Re:A Developer’s Guide to Responding to National Security Le...
by themodelplumber on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @10:18PM
(#16322002)
You still haven't stated why an attorney is necessary...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A Developer’s Guide to Responding to National Security Le...
by geofft on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @10:32PM
(#16322060)
Because whether or not we like it, the law is non-obvious to people who haven't studied it deeply, this is a particularly non-obvious area of the law, and you will be better off with an expert.
Same reason you want to find someone who knows C very well to review your security-sensitive C code. It would be nice if C didn't come with rules about undefined behavior that are surprising to people who haven't deeply studied C, but it does, and no amount of wishing it didn't will change the fact that you are inviting immense and needless risk by not finding an expert (or, if you'd prefer, spending years becoming one yourself, which you can certainly do if you have the luxury of years).
Re:A Developer’s Guide to Responding to National Security Le...
by mirimir on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @10:30PM
(#16322047)
People need attorneys for DUIs, and often for less serious moving violations. So for NSLs, having an attorney is essential. There are two primary reasons. First, you want to comply only as legally required. And second, you want to avoid making mistakes that have criminal penalties.
Edit: Even if your firm has general counsel, it's not uncommon to hire outside attorneys for specific matters.
Re:A Developer’s Guide to Responding to National Security Le...
by wolco on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @11:24PM
(#16322231)
Some firms will pull the company lawyer and costs will be on you personally if you decide you need your own lawyer.
Re:A Developer’s Guide to Responding to National Security Le...
by mirimir on Wednesday February 07, 2018 @12:22AM
(#16322400)
There's some confusion here about what "you" means. I can't imagine how an individual developer at some firm would receive an NSL individually. So it's the firm that would be deciding whether or not to hire outside counsel.
Re:A Developer’s Guide to Responding to National Security Le...
by sseveran on Wednesday February 07, 2018 @09:18AM
(#16324512)
Of course. If you think you need a lawyer you want to be the one paying them. A company lawyer ultimately works for the company.
Re:A Developer’s Guide to Responding to National Security Le...
by debt on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @10:24PM
(#16322032)
Because the government has at its disposal many legal tools of which an individual developer may not be properly equipped or knowledgeable enough to deal with.
Subpoenas, search warrants, etc.