News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A letter to my students by pg on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:38PM (#1631732)
There are two ways CA could be doing less for its citizens. They could be raising less money, or spending it more wastefully. The writer seems to assume all the problems he observes are due to the former and none to the latter. The first step in verifying his claims would be to check whether the state's revenues are in fact lower.

Are current state revenues lower than revenues in, say, 1960, when adjusted for inflation?

Re:A letter to my students by patio11 on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:13PM (#1631794)
Using state figures and the CPI calculator:

1965-1966: $4B nominal ($28B, constant 2010 dollars)

1982-1983: $25.3B nominal ($57.2B)

2008-2009: $144B ($145)

2009-2010: $119.2B ($119.2B)

Even if you adjust for California's prodigious immigration-fueled population growth, spending per person in constant dollars has more than doubled.

You spent your school years with teachers paid less and less.

I feel the urge to get out numbers here, but it would be like shooting fish in a barrel.

Re:A letter to my students by tmsh on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:49PM (#1631879)
Actually, I think you have to go back further. My grandfather, a poor kid from west LA, went to UCLA and then UC Berkeley as an engineering student back in the late 1930s / early 1940s.

He learned Latin in high school (think inner city kid learning Latin). Grew up with all the airfields in LA and mechanical engineering seemed like the thing, I guess. So despite being interned (he was a Japanese American) he went on to be a very successful engineer and eventually businessman (owned his own hydraulics company, etc.).

It's arguable that a lot of this happened because of a golden age in California's educational system. Same thing with my parents. I've met them and they're idiots -- but at least my father benefited greatly from UC Berkeley (he's a philosophy professor).

I think PG is right to question what exactly is going on. But there really was an extraordinary investment in higher education (for whatever reason) in the early- to mid- 20th century. And arguably, that affected a lot of things which we Californians take for granted.

I think what the OP is trying to say is that our attitude about public education has changed. It was irrational, the level of investment that was made into higher education pre-1980s (both raising and allocating funds). And today's set of challenges may require a different emphasis (e.g., charter schools, leaner campuses, more online learning, etc.) -- but that generous spirit that, afaik, built California into a great state -- that's not worth overlooking.

Re:A letter to my students by Retric on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:33AM (#1632018)
If you want to see how CA as fucked themselves look at spending on prisons, pensions, and personnel.

Prisons (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_incarceration_timeline-... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Incarceration_rate_of_inma...) Just locking up all the bad people sounds like a great idea but it's also ridiculously expensive and provides little long term benefit.

Pensions without appropriate savings represent a huge drain on the government that "suddenly appears" (after 30+ years).

Personnel costs rise not just with inflation but with the completion from the local job market. Unfortunately for the state it can't reduce benefits when times get tough.

Re:A letter to my students by igravious on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:35AM (#1632191)
Pity you had to use such crude language while making your point. I'd like to see these figures per state. And then I'd like to see the percentage of the budget over time that is allocated to locking up citizens.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_criminal_justice_cost_t...

Re:A letter to my students by c1sc0 on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:17AM (#1632310)
Funny, I didn't notice that bad language at all until I re-read the comment.
Re:A letter to my students by duairc on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:43AM (#1632655)
Wow, I had to reread it at least 5 times before I noticed it. "Fucked" for some reason is much less offensive to me than other forms like "fucking"... not like that is extremely offensive either, but "fucked" doesn't even seem at all bad.
Re:A letter to my students by mkr-hn on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:36AM (#1632636)
I think it's a safe bet that anyone who finds themselves this deep in a site like HN is either an adult, or a kid with parents who give him/her a lot of freedom.
Re:A letter to my students by igravious on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:16PM (#1634619)
sigh Totally unexpected down-modding :) At the time I left this remark the commenter had only like 3 or 4 points and I was afraid that his use of the word "fuck" was causing his pertinent info to get overlooked. So I was trying to steer people towards this salient info regarding incarceration rates. I am not in the slightest bit offended by the language :) I was afraid others might be and was trying to offset that behaviour and I get modded down to the flames of hell and those who reply to me get tons of karma.

For fuck's sake, where's the justice? Anyway, the dudes now got over 30 points so maybe my heroic effort did not go in vain. On-topic: unjustly locking up a whole swathe of your citizen's has got to be a drain on resources. Compare US incarceration rates to most Western European countries and think about the consequences for a while.

