News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by llccbb on Thursday February 08, 2018 @11:10AM (#16333091)
Nice enough design work. But as someone who works in the climate data space I think there isn't much value add here. CO2 data is already free and open and not challenging to use. It seems like a half-wasted use of electricity and contributors time to just show data and not have any call to action or resources for how to do something about the problem. From the branding and social media integration I am guessing there isn't any deep interest in actually _doing something_ about carbon emissions. It feels like the villager who is screaming about a house on fire instead of joining in the bucket line.

Something like ClimateWatch[0] is actually building a strong platform for aggregating disparate data sources around climate change, GHG emissions, climate resilience practices, and multinational legislation. Granted ClimateWatch isn't built by an online community of volunteers, but maybe it is something to look at for further inspiration.

[0]https://www.climatewatchdata.org/

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by andy_ppp on Thursday February 08, 2018 @12:24PM (#16333778)
What are the things people can actually do - realistically the only way to fix this is a carbon tax that includes the environmental costs of burning carbon. Becoming vegetarian on an individual level will basically be a drop in the ocean, there are not enough people going to change.

See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKCuDxpccYM

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by Accipitriform on Thursday February 08, 2018 @02:29PM (#16334841)
Actually one of the only realistic things you can do is advocate a large scale rollout of nuclear power to replace coal, primarily in the US, China and India.

I'm not advocating dinosaur approaches like the AP-1000, but instead new, innovative designs like that championed by ThorCon Power.

http://thorconpower.com/thorcons-green-nuclear-power-gains-m...

"A comparison of all offered sources of nuclear found ThorCon’s power to be 4 to 5 cents per kWh lower than the competition and the only clean source of non-intermittent power that was competitive with coal."

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by greglindahl on Thursday February 08, 2018 @04:34PM (#16335776)
What's realistic about calling for a large-scale rollout of something which has never been built, in an industry where cost-overruns are typical? Shouldn't you build at least one before betting the farm on it?

Meanwhile, coal is already on the way out in the US, replaced by... unrealistic? ... power sources.

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by Accipitriform on Tuesday February 13, 2018 @01:15PM (#16369336)
"What's realistic about calling for a large-scale rollout of something which has never been built, in an industry where cost-overruns are typical? Shouldn't you build at least one before betting the farm on it?"

(Sorry for the delay in responding, busy times...)

If you read the ThorCon material, you'll find that there's nothing controversial about its design. It's all based on the solid ORNL molten salt work. ThorCon is in the process of building a first reactor, which will likely be in Indonesia due to the broken nuclear approach in the US.

"Meanwhile, coal is already on the way out in the US, replaced by... unrealistic? ... power sources."

Most of the true replacement (reliable) power is natural gas, which still produces very significant CO2. Wind and solar will never really be effective replacements without reliable backup power, even with grid storage. The problem is there will eventually be an outlier event where there is too much calm air, and too much overcast, to supply enough electricity. At that point lots of people will die, if it's very hot or very cold. Reliable power is very important.

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by titojankowski on Thursday February 08, 2018 @12:30PM (#16333843)
ACTION: Here’s 70+ startups that see carbon dioxide as a profit opportunity: http://airminers.org

Climate change will create the first trillionaire.

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by andy_ppp on Thursday February 08, 2018 @12:38PM (#16333905)
Great idea. Will apply.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by safiume on Thursday February 08, 2018 @01:07PM (#16334147)
Yes! The situation is dire enough that we need all hands on deck pushing forward on all solutions. The creators of AirMiners.org talk about active solutions here https://goo.gl/oUFg9c. An active project seeking STEM experts: Open NanoCarbon, an open science effort to solidify all the anthropogenic carbon. It's listed on the Air Miners and in the video, and is having a 2/15 meetup at Google SF: https://goo.gl/kbhuUk
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by safiume on Thursday February 08, 2018 @02:52PM (#16335042)
Later on, we'll need makers, hacker and coders to help build hardware with high recycled solid carbon content, i.e: glasses, metals, plastics, electronics, etc.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by llccbb on Thursday February 08, 2018 @03:38PM (#16335389)
You are entirely right that almost any change you make on an individual level will not stack up enough to transform the world to carbon neutral or carbon negative. Actions must be collective.

Help your neighborhood, city, state, build and implement a climate resiliency plan. Support and foster societal practices that are less carbon intensive (more bike stands and less parking spots; support public transporation;). Act within your network to promote more sustainable behavior. Does your work have a carpool system? Does your work __or the business you own__ provide incentives to their employees to ride bikes? Does your work recycle? Do you work in an energy efficient building? Is your house/apartment energy efficient? The "Green" trend should never stop. Optimization and efficiency are key.

