it.
3) Try to enact means to punish abusers.
Maybe that's because you don't actually SEE the surveillance.
Surely you close the door when you try on clothes at a mall, or when you use a toilet?
You're making claims that because we interact on the web we should not expect any safety. That's fine... but what about those of us who specifically don't use Google, Facebook, etc... we are STILL surveilled, constantly. The US Gov't is STILL trying to break encryption (for everybody) in order to surveil more completely.
Privacy is forfeit by participation in these types of forums (centrally administered), but not all forums are like these.
As distributed networks continue to develop, the arguments you've used to advocate a carelessness about your post-privacy lifestyle will no longer be valid. But the state apparatus and oppressive outcomes that type of intellectual laziness enables/encourages will persist.
I don't think we'll be able to stop the surveillance state, but we should push for the right legal and judicial culture.
There is no Rule of Law.
But you may be right about trying to stop the surveillance monster... perhaps if you don't mind it we can put the cameras in your bedroom first.
And then you call me complacent for not wanting fight against surveillance.
So, do you believe that political fights are worth it or not? Make up your mind and stop bringing bedroom stuff into the discussion.
I do not. They are a sideshow. Our systems have already been coopted by powerful, monied interests with armed guards.
Recent 702 vote made it perfectly fucking clear who's in charge (if it wasn't already clear from "this is how we know we're a family") and whose opinion matters.
It wouldn't be very nice of me to assume you're ignorant (and I don't, tbh), but I do find it frustrating that people feel there is room for returning to an imagined better place, where authority wasn't corrupt. In history, it seems to me, the news wasn't as thorough and the well-connected just as oppressive.
Sorry, not down with your logic one bit.
Take the long view. I guarantee that the people collecting the data do.
I mean honestly:
- Use Android? Chances are you're being watched by Google.
- Facebook tracks literally hundreds of millions.
- Post on HN? Guess what, you can't delete your posts after a while. Advances in stylometry in addition to more and more data being on the internet will mean your identity on here will be compromised eventually.
---
However, using Android allows Google to have literally minute-by-minute traffic updates which allows our cars to move more efficiently.
Facebook's tracking of millions may aid in allowing smaller organizations to connect in a more programmatic way.
HN well, obviously is allowing you to read this now.
Things like privacy were forfeit the minute we gained the technology. If people have problems with these technologies being used in bad ways, we should punish the people using the technologies in such a bad way. The spooky "surveillance state" is a red herring imo.