Re:A letter to my students by rwl on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:38AM (#1632028)
but that generous spirit that, afaik, built California into a great state -- that's not worth overlooking

Exactly right; and that, not the numbers, is the point of the article.

Re:A letter to my students by speleding on Thursday August 26, 2010 @04:52AM (#1635422)
What's also missing from the picture is the comparative advantage that the US had in the fifties compared to the rest of the world (with Europe in shambles after WW II). Today it's a lot harder/more expensive to have the best educational system now that the others are doing a decent job again.
Re:A letter to my students by krschultz on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:04AM (#1632576)
It has not more than doubled. Don't throw around numbers if you haven't actually looked at them.

Population in 1960: 15,717,204 Population in 2010: 36,961,664

$28B for 15.7M people is $1783 per person $119B for 37.9M people is $3140 per person.

And the costs have increased far faster than inflation, so comparing constant dollars is not an apples to apples comparison. Inflation includes a lot of things, but not everything. The state spends a massive portion of its revenues on education and healthcare, those are two things notoriously increasing in price faster than inflation.

It is fashionable to be anti-government, but the the numbers don't seem that bad to me when you look at the whole picture.

Re:A letter to my students by patio11 on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:19AM (#1632879)
I did actually look at the population numbers but, inexplicably, just did a mental guesstimate rather than getting out my calculator or trusty paper. I apologize: it seems my mental guesstimate was on the wrong side of 2.
Re:A letter to my students by byrneseyeview on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:26PM (#1633305)
The state spends a massive portion of its revenues on education and healthcare, those are two things notoriously increasing in price faster than inflation.

I would assume that the government is disproportionately likely to spend on these categories. So isn't this another way to illustrate inefficiency? If there's a correlation between government being a customer, and prices rising while the quality of the end product drops, that sounds like one more argument in favor of lower spending.

Re:A letter to my students by etal on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:12PM (#1633654)
Those sectors are also much harder to automate, relative to the rest of the economy, since people want individual attention from doctors and teachers. So as the cost of everything else drops thanks to improved automation and technology, the proportion of our wealth that we spend on necessary but less-automated services increases.

(There's a term for this effect, but I'm having trouble finding it again.)

Re:A letter to my students by wvoq on Thursday August 26, 2010 @03:00PM (#1636827)
Cost disease.
Re:A letter to my students by etal on Thursday August 26, 2010 @03:35PM (#1636928)
Thanks!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease

Baumol's cost disease (also known as the Baumol Effect) [...] involves a rise of salaries in jobs that have experienced no increase of labor productivity in response to rising salaries in other jobs which did experience such labor productivity growth. [...]

Baumol's cost disease is often used to describe the lack of growth in productivity in public services such as public hospitals and state colleges. Since many public administration activities are heavily labor-intensive there is little growth in productivity over time because productivity gains come essentially from a better capital technology. As a result growth in the GDP will generate little more resources to be spent in public sector. Thus public sector production is more dependent on taxation level than growth in the GDP.

Re:A letter to my students by jbooth on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @03:26PM (#1633851)
That sounds like you're taking a favored conclusion and arguing backwards.

How many people have health insurance in the US?

How many of those are government employees? (Answer: far less than half)

Is the government running health insurance? (Answer: no).

EDIT: Wasn't trying to get too political on this. I just find the argument "the government buys some health insurance, so that's why it's expensive" outrageously unpersuasive.

Re:A letter to my students by jlangenauer on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @06:50AM (#1632483)
I can't speak for California, but certainly here in Australia, there's been one factor increasing the cost of higher education: the rise of a managerial class within universities, who cost plenty but whose contribution to education and research is questionable.

It'd be almost impossible to quantify - and it is probably only one of several factors - but the take-home point is that increased spending isn't necessarily an indicator of better education.

Re:A letter to my students by ahi on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:57AM (#1632982)
I am non-faculty/research staff at a state school in the US. I agree. Faculty positions get cut or shifted to adjuncts and lecturers while managers who spend most of their time managing other managers keep getting their 5%.
Re:A letter to my students by sabat on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @05:12PM (#1634175)
Absolutely the same case in California. Along with other corporate giveaways and general waste. And no one willing to take responsibility for getting rid of it -- they're too busy making deals with the beneficiaries.
Re:A letter to my students by jerf on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:37PM (#1631842)
Budget chart: http://www.dof.ca.gov/budgeting/budget_faqs/information/docu...

It's from a ca.gov domain, so I'm not sure it gets much more authoritative.

You can do your own analysis, but one snapshot would be 137B total spent in 2000-1 to 200B total spent in 2010-11. I chose to include federal funds on the grounds that for the topic in question, that would seem the relevant measure since a lot of those federal funds lately have been for public services, the topic in discussion. http://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl shows the inflation rate across that time frame as a 1.27 multiple, vs. a 1.46 multiple in California spending.

You can make the numbers somewhat worse by using 2009-2010's expenditures of 221B; how fair you think that is is up to the reader, I guess. Given that our author probably still thinks that's not enough, arguably that would be a more fair demonstration of what is still apparently not enough money.

Re:A letter to my students by Locke1689 on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:46PM (#1631862)
So I went ahead and did a calculation of my own: revenue by all taxes per capita in the state of California between 2005 and 1964.

All following figures are from US census data:

  Total revenue from all taxes per capita 1964: $2182.85 (helpfully provided by the 1964 census).
  Total revenue from all taxes 2005: $146,692,000,000
  Total resident population of California, 2005: 36,250,000
  Total revenue from all taxes per capita 2005: $4,046.68
1964 number is also adjusted using the CPI calculator
Re:A letter to my students by Locke1689 on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:06AM (#1632154)
I'd just like to point out to people reading this (since one commenter already said something then deleted his comment), that I am actually very liberal. I strongly believe in the fundamental role of the government in the welfare of the nation and I also strongly believe that we should be taxed for the money that's needed to make that happen.

HOWEVER, what I will never do is frame statistics or data just to fit my argument better. I was curious about this statistic (I don't really believe this tiny bit of data is really evidence for any drastic response) and decided to do the grunt work with the past US census data to satisfy my curiosity, whatever the results.

Also, the US census papers look way better in 1964 than they do in 2005. I think the 2005 documents may have a more legible typeface but it certainly makes me go "ugh." The margins are very bad in the '05 docs, too.

Re:A letter to my students by stevoski on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @07:31AM (#1632527)
I think you should be looking at revenue by taxes as a % of GDP, rather than in $ terms. Real GDP per person is much higher in CA today than in 1964. Did government spending increase relative to the size of the economy? Or decrease?
Re:A letter to my students by Locke1689 on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @07:02PM (#1634450)
I think that's a good point. The increase should be compared to the increase in GDP, the increase in the workforce (women working) and a number of other variables. I'm swamped as it is, maybe you want to do those calculations? ;)
Re:A letter to my students by _delirium on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:24PM (#1631822)
Those nominal budget figures vary widely from the actual budgets, though, and how much varies year to year. For example, the 2009 nominal budget is indeed $119.2b, but 2009 state revenue and expenditures are somewhere around $450b. I suppose an interesting question would be whether on versus off-budget spending was a similar or different ratio in 1965.
Re:A letter to my students by eli on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:51PM (#1631961)
So is the implication that the state has grown much more wasteful in its spending over the last few decades?

If you've got a plan for providing the level of services from the 60s without raising taxes, I'd love to see the details. (Consider pension and healthcare costs now versus then, even accounting for inflation)

Re:A letter to my students by ataggart on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:42AM (#1632038)
Pension and health care outlays are not exogenous givens. The economy is not some external entity which government passively receives prices. Likewise the recession is not some external thing that can be waited-out like a hurricane. Our actions, and particularly those of that blunt club called government, entirely affects what emerges from the market making up the economy.
Re:A letter to my students by eli on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:36AM (#1632637)
That's easy to say, but what specifically do you suggest they do about it? Given where we are right now (and setting aside CA's ridiculous laws regarding how they can reallocate their budget), what would you change to free up hundreds of billions of dollars without raising taxes?

Take over healthcare and beat back prices? Hey, I'm all for it, but I think that's gonna cost more in the short term.

Re:A letter to my students by ataggart on Thursday August 26, 2010 @02:15PM (#1636707)
>Take over healthcare and beat back prices?

I guess you didn't really grok my point about prices not being exogenous entities.

Re:A letter to my students by elai on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:25AM (#1632099)
Repair the bugs in the american health care system? Americans spend more per capita yet get worse services.
Re:A letter to my students by uxp on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @02:52AM (#1632204)
I'm pretty sure that's working as intended. Might be better off loosening restrictions on how health care providers operate so they can work it out themselves.

On a more serious note, there isn't one solution. There are hundreds of thousands of ways to spend less and bring more money in. It took this country, and that state, a few decades to get into that mess. It will probably take just as long to get back to the prosperity the 40's and 50's were known for.

Re:A letter to my students by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:38AM (#1632640)
Do you have evidence for worse services?

(E.g., something like higher post-diagnosis death rates for statistically comparable people?)

Re:A letter to my students by elai on Friday August 27, 2010 @12:06PM (#1639191)
They often just get refused service, even after paying way more.
Re:A letter to my students by protomyth on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:27AM (#1633087)
Sadly, the US Gov is going to make it worse. Go look at the budget for Indian Health Service versus the number of people served, then expand that to cover all Americans. For a bonus, check the level of service compared to the private sector.

It probably would have been cheaper to allow people to have real personal health savings accounts and provide a "last-resort" insurance that pays everything over some amount ($100K perhaps). That last bit probably would bring down premiums because of a max risk.

Re:A letter to my students by SolarUpNote on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:31PM (#1631942)
Wolfram Alpha should come in handy here: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=california+population
Re:A letter to my students by mkr-hn on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:44AM (#1632657)
I've been running all over the place for graphs over the last week for different things, and that site never occurred to me.

Thanks for the reminder.

Re:A letter to my students by DanielN on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:33PM (#1631945)
Looking for answers in such macro terms is probably not an effective response to the problems posed in the article.

What would likely be more effective would be data on changes in teacher salaries over time, changes in administrator salary over time, etc.

This makes a huge difference in the argument if for no other reason than that the increase in revenue over time has been due to increased services (not necessarily relating to the betterment of the state or its educational systems) rather than the deepening of the pockets of existing services in 1964.

Re:A letter to my students by avdempsey on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:07PM (#1631782)
According to Prop 13 grand-daddy Howard Jarvis, state revenues have indeed increased since Prop 13 passed (1978).

We have a heckavu budget morass in California. Our ballot initiative democracy has _written into the constitution_ both spending minimums (40% of general budget from Prop 98) for education, and tax maximums. It's a massive vote of no confidence to strip our legislatures of the working room to make a budget.

I'm going to agree with the letter here. Somehow, in California in the 60s, we decided as a state to build the world's best civil infrastructure. We (well my grandparents) built this to benefit residents statewide. The terms of debate have changed from what makes the best place to live, to fear or sounds-nice-but-not-right-nowism.

From 2/3s majorities, to social issues, to pensions, we're in a real hole. But a rebuilt civil infrastructure is necessary, decline is obvious.

Re:A letter to my students by _delirium on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:04PM (#1631775)
Not an answer, but you should probably adjust by some sort of CA wage index rather than purely inflation, since a lot of things the government pays for have grown more expensive much faster than inflation (like salaries of sysadmins, and land). Looking at revenues as a percentage of state GDP would be one approximation (that would also bake in a correction for population growth).

I do think it's likely they haven't decreased greatly, though--- imo a bigger factor has been that where the money is spent has shifted greatly (less on education, more on cops and prisons, for example).

Re:A letter to my students by ohyes on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:13AM (#1631991)
His claim is that California is bottom of the barrel WRT the amount of money that it is reinvesting in its education system. (Hence the 'prime the pump' analogy)... This is true:

http://www.statemaster.com/graph/edu_ele_sec_fin_cur_exp_per...

To turn this into a 'low taxes vs high taxes' debate is kind of deceptive. I think that the point about taxes is that the debate around taxes has essentially become petty and mean-spirited.

If a politician wants to raise taxes (in any way, even on the wealthiest 1 or .1%, who would barely notice), countless will bitch about it, without regard for data or reason (or common sense). It will be a knee jerk reaction.

WRT to his assumptions, I don't think that he is assuming that California is not spending its money wastefully (see his mention of the penal system). There is an argument to be made, however, that it is incredibly difficult to reclaim wasteful spending that has already been done. (California is not going to pardon 60% of its prison population and close its prisons or cancel state pensions).

So the expedient solution, if you believe in spending more on education and social services, would be to tax more. (but no politician in their right mind would say that).

Re:A letter to my students by moron4hire on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @08:00AM (#1632569)
The fundamental problem is that everyone has only ever focused on expedient solutions.
Re:A letter to my students by ohyes on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @11:51AM (#1633178)
I think that there is a distinction to be made here between /politically/ expedient solutions, and expedient solutions with regards to actual goals.

The war on drugs, high incarceration rates, and trumpeting an ideology of low taxes are all politically expedient, but not necessarily expedient with regard to what we actually want to achieve.

In an optimization problem, a nearest neighbor algorithms will generally produce a sub-optimal, but okay result.

This is only true, however, if your nearest neighbor algorithm is using the correct selection heuristic... Garbage in, garbage out.

Our political system needs a new heuristic.

(Assuming P!=NP, and that the governance of California is an NP hard optimization problem...)

Re:A letter to my students by bokonist on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:13PM (#1631795)
According to this source of unknown reliability ( http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/California_state_spendin... ) state & local spending as a percentage of state nominal GDP went from 20% to 24% from 1992 to 2009. Don't know the numbers going back to 1960, but I'd be shocked if spending was lower then.

For the change in average levels of education and knowledge, the cause seems pretty obvious to me. If you extended the border of California 400 miles south into Mexico, the average state scores on tests of math, history, and English would obviously go down, simply because of the composition of the population. Similarly, if you move 10 million Mexicans into California, the average test scores of the people living within the borders of California will fall (even if there is no change in the amount of learning for one individual person). In general if you look into correlations between education spending and test scores, there is very little correlation. If you look into the correlation of ethnicity and test scores, its very significant.

Re:A letter to my students by mkr-hn on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:22PM (#1631817)
Here's an excerpt from the bio of the guy who runs the site: "Despite 35 years living in Seattle, I instinctively revolted against the suffocating left-coast culture of the Soviet of Washington, and came to revere the four great Germans who helped inspire the Reagan revolution: Ludwig von Mises, F.A. Hayek, Leo Strauss, and Eric Voegelin."

However, he does link to real government sources (near the botton), so you can check to see if he weighs by ideology when posting numbers.

Re:A letter to my students by yummyfajitas on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:53PM (#1631884)
I applaud you for making an observation which could easily fuel an ad-hominem attack on an obvious partisan, and then holding back after observing that regardless of his biases, he is just tabulating official numbers.
Re:A letter to my students by mkr-hn on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @09:14AM (#1632724)
When I see source and unknown reliability in the same post, my instinct is to check and make sure the person who said it knows where to find the tools to make that judgment on their own.

Sometimes they end up in disagreement with me, but I always prefer informed and still wrong to uninformed and wrong[1]. :)

[1]Which is not to say these numbers are wrong or right. I'm speaking generally.

Re:A letter to my students by neeson on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:52PM (#1631882)
To rephrase what you just said: Mexicans, because of their ethnicity, are less able to understand (for instance) mathematics, even when given the same amount of instruction, than people of the ethnicities that characterize the population of California circa the 1960s (i.e. predominantly white). Did I get that right?
Re:A letter to my students by bokonist on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:02PM (#1631893)
Mexicans in general score lower on tests of English and math, both in Mexico and America. See for one example: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0883611.html#axzz0xaC7EpRR This data is well known and not-controversial. The reasons for the test score disparity are quite controversial.

My point is simple. You have a group A of 10 million that on average score 450 on the math SAT. You have a group B of 10 milllion that score 500 on average. If you randomly move 5 million from group A to group B, then statistically, the average score of group B will fall to ~481.

Re:A letter to my students by neeson on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:18PM (#1631924)
Thank you for the numbers. Point well made.
Re:A letter to my students by lzw on Saturday August 28, 2010 @01:55PM (#1642075)
Ah, and a racist troll to boot! Hilarious!
Re:A letter to my students by erikpukinskis on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:52PM (#1631883)
In general if you look into correlations between education spending and test scores, there is very little correlation. If you look into the correlation of ethnicity and test scores, its very significant.

Good job, you just discovered that our standardized tests scores are biased in favor of white kids.

Re:A letter to my students by gwern on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:21AM (#1632005)
Which is why those ethnicities then go on to have perfect 4.0 GPAs and rack up countless patents & inventions and start tons of successful new companies, thus proving those standardized tests wrong in the most effective way possible.
Re:A letter to my students by kenjackson on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:30AM (#1632901)
Accept of course those standardized tests are the gatekeepers to the best schools, best programs, best networks, and likely even confidence and motivation.

A better way to show that standardized tests mean nothing is to have every student take them, but then store them away for the next 40 years. No one knows the results. And then in 40 years correlate the results of these tests with "life success". We've already seen with one similar measure "IQ test", which has little bearing on academic placement, that it turns out to have very little utility in predicting "life success". UPDATE: Link on IQ -- http://www.halfsigma.com/2006/06/high_iq_does_no.html

Re:A letter to my students by gwern on Thursday August 26, 2010 @02:16AM (#1635224)
Any of which should only reduce the magnitude of the ethnicities' outperformance. Not eliminate it entirely. You don't need to go to Harvard to start Apple or Dell or Google. (To give an analogy, Asians are heavily discriminated against in higher ed; but when I look around, it seems to me that unlike blacks, they outperform.)
Re:A letter to my students by kenjackson on Friday August 27, 2010 @01:22PM (#1639441)
Yet none of those companies were founded even by poor white youths, much less black youths (even white females). Apple, founded by Jobs, who did an internship at HP as a high school student, and attended Reed. Google by Stanford grad students, Dell, son of a doctor and stockbroker, who went to UT Austin. Microsoft, two Harvard students.

The problem is that a young black kid raised where many are raised, SAT scores not withstanding, likely won't have the opportunities that those I listed had. Let me give a glimpse of Michael Dell's early life, from Wikipedia: "The son of an orthodontist and a stockbroker, Dell attended Herod Elementary School in Houston, Texas. In a bid to enter business early, he applied to take a high school equivalency exam at age eight. In his early teens, he invested his earnings from part-time jobs in stocks and precious metals. Dell purchased his first calculator at age seven and encountered his first teletype machine in junior high, which he programmed after school."

If you go into the inner-cities, this type of early life, even from the bright and ambitious will likely look very different.

And lastly, Asians are disciminated against in a very different way than Blacks are. They are discriminated in the belief that they excel at math and engineering. I've seen first hand, in elementary school, how powerful expectations are (and there is good data around this too).

Re:A letter to my students by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:17PM (#1633449)
You are lying with statistics, albeit possibly unknowingly.

That article comes right out and says that IQ does not have an effect on life outcomes, if life outcomes are normed for educational attainment. It then goes on to say that IQ does not predict career success, if career success is measured by money and normed for career type. That's like saying air temperature has no effect on snow cover, if snow cover is corrected for season. And altitude.

Re:A letter to my students by kenjackson on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:33PM (#1633503)
And of course, no argument is complete with an anecdotal Feynman story.

Two grad students at CalTech were having a discussion about what Feynman's IQ must be. They bandied 180... maybe even to 200. When coincidentally Feynman walks right past them.

One of the students pipes up and meekly asks Feynman, "Professor Feynman, what is your IQ?"

Feynman turns around and responds, "120". The grad students have a look of disbelief. To which Feynman adds, "but its all in Physics".

Re:A letter to my students by gwern on Thursday August 26, 2010 @02:12AM (#1635215)
I have previously addressed the issue of Feynman's IQ: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1251164
Re:A letter to my students by kenjackson on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:27PM (#1633484)
Actually the analogy you made is very appropriate. If you do control for season and altitude, and snow cover is not correlated with temperature still, you have a problem.

But sticking with just the article. The point he makes is that its the educational attainment that people pay for, not the IQ score. Now you're saying, "But educational attainment is a product of IQ score". Possibly, but in controlling that factor you can attempt to tease out the extent at which it really is the educational attainment rather than simply the IQ.

A better way to put is that if IQ was in itself the key to life success then it wouldn't matter if you went to college or not. Rather, what the data seems to show is that those with high IQs seem to at least have the wisdom to know that educational attainment will be the key their life success. Quite possibly being tracked into by virtue of a higher IQ.

BUT the data should show that regardless of credential, higher IQ yields more success. But it doesn't show that.

Now there are a lot of factors that potentially come into play. And that was my original point. One can't look at SAT scores and then say, "those with high SAT scores do better in life", when there are so many comingling factors that complicate the equation, and are ridiculously difficult to control for in the real world.

Re:A letter to my students by JabavuAdams on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @09:34AM (#1632769)
Don't get distracted. I suspect that you would find an even stronger correlation with "home culture", but that's too hard to define and to measure.

Any ethnicity can have a scholarly culture, but for people starting out at the bottom, in a new society, it's less common.

There's also a selection bias against those who have not moved up in society. E.g. take a depressed area -- if the people with the gumption to improve their situation do so and leave, what's left? Right, concentrated fail.

Re:A letter to my students by harshpotatoes on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:55PM (#1631968)
That of course assumes that the money needed provide the same services for the people grows at the same rate as the population growth. In other words, the cost per person might actually be significantly lower to provide services for 1million people than it would be to provide services for 20 million people. And maybe this isn't due to a government 'inefficiency' (mismanagement of funds), but rather an inefficiency that is inherent in the design of our cities and services (Meaning: Long term problem requiring redesign of many services in order to increase spending efficiency).

So really, I think it's far more important to question: 1) How has the cost for these public services scaled with the population in the past? 2) Based on that, how do I think the cost of the these public services scale with the population in the foreseeable future? 3) Is this increase in expenditure due to wasteful mismanagement of funds, or a design problem in our cities and services?

Re:A letter to my students by 3d3mon on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:03AM (#1632296)
If you try your hand at this "armchair budget analyst" game, you'll learn that its easier practically and politically (yes, politically) to just raise the money, especially in a state like CA:

http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-statebudget-fl,0,95571....

To be fair, the CA real estate boom/bust really did a number on the state's coffers. To ignore the impact of the "great recession" is to not see the problem accurately. The govt relied on increasing property tax revenue that disappeared as quickly as the monopoly money used to pay for it (aka subprime loans) and on state income taxes and sales taxes from workers who quickly lost their real estate bubble jobs. If those workers still had their jobs and homeowners still had their homes, we'd find something else to complain about. Moral of the story is be careful when playing with credit.

Re:A letter to my students by kds on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @05:20AM (#1632401)
Not just less or more inflation-adjusted revenues and their spending as absolute sums - the per-capita values impacted by the population growth would be even more informative.
Re:A letter to my students by mkr-hn on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:55PM (#1631761)
I don't know much about economics, so I'm probably missing something obvious. How is revenue linked to how much a government is doing for its people?
Re:A letter to my students by achompas on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:59PM (#1631768)
Government revenue (usually: taxes) funds the services governments provide for its people.

Example: USPS has seen slow/negative net revenue growth, so they're considering cutting Saturday service.

Re:A letter to my students by mkr-hn on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:03PM (#1631773)
That much I knew. But my thinking was that the amount spent and how was a better indicator. If they bring in $5000 in revenue and buy $5000 in golden toilet seats, it's not being spent well.

But if that $5000 is going to needed books for schools, it's good.

Re:A letter to my students by barrkel on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:28PM (#1631829)
It's only good if the books are genuinely worth $5000. That was one of the interesting things that came up with Feynman's time vetting school books in California:

http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm

At first we weren't supposed to talk about the cost of the books. We were told how many books we could choose, so we designed a program which used a lot of supplementary books, because all the new textbooks had failures of one kind or another.

[...]

[During my time on the commission,] there were two books that we were unable to come to a decision about after much discussion; they were extremely close. So we left it open to the Board of Education to decide. Since the board was now taking the cost into consideration, and since the two books were so evenly matched, the board decided to open the bids and take the lower one.

Mr. Norris, the Pasadena lawyer on the board, asked the guy from the other publisher, "And how much would it cost for us to get your books at the earlier date?"

And he gave a number: It was less!

The first guy got up: "If he changes his bid, I have the right to change my bid!" -- and his bid is still less!

Norris asked, "Well how is that -- we get the books earlier and it's cheaper?"

"Yes," one guy says. "We can use a special offset method we wouldn't normally use . . ." -- some excuse why it came out cheaper. The other guy agreed: "When you do it quicker, it costs less!"

That was really a shock. It ended up two million dollars cheaper. Norris was really incensed by this sudden change.

Re:A letter to my students by achompas on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:11PM (#1631790)
Agreed. But given that 49 out of 50 states were struggling to fall under budget this past year, we can safely say they're cutting the useful stuff now.

Great anecdote from NY State on a recent episode of This American Life ("Social Contract"): Arizona sold their state capitol to cover costs, and now pays rent to use the building.

Re:A letter to my students by pmb on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:12PM (#1631792)
States can't run a deficit. Money in can never be greater than money out.
Re:A letter to my students by mkr-hn on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:17PM (#1631803)
I don't think I'm being as clear as I should be. I'll see if I can rephrase it tomorrow. Trying to think economics at this time of night often proves hazardous for me. :)
Re:A letter to my students by Retric on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @10:19AM (#1632880)
That ignores unfunded liabilities. A state can easily under fund a pension system.
Re:A letter to my students by eli on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:55PM (#1631967)
I think this is actually a much less helpful question than you think it is. For a lot of reasons, outside factors made things like real estate and healthcare a lot more expensive for the state of california. I don't see any evidence that CA is any more wasteful than it was 40 years ago.

Or, put another way, where exactly do you see an extra $100B in CA's budget?

Re:A letter to my students by joe_the_user on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:54PM (#1631964)
I believe California currently spends a similar amount on prisons as on education. I don't believe that was the case in 1962.

That would effect total spending. Whether that means California is doing more for its citizens in this way is a question one can ask.

Re:A letter to my students by callmeed on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:38AM (#1632118)
Err, not even close:

9.6% of the general fund on corrections/rehab programs

43.4% on K-12 education

14.3% on higher education

http://www.ebudget.ca.gov/pdf/BudgetSummary/SummaryCharts.pd...

Re:A letter to my students by joe_the_user on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:23PM (#1634023)
So prisons are merely approaching the cost of higher education, sorry. (9.6% versus 14.3%).
Re:A letter to my students by callmeed on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @04:52PM (#1634109)
How do you know it's approaching? Higher education is 50% higher but I don't know if corrections is growing at a faster rate.
Re:A letter to my students by aliston on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @03:53AM (#1632279)
I've heard this point made on a per-individual basis. The numbers I found actually make it look even worse:

California per-pupil spending 2008: $9,015 California’s Annual Costs to Incarcerate an Inmate in Prison: $47,102

http://blogs.sacbee.com/the-public-eye/2010/08/california-pe... http://www.lao.ca.gov/laoapp/laomenus/sections/crim_justice/...

Re:A letter to my students by hugh3 on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @12:51PM (#1633371)
California per-pupil spending 2008: $9,015 California’s Annual Costs to Incarcerate an Inmate in Prison: $47,102

Why should those be, in any way, comparable?

Prisoners need cells, three meals a day, healthcare, clothing, and constant supervision, 24 hours a day. Schoolchildren only need classrooms and supervision for six hours a day five days a week. And prisons can't get away with a 30:1 inmate-to-guard ratio, either. It makes perfect sense that a prisoner should cost more than a schoolkid.

Of course I'm sure California prison guards are still ridiculously overpaid. My personal solution to this conundrum is to outsource California's prisons to Mexico.

Re:A letter to my students by lutorm on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @03:15PM (#1633821)
Of course it's reasonable that prisons are more expensive on a per capita basis. The real question is which of those are most const-effective in making CA a better place to live. Putting all those people in prison was a choice.
Re:A letter to my students by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @01:22AM (#1632093)
Apparently this professor is better acquainted with the definition of the word posterity than Paul Carr. Thanks again for pointing that out the other day.
Re:A letter to my students by nanospider on Wednesday August 25, 2010 @09:06AM (#1632709)
Looks like there's a Ycombinator startup idea in here somewhere!