On the other hand
Tobacco companies for years lied about the risks and promoted false science
Energy companies regularly fund climate change denial organizations (see Heartland Institute)
Monsanto sends detectives after farmers who get tangled with them (https://www.organicconsumers.org/old_articles/Monsanto/farme...)
Tyson, Purdue regularly keep chicken farmers in poverty and silenced about chicken farming conditions.
Volkswagen created emission cheating software to hide their emissions...
Again, tech companies aren't great and control a lot of information, but what about the food we eat and the air we breathe?
>Tobacco companies for years lied about the risks and promoted false science
And were punished severely, rightly so. They paid out billions.
>Energy companies regularly fund climate change denial organizations (see Heartland Institute)
This is difficult to solve within the existing legal infrastructure and might require a constitutional amendment
>Monsanto sends detectives after farmers who get tangled with them (https://www.organicconsumers.org/old_articles/Monsanto/farme...)
I'm not sure that should be illegal - they sued the farmers and lawyers use investigators.
>Tyson, Purdue regularly keep chicken farmers in poverty and silenced about chicken farming conditions.
This should be more regulated and there are serious calls to do so.
>Volkswagen created emission cheating software to hide their emissions...
And are now paying billions for it.
It's a sad fact of the national attention span, but still likely a fact.
BUT Facebook already changed their news feed algorithm and many tech companies are making changes
I can't rid myself of the impression that such changes are only applied to avoid the hammer coming down.For example : Facebook gave exactly zero fucks about harrassing - or hate posts in specific markets despite the fact that such posts were illegal in such markets. Only when Germany started to crack down severely you saw change.
Same with other tech companies. Uber and Airbnb don't only not give a shit they actively flout the law and you only see changes in their behavior when the hammer of the law threatened to come crashing down.
While I agree with your examples that doesn't mean that we should give tech companies a pass. Rotten (and potentially illegal) behavior is hurting us all for the benefits of very, very few.
I'm glad, that Europe is at least trying to put a stop at the most egregious behavior. The US seems more inclined to give a pass even when borderline crimninal behavior is involved. (Equifax?)
Also, I would say the flow if information is a more pressing priority, because its vital to solving those other problems as well. Imagine a future Facebook that takes a payoff from Monsanto to opaquely bury all criticism of it.
> BUT Facebook already changed their news feed algorithm and many tech companies are making changes. Not saying they're doing it perfectly or even well, but still.
Facebook's algorithm tweaks don't solve the problem of its market position and dominance.
- Major merger approvals tie up DC for months at a time. - The SEC is perpetually unable to keep up with Wall Streets’ shenanigans - Major procurement programs like the F35 dominate the military’s buying capacity
Etc etc
Not to mention, it's not like the government can't do both at once. Most of those industries you mentioned have other departments that regulate them.
Was what he did stupid? Oh absolutely. Maybe he needed to be taught a lesson .. but now his entire channel with hundreds of thousands of subscribers is gone, and so is the ad revenue .. and all the videos/content.
Because of the dependence on that platform, Google can kill anything they deem unworthy. You could say, "Well so could television companies, or Netflix/Amazon Video," but you typically enter in a contract with those companies, and there's some degree of oversight on the content. Here people are giving YouTube their content, and then monetizing it only if/after they get popular.
First he's not "a kid", looks more like 18 - 22. So old enough to know better.
Second there's something of an epidemic of acid attacks in London recently. So scare the shit out of random strangers for clicks n giggles.
He should try his "humour" in an airport or on a copper - I'm sure he'd get plenty of extra views.
Do you believe that the government would be more or less ok with allowing controversial content like that? I suspect that government regulation would make this problem worse, not better.
> Do you believe that the government would be more or less ok with allowing controversial content like that? I suspect that government regulation would make this problem worse, not better.
In the US, the government would absolutely be OK with it. Protection of speech from government interference is one of the most fundamental and sacred cornerstones of US law.
Acid attacks are extremely, extremely horrible and damaging.
Isn't that precrime?
I think CNN, NBC ("beauty of our weapons") and Fox news control a bigger fraction, but nobody's clamoring for them to be regulated. I wonder why it's just the upstarts being targeted.
They seem to take the privacy of their users far more seriously than other competitors as well as the government (US - net neutrality).
For Google:
If your site gets incorrectly fucked over by one of Google's ranking algorithm changes, try to find someone to talk to who cares enough to try to fix the issue.
Ditto if your Gmail account gets wrongly flagged and closed for some reason. There's no one for you to call and you're fucked, unless you happen know someone inside Google.
Neither of these have happened to me personally, but I've followed cases of each pretty closely.
For Facebook:
It's recent newsfeed changes have had a huge detrimental impact on legitimate news organizations, even more in some foreign markets than int the US. See how much Facebook cares.
> What exactly do you hope to achieve by regulating them?
The standard stuff, like elimination of unfair competition (e.g. Google using Search to push its other stuff). I'd also like to see some breakups/forced divestitures to increase overall competition.
In Facebook's case, specifically: I'd like to see Instagram and Whatsapp spun off; and the core Facebook social network decentralized into several independent instances, with mandates to conform to open interoperability standards. Those standards should include a mandatory privacy permissioning system, to control how personal data is used across instance boundaries.
Capitalism isn't the only idea by which we run our society, nor is the market society's only priority.
Also, we have experience with the pernicious effects of too much market dominance, which is why we developed antitrust law.
They might, but is "innovation" something that should be enforced by law? Do companies have a right to expect equal access to a market regardless of the successes or advantages of their competitors?
Yes. Two of them (Google and Facebook) basically control a huge fraction of the information people are exposed to on a daily basis, either directly on indirectly. They're so dominant and aloof, that they can make or break businesses without even realizing it or caring. Their control over information flow also has important civil society implications.
Amazon could conceivably control most American retail activity in the future, though it has a few retail titans that could conceivably stand up to it if they get their acts together [1]. At best, we seem to be headed towards a retail oligopoly.
Personally, I'm much less worried about Apple, its control is much less pervasive. Though I wish there were more alternatives to it other than Android.
[1] https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2016/01/01/amazon-is-...