Monetarily, divest your wealth from high carbon enterprises. Spread this suggestion and work with your employer to provide investment funds that are low carbon. Don't work in an carbon-heavy field. Work to actively solve the problem. Don't buy that Tesla. Don't own a car if it isn't a necessity. Tell other people about your wonderful car free life. Save money on insurance, gas, oil, tires, brakes....

You don't have to go to a completely plant-based diet. Host a party once a month and only serve vegetarian. That converts N hypothetical meat-containing meals into plant-based meals. Maybe someone likes your tofu dish and starts making it every other week for themselves.

A top-down carbon tax is a very logical economic mover, but it is only one tool in the tool belt. Recarbonization of the biosphere (plants, forest) is a necessity to have any chance of going carbon neutral or negative. Also climate change will not be stopping. We __are__ going to be in a different world and people will be in different places than today. The actions taken now will still mean everything to 10+ billion people.

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by amelius on Thursday February 08, 2018 @01:06PM (#16334140)
We need a personal carbon profile. E.g. this means that when you buy meat, etc. it is added to your personal carbon balance. Of course, it will require a complete overhaul of payment systems, but eventually this can lead to more awareness and hence a reduction of emissions.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by Brakenshire on Thursday February 08, 2018 @01:15PM (#16334221)
A carbon tax at source (presumably, at a wholesale level) for electricity, natural gas, diesel, petrol etc would capture most of that, with a lot less effort.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by amelius on Thursday February 08, 2018 @05:47PM (#16336270)
That would certainly help, but paying != solving, unfortunately, unless you charge for storing CO2, which is rather expensive.
[dead]
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by rvo on Thursday February 08, 2018 @03:15PM (#16335215)
Sorry to do this but could you stop spamming the comments with these updates and stuff?
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by titojankowski on Thursday February 08, 2018 @01:32PM (#16334359)
8,000 POUNDS OF CARBON DIOXIDE REMOVED PROOF: https://www.dropbox.com/s/jyp5xctoqyr4asj/hacker%20news%20ca...
[dead]
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by semi-extrinsic on Thursday February 08, 2018 @01:14PM (#16334216)
About the same as if you got 7000 people to substitute a 1 mile car drive with walking, once.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by jamroom on Thursday February 08, 2018 @01:37PM (#16334405)
I can't believe that a car dumps a pound of CO2 every mile..
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by detaro on Thursday February 08, 2018 @02:29PM (#16334844)
If my numbers are right, that would be a car that does 20 miles per gallon.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by semi-extrinsic on Thursday February 08, 2018 @03:51PM (#16335490)
The EPA says [1]

> The average passenger vehicle emits about 411 grams of CO2 per mile

Now that's only tailpipe emissions, so once you include the emissions from producing the gasoline/diesel, it's more than a pound per mile.

[1] https://www.epa.gov/greenvehicles/greenhouse-gas-emissions-t...

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by detaro on Thursday February 08, 2018 @05:09PM (#16336044)
And they mention 21.6 mpg as an assumed average, so that seems to match up.
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by jamroom on Friday February 09, 2018 @02:24PM (#16343091)
OK I'm feeling kind of dumb - let's say a car gets 20mpg - if we are emitting 411 grams of CO2 per mile that comes out to 8,220 grams of CO2 in that 20 miles, which is 18.1 pounds of CO2. How do we get 18.1 pounds of CO2 out of a gallon of gas that weighs 6 pounds?
Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by semi-extrinsic on Sunday February 11, 2018 @01:46PM (#16354064)
Not a stupid question, it's actually a common one.

The answer is that only the C in CO2 comes from gas, the O2 comes from the air.

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by titojankowski on Thursday February 08, 2018 @11:15AM (#16333152)
Good perspective! I hear you on people screaming and freaking out about climate, we have too many of those already.

That’s part of the inspiration for Carbon Doomsday. The skulls escalate it more to a Monty-python type of violence and humor. Tis but a scratch!

And in case you didn’t know, No One Gives a Fuck About Climate Change: http://titojankowski.com/no-one-gives-a-fck-about-climate-ch...

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by titojankowski on Thursday February 08, 2018 @01:44PM (#16334469)
Also this: http://blog.ycombinator.com/why-toys/

Climate change needs more toys

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by titojankowski on Thursday February 08, 2018 @11:18AM (#16333190)
Any suggestions for actions we can guide visitors towards? We’re a bunch of hackers and coders, and that’s who this site is for.

Maybe there’s other open source projects that need development help?

Re:Show HN: Carbon Doomsday – Graph and API of Earth's Carbo... by safiume on Thursday February 08, 2018 @06:52PM (#16336641)
Ok,today, Deep learning experts needed to help ONC meta1 project https://goo.gl/yutZP8 That's extending the sanity server and extracting relevant CO2 dissociation data. I intend to have it completed by next week's ONC meetup https://goo.gl/nz2wHr, and welcome additional